7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models Film Characters

7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models

Molly Mahan Molly Mahan Ranker
Staff
286,630 views 7 items
The Princesses in Disney films are some of the most popular characters in the world. Little girls everywhere have at one time or another wanted to grow up to be one of the princesses. From singing songs with cute animals to some day marrying prince charming while wearing their amazing wedding gown. Snow White, Belle, Jasmine, Cinderella and the rest are considered role models, but has anyone taken the time to look behind the doe eyes and the catchy songs? Could it be that these adored characters are nothing more than anti-feminist propaganda? This list will show some reasons that you might not want your little girl to grow up to be a Disney Princess.

The Disney Princesses used in this list are the current lineup of "official" Disney princesses. Other Disney heroines like Alice (Alice in Wonderland), Princess Kida (Atlantis: The Lost Empire), Nala (The Lion King), etc. have not been reviewed, so please do not feel slighted because Megara or Esmeralda did not make the list and you believe they are worse role models than those present.

And just in case you think it couldn't get any worse, check out Ranker's list of Racist Disney Cartoons.
< >
Show:   5   25 View:
More Options
  1. Princess Ariel



    Now, Ariel certainly is strong willed, but she is hardly independent. This does not a strong, independent woman make.

    She wants to leave the sea, which is ruled by her caring, land-loathing father, to go on land to marry some guy she doesn’t know a thing about, who rules some little principality in whatever European country that’s supposed to be. Her station isn’t going to change. It’s not like she wants legs to become a dealer of rare and collectible forks. No, she wants legs to try and bang some dude she doesn’t even know who makes a hobby of feeding on some of her best friends in hopes that life on land will somehow be better than being the most beloved princess in the ocean. Hell, the whole message of "Part of That World" is about how her life is perfect under the sea, but that just isn’t enough for her.


    "I wanna be, where the yogurt is..."


    Further, to get those legs, Ariel has to sell her voice (the original Hans Christian Andersen story tells us mermaids don’t have souls) and the sea-witch Ursula even tells her how useless a voice is for a woman in "winning" a man, anyway. Her body is supposed to be her key to his heart, not her thoughts or vocal ability (how was she to know Eric had a thing for sopranos?). It’s to be a romance based in nothing but how pretty each person is to the other.


    "I got him the only way us girls can. With my looks."


    Now, if Ariel actually knew a thing about Prince Eric other than the fact that he likes boats and is handsome (as hell), then I’d be all for their star-crossed romance.

    Instead, we’re given a heroine who tells her family (who all love and support her) to F-off and sells her voice to a witch to have a chance to be with some guy she doesn’t even know.

    Impetuous and passionate, sure. But a good decision maker? Not in the least. Is this a case of spare the trident, spoil the child, or did I just want to squeeze that sentence into this list?
  2. Belle



    Belle is usually the number one princess of choice among intellectual women. She reads, she thinks, she's poor and somehow isn't a servant and she has a strong relationship with her father that isn’t borderline creepy.

    She seems like a well-developed character, which is what makes her story the most destructive of them all.

    Belle is a woman who longs for adventure and yearns to make her life better. She wants to leave her small town to find a life worth living and a man worth loving, because that he-man misogynistic hunk of a hunter named Gaston just doesn’t cut it for her.

    Sadly, her plans are derailed when her father, in hopes to make their lives better, leaves her to enter his wood chopping machine into the local fair.

    After leaving for a few hours, his horse Philippe returns without him. Worried, she has Philippe take her to him. They find him locked in a cell in an otherwise seemingly abandoned castle. When accosted by The Beast, she suggests that her life be traded for her father’s. The Beast agrees and that’s the end of act 1. We're good so far. But then comes Act 2...

    Act 2 is dedicated to everyone in the castle trying to make Belle fall in love with the Beast, so she can break the spell. It’s basically a manipulation game where the Beast tries to act civilized to win the heart of the cultured peasant. And he wins, but in winning he is also changed—not just physically from a monster into a man, but within.


    "Why are we fighting bro? She's just a stupid girl."


    At the beginning of the film, The Beast and Gaston are exactly the same person. They are both chauvinist assholes who don’t care about anyone but themselves and wager a woman’s worth based on her body. It is the Beast’s ability to change or, rather, Belle’s ability to change the Beast that turns him into the character that we love. And that is the problem with Belle and the movie: It teaches women that they can effectively change the man that they love into the person they want him to be; or, conversely, that you should change to be with the person you love.

    While I’m all for men not being assholes and becoming decent human beings, the message that it’s a woman who causes the change is definitely dangerous. Using a woman who is awesome and interesting as the vehicle of this message is additionally dangerous as any woman who thinks herself deserving of a decent man but has a propensity for dating assholes may believe they can follow Belle’s route of changing men, but unless her person of interest has a horrifying curse affecting him, the change isn’t likely going happen.

    So, in the meantime, love the one you’re with and don’t expect change (and more importantly, don't expect them to change. If you're with them, you obviously like them, so actually you should be hoping even harder than they don't change. You’re not a Disney princess and your life isn’t scripted in the manner of a fairytale. /toughlove
  3. Cinderella



    So, she meets the prince, whirlwind romance, midnight strikes and she flees the scene.

    We all know the story. But the thing that I never understood about the story is those damn glass slippers: why didn’t they return to whatever matter they came from? The carriage returns to a pumpkin, the princess is once again a bumpkin, and yet the glass remains in slipper form. And what kind of a woman wears a glass slipper? Standard heels scare me enough, the chance that I might slip and it’ll shatter and tear my Achilles tendon does not do anything for me, but I’m obviously no princess. But you see, neither was she, until she got a little help from a portly old blue fairy woman.

    Aside from constantly cleaning the house, putting up with three bitches and having
    rodent friends, Cinderella’s life wasn’t too bad. She lived without any sense of eminent danger, and she has a Fairy Godmother. Though, she doesn’t know that until she wants to go to the royal ball. Seriously, where has that tart been all her life?


    "No, Cinderella, I wasn’t here because cooking and cleaning without talking back are all necessary skills you will need in life."


    But once that wicked stepmother cock blocks Cinderella from meeting Prince Charming? You better f*cking believe the Fairy Godmother is going to appear and bibbity-bobbity-boo the hell out of the situation to ensure that Cinderella gets her chance at some royal sausage.

    Again, girls, do your chores and get married. Aspire to nothing else.

    At least she and Prince Charming had some fine conversation for, what, five minutes at that royal ball, right? Enough to leave an impression that separated her from the other fine vixens of the kingdom.
  4. Princess Aurora



    Sleeping Beauty is the last princess movie to have had Walt Disney’s personal hand all up on it.

    She’s a princess who doesn’t know she’s a princess and therefore has no aspirations besides meeting other humans—preferably male humans.

    After 15 years of seeing animals bang in the woods, Briar Rose sings a little ditty called "I Wonder" where she basically mourns the fact that all the lady animals are getting some from their male cohorts and she hasn’t laid eyes upon a man in the entirety of her life.

    In fact, the only other people she knows are 3 fairies masquerading as humans to take care of her.


    "She wants us to do what?"


    She’s so lonely, in fact, that she creates an imaginary "dream prince" and the animals play along (the owl acting as the prince, of course).

    While they’re dancing and singing, however, a real prince comes along and starts dancing with her. This startles Briar Rose until Philip’s smooth line of, "We’ve met before … once upon a dream" wins her over.

    Yeah, nothing like telling a poor, desperate girl that you’re her dream prince to get some.

    It actually makes me wonder if the entirety of Sleeping Beauty happens in Briar Rose’s head (and how awesome, albeit f*cked up, would that be?). A girl so desperate for love, she'd rather sleep and dream of imaginary princes than live a life on her own, be it within the forest or outside.

    She spends more time imagining what she wants than she does actually trying to achieve it. There are few other characters that could potentially inspire girls to be lazy, submissive, inside-the-box thinkers than Sleeping Beauty.
  5. Princess Tiana



    Tiana is a character of high merit, despite looking exactly like Belle with a separate color pallet.

    She’s the first (and so far only) princess from the modern age of sub-Saharan descent.

    She’s also the first official Disney princess to actually have and hold a job. Granted, she’s the first (historically speaking) heroine of this lineup who lives in a time when a woman holding down a job that isn’t model or governess wouldn’t necessarily be a bad thing.

    Nevertheless, she’s a woman who can take care of herself and follow her own goals with or without a man, which is a good thing, because she’s also, regrettably, the first princess whose prince is completely incompetent.

    Like Briar Rose, Tiana has no need or desire to become a princess. She only wants to fulfill her dead father’s dream of opening a restaurant (a little Elektra complex never hurt
    anyone). It is actually the prince who is desperately trying to find a mate in this film. Prince Naveen comes to the US of A in search of a wealthy woman to marry because he is now penniless and unable to take care of himself. He has no skills or trade, aside from making women fawn over him. Tiana, in fact, is repulsed by him, until long after they are both stuck with each other in frog form, while trying to regain their human bodies. It’s a union that comes from a shared suffering rather than love; in the vein of, "yeah, I’ll marry you if you’re the last man on earth."


    "Yes, I’ll marry you, if by some freak occurrence we both turn into amphibians and the only way I can have sex and it NOT be weird/physically impossible is with you."


    It’s disappointing that such a revolutionary character in the Disney princess line up is put together with a chump. He is the fool to Tiana’s straight man, screwing up her well played plans, teaching young girls that they don't need an equal, but a man who happens to treat them well that they can nurture and take care of for the rest of their lives.

items 1 - 5 of 7

leave a comment

comments powered by Disqus
  1. Pura Uselman
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 2/18/2013 12:30 AM
    admirable bad disney princesses thing here.
  2. rockinrobyn
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 1/18/2013 12:30 PM
    disney princesses that make the worst role models , gals!
  3. Sabrina
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/30/2012 4:23 AM
    I honestly think this article is ridiculous, Disney princesses were created to be something entertaining and fun for little kids and adults alike. Each one was actually an adaptation of a classic fairytale. So no, Disney did not make these to be "bad examples", and every little girl who watches them isn't going to look for the barely existent subliminal messages and the fact that anyone had the time to break down classic Disney movies this way needs to find some thing else to do with their lives. Your completely focusing on the negative and ignoring any positive message in these movies.
  4. Breanna
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/24/2012 9:04 PM
    i think you're going overborad with some of these. You have to remember that alot of these princesses were made in a certain time period where the veiws of women were in the kitchen, smily face, and inactive. I'm not saying that it's right but that was how it was back then when Walt was alive. With Jasmine you also have to think about the times the movie is SET in. Women were not allowed to be heirs only the first born son and if not that a uncle or cousin. Jasmine didn't give up any of her dreams if you watch Aladdin the TV series or the tow movies after this you're see that Jasmine goes on many adventures even more than Ariel. With Snow White she was already written as a innocent naive person. in the original book she was a seven year old girl, just a kid. In this Snow is only 13 still a kid. Fairy Tales are suppose to teach a lesson and in the Snow White tale the lesson to kids is to not talk to strangers and be good. Snow HAS to be stupid and eat the apple because she is the image of what parents don't want their kids to do. Her death is suppose to happen so kids will be scared and not talk to strangers.
  5. what were you thinking, Disney?!
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/05/2012 7:30 AM
    whoah! give me a five man! i agree with you TOTALLY! (although i haven't realised all this before.
  6. Katie Marie
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/01/2012 12:27 AM
    This atricle digusts me. I am an anti-feminist woman and proud of it. I wish life were simpiler and wasn't full of brats (aka FEMINISTS) that have this idea that they're somehow better than men. They try to rub that into our kid's brains, and do you know what that does? It creates a generation of girls who are just plain BULLIES, feel the need to brag, and who are very very very very very very (shall i go on?) very very ANONOYING and LOUD for no reason! It creates a generation of men who are weak willed and feel the need to sit back and be uncaring about anything in life. But thats what the BRATS wanted, wasn't it? I am 13 years old and i hate feminists! I am Catholic too and i am DIGUSTED by the opionions those pests (yes, you saw that) give out. Somehow, they think that abortion is OK because its 'their baby', 'thier choice'. Let me tell you something all you stupid feminists. Murder is murder, no matter who does it or when you do it. Is it still somehow the mother's choice, after their child has grown to say, 20, to shoot down thier child because it was 'thier baby' ? Onto another topic- the bible teaches that the man is supposed to be the protector. How can the man protect when from childhood, feminists were saying that they were better than men? (i dont care what you feminists say- "oh we're all equal" "we're just trying to protect the rights of woman blah blah blah") thats the message that you're giving off. Take a second and look at how you're built. I know that woman suffered and didn't have any rights in the past, bu now that we're equal to men, shouldn't we stop there? Think about it. You're doing the same thing the men did to us all those years ago. Mabye not as extreme, but still. Can't you back off now that you have what you *cough* supposedly *cough* want? Gosh.
    1. GenaSherlockWillis
      7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/19/2012 7:10 AM
      You lost me at abortion, that has nothing to do with this article at all, and also you're (as stated below) only 13, there is no 13 year old woman. I'm 15, and i'm a girl. Also the bible has nothing to do with any of the article above. Please make your comments somewhat relevant to the article.
    1. maryd
      7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 5/02/2012 9:55 AM
      You're not a woman, you're a girl. There is no such thing as a 13 year old woman. Your argument is very poorly written and constructed, rife with grammatical and spelling errors, and is even worse than this article on Disney princesses.
  7. smarter than everyone.
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 3/16/2012 8:16 AM
    This whole argument should be taken off the internet. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and views, but when you wish to make a statement, which the entirety of this page is derogatory, unprofessional and completely pathetic; you use proper grammar, punctuation, developed sentence structures and actual valid evidence. Cursing in your argument also shows how inconsistent your thoughts are, taking away from all the opinions. Cursing does not make your statements stronger or important. Simply is not necessary. You write so poorly I, a fifteen year old, cannot take any of this seriously. I could respect this page to some extent if the argument was well written, and addressed maturely as well as properly, both of which you have failed to do. The princesses are innocent, never showing any indications of explicit alterative motives, which for you to even suggest such is ridiculous. All Disney movies are classic with wonderful plots and characters all of which have good kind hearts and intelligent strong minds. It's disapponting to know how essentially dumb people are, especially disappointing to find attempts of being analytical of Disney; critizing Disney, knowing nothing they talk about, everything totally invalid.
    1. Molly Mahan
      7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 4/06/2012 7:29 PM
      Lucky for you, it's not meant to be taken seriously.
  8. smarter than everyone.
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 3/15/2012 8:47 PM
    This whole argument should be taken off the internet. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and views, but when you wish to make a statement, which the entirety of this page is derogatory, unprofessional and completely pathetic; you use proper grammar, punctuation, developed sentence structures and actual valid evidence. Cursing in your argument also shows how inconsistent your thoughts are, taking away from all the opinions. Cursing does not make your statements stronger or important. Simply is not necessary. You write so poorly I, a fifteen year old, cannot take any of this seriously. I could respect this page to some extent if the argument was well written, and addressed maturely as well as properly, both of which you have failed to do. The princesses are innocent, never showing any indications of explicit alterative motives, which for you to even suggest such is ridiculous. All Disney movies are classic with wonderful plots and characters all of which have good kind hearts and intelligent strong minds. It's disapponting to know how essentially dumb people are, especially disappointing to find attempts of being analytical of Disney; critizing Disney, knowing nothing they talk about, everything totally invalid.
  9. Patrick
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 3/06/2012 10:35 PM
    You're a woman's studies major, aren't you? Have a nice life and keep on being perpetually misandric (hatred of men)
  10. JoeGemini
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 3/06/2012 10:31 PM
    I have never read such a serious and overtly feminist assessment of Walt Disney pictures. God help all those born with a Y Chromosome.
  11. Cece
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 2/28/2012 10:20 PM
    This gave me a good laugh. Very interesting viewpoints though. Personally I just love the movies but very interesting viewpoints ^_^
  12. Brittney
    Princess Aurora at 2/26/2012 2:58 PM
    For Sleeping Beauty, I wouldn't make such a big deal because no one really cares about the princess. The real stars, and the characters little girls like me wanted to be, were the fairies. I like how the heroines were quite old, as so much media has kids or young adults as the protagonists. The prince and princess were really more like props than actual characters.
  13. Andi
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/15/2011 8:44 AM
    WOW did you ever miss the boat with Belle. It was her good nature that changed the beast, not her looks. Geez, did you even SEE the movie?
  14. Craig
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/10/2011 8:58 PM
    You make a few good points but I disagree with a lot of this. Good news first, I agree with your assessment of Ariel. Horrible message, really. Your criticism of Cinderella actually has very little to do with CInderella, but I agree nonetheless. Now, the bad news. I don't know where you get the idea that Belle actively caused the change in the Beast. In the story, as you mentioned, the residents of the castle are all trying to get the two to fall in love. But, IIRC, they never actually mentioned this to her, so it's not like she stated her standards and then prodded the Beast to change to meet her expectations. In fact, I don't think she was even aware that the Beast was a potential love interest at all for the vast majority of the movie. What really happened is that the Beast fell in love with Belle and then developed compassion because he cared about her. The situation of a girl trying to change a bad boy is not really the same thing, at all. I'm not sure what problem you have with Aurora--That she isn't a defiant go-getter like Ariel or Jasmine? Not everyone can be like that. Besides, the fairies were isolating her in order to protect her from Maleficent who, you know, wants to murder her with a spindle. Why was it a bad thing for Aurora, a helpless teenager, to harmlessly daydream instead of deliberately defying her caretakers and recklessly running away? With the Princess and the Frog your beef is more (completely, by the looks of it) with Prince Naveen than with Tiana, so by all logic she should not even be on this list. Princess Jasmine was not, in fact, repulsed by the idea of marriage. She was repulsed by being forced to marry a complete stranger for political gain. One of her first lines was "If I do marry, I want it to be for love." So while she did eventually get married like her father had hoped, the point is that it was the way she wanted it...to a man she chose and loved. Did you even watch this movie? You are probably right about Snow White, but like someone above me wrote...the movie came out in 1937. Seriously? What did you expect from a movie that came out in 1937? I'm kind of surprised the prince didn't just punch Snow White in the eye for cheap audience laughs. This was a long comment. But Disney Princesses are obviously Serious Business.
  15. Rubrick
    Belle at 12/09/2011 12:44 PM
    You're wrong about Belle. The story is about how *acting* like a nice guy can turn you into one. It's really the story of the Beast; he's the one to make a giant leap of faith. Luckily, Belle is smart enough to recognize what he is doing and try to help him.
  16. Jake
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/08/2011 12:40 PM
    Wow...just wow. This whole article can be picked apart. While you did make some very good points others you blew out of proportion and completely missed the point. Tiana for instance was so focused on her father's dream that she was ignoring everything else. Only after meeting her prince (who yes was useless to start) did she realize what she truly wants. She fell for him AND got her restaurant. Jasmine was disgusted with marriage because she could not choose her suitor (you know kind of how it actually is in real life in the middle east). By the end she is able to choose her suitor, its telling girls not to go with the system but to fight for what you want....
  17. Jaeliyah
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/07/2011 6:53 PM
    I'll admit I'm coming from a bias as I've always had a personal fondness for Disney animated films, but I have three quibbles -- 1) I personally find animated characters that aren't good role models less toxic than the supposition that they should be. Rather than looking for the perfect caricatures for children to emulate, perhaps a more productive pursuit would be to teach children how to consume media and to be themselves. 2) In answer to the first question posed, yes, many times. This article barely touches on a debate that began long ago and doesn't really bring anything new to the table. It's like you're writing in a genre you've never read. 3) At what point in "Part of Your World" does Ariel mention anything remotely positive about life under the sea? She starts the song by saying she wants to know more of the surface world than her collection of discards and refuse, and indeed, later in that same song, which occurs before she even lays eyes on Eric, she declares her willingness to sacrifice a great deal to go to the surface.
  18. Bobby
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/04/2011 10:37 AM
    Wait, did you seriously jack Brianna Garcia's princess illustration for the thumbnail? C'mon, don't be that guy. Don't be that guy who writes a s**tty article that was supposed to be humorous (I think) and then steals an artist's work to lure people into clicking on the link and doesn't even attribute the image to her.
  19. Leinad
    7 Disney Princesses That Make the Worst Role Models at 12/04/2011 8:25 AM
    Yeah, the worst one was done in 1937! How DARE Disney create a cartoon that reflected the social values of the time and not predict how those values would have changed nearly eighty years down the road! Why, Disney should banish Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs to the vault forever so we don't contaminate our little girls!
  20. Daniel
    Belle at 12/03/2011 5:03 AM
    You are SO wrong about Belle. She's selfless. It's her selflessness that shows the Beast how stupid he is. Both people in a relationship change for the better because neither people in said relationship are Belle. She is the one to aspire to become. Bad choice to include her

today on Ranker