Anastasia Steele Fantasy Casting

Kate Kavanagh 63,261 views 92 items 3,392 voters

Who should play Anastasia Steele in the 'Fifty Shades of Grey' movie? The role made famous in the E.L. James erotic fiction novel will no doubt be a challenging one. Ana Steele and Christian Grey have an unconventional relationship! The 'Fifty Shades' movie has everyone talking about the actors who'll portray the lead characters -- but who do you think should get the nod? This list includes actresses who might be a good fit to play Ana, a recent college graduate who falls for, and becomes the obsession of, the handsome and ridiculously complicated Christian Grey. See a favorite on the list? Vote them up, and vote down the actresses you don't think would make a good Miss Steele. Also, if you have a favorite actress who isn't listed, add them. Also, be sure to weigh in on this list of Christian Grey fantasy casting!

In '50 Shades of Grey,' Ana Steele is about to graduate from college when she meets billionaire Christian Grey. The attraction is instant, and intense. Within days, the virginal Anastasia finds herself drawn into Mr. Grey's dark, seductive world of BDSM. Any actress that portrays Ana on screen must project a vulnerability and a certain innocence -- that's just a must.

Check out these books like 50 Shades of Grey.

Anastasia is described in the 'Fifty Shades' trilogy of books as a dark-haired, blue-eyed, seductress with gorgeous, pale skin. Obviously in a movie version, that could change -- but keep the description of Ana in mind when voting on who you think would rock the role.

Who would make a great Ana Steele? Would Jennifer Lawrence be able to pull it off? Can you see 'Vampire Diaries' star Nina Dobrev conversing with her inner goddess in the role? Could Emmy Rossum, Amanda Seyfried, Lucy Hale or even Emma Stone take a turn in the Red Room of Pain with the dashing, damaged, twitchy-palmed Christian Grey? Can you see Lily Collins uttering her "oh my's" as Christian works his...magic? All of those actresses might be great choices, but this list is for the fans. You decide!

rerank this list your way

< >

View:

More Options Add Item Follow List

Rank Name

1

Up 1015

Down 629

Emmy Rossum

1986
2

Up 842

Down 598

Alexis Bledel

1981
3

Up 9

Down 10

Emily Ratajkowski

1992

added by: tvoffer1
4

Up 534

Down 620

Lucy Hale

1989
5

Up 2

Down 15

Ashley Rickards

added by: LenaMichelleMendoza
6

Up 28

Down 55

Rita Macieira

added by: DiogoLima
7

Up 387

Down 571

Lily Collins

1989
8

Up 84

Down 138

Melissa Benoist

added by: TammyRuggieroAllman
9

Up 99

Down 164

Ashley Greene

1987

added by: Sarika
“ would be perfect! Her downplayed beauty matches ana's! We just need to see her with blue eyes :) „
10

Up 2

Down 25

Victoria Justice

added by: GemmaPope
11

Up 326

Down 599

Nina Dobrev

1989
12

Up 253

Down 474

Emilia Clarke

1987
13

Up 14

Down 61

Jessica Alba

added by: PageSita
14

Up 33

Down 102

Lyndsy Fonseca

added by: MyriamAnna
“
Lyndsy Marie Fonseca was born in Oakland, California, raised first in Alameda and then Moraga, California. Lyndsy competed in the International Modeling & Talent Association, where she was recognized as the second runner-up for "Young Miss Dancer of the Year" and was the first runner-up for "Miss Barbizon Young Miss Talent of the Year"

she plays ''Alex'' in ''Nikita''
„
15

Up 252

Down 568

Leighton Meester

1986
16

Up 46

Down 146

Jessica Stroup

1986

added by: Sarika
17

Up 3

Down 55

Nadia Bjorlin

1980

added by: Briza1
18

Up 3

Down 57

Jordanna Brewster

added by: Briza1
19

Up 235

Down 567

Emma Watson

1990
20

Up 243

Down 591

Mila Kunis

1983
21

Up 21

Down 103

Shailene Woodley

added by: KendallAnderson
22

Up 0

Down 56

Cassi Colvin

added by: FlamenRed
23

Up 8

Down 77

Jessica Lowndes

added by: AndreaCastro
“
Jessica Lowndes was born in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. She studied at Pacific Academy in Surrey and was included on People magazine's list of World's Most Beautiful People of 2009, along with co-stars from the series 90210.[1]
Jessica Lowndes is of English, Ukrainian and German descent. In 2005, Lowndes moved to California and moved back to Canada in 2010.
„
24

Up 17

Down 98

Willa Holland

1991

added by: MyriamAnna
25

Up 4

Down 72

Juliane Hough

added by: SonyaJackson
26

Up 133

Down 389

Alexandra Daddario

1986

added by: AndreaCastro
27

Up 20

Down 115

Emma Stone

added by: MyriamAnna
28

Up 31

Down 146

Rachel McAdams

added by: downtown92101
29

Up 103

Down 329

Phoebe Tonkin

1989

added by: Amy-AnnCabbage
30

Up 1

Down 71

BreMarie

added by: BreMarieWoolf
31

Up 8

Down 90

Lea Michele

1986

added by: kaylive
32

Up 152

Down 475

Jennifer Lawrence

1990
33

Up 12

Down 107

Camilla Luddington

added by: KendallAnderson
34

Up 173

Down 545

Natalie Portman

1981
35

Up 174

Down 552

Amanda Seyfried

1985
36

Up 140

Down 464

Anne Hathaway

1982
37

Up 148

Down 488

Emma Stone

1988
38

Up 141

Down 473

Minka Kelly

1980
39

Up 8

Down 107

Allison Harvard

added by: lovely44
“ Allison would be perfect to portray "Anastasia!" She was one of the models competing on Americas Next Top Model. She has huge, beautiful eyes. „
40

Up 18

Down 136

Claire Holt

1988

added by: LilithSchelcher
41

Up 49

Down 232

Ellen Page

1987

added by: LilithSchelcher
42

Up 15

Down 133

Rachel McAdams

added by: downtown92101
43

Up 111

Down 418

Lyndsy Fonseca

1987
44

Up 15

Down 140

Shenae Grimes

1989

added by: TanyaEspinosa
45

Up 9

Down 122

Chyler Leigh

1982

added by: NuriaLozano
46

Up 107

Down 430

Felicity Jones

1983
47

Up 66

Down 304

Zooey Deschanel

1980
48

Up 85

Down 365

Michelle Trachtenberg

1985
49

Up 112

Down 460

Rachel Bilson

1981
50

Up 26

Down 184

Emily Browning

1988

added by: LilithSchelcher
+Add New Item

! Item Added
Want to make your version of this list? X