creepy stories The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends  

Juliet Bennett Rylah
513 votes 253 voters 21k views 18 items Follow Embed

List Rules Vote up the creepiest tales about New York City's Central Park.

As with any famous landmark, there are certainly a number of creepy stories about Central Park. Coming in at 834 acres, Central Park is one of Manhattan's most iconic and bucolic attractions. It first opened in 1857, and was later reopened in 1873, after improvements designed by landscapers and architects Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux. Of the 42 million visitors the park is estimated to receive each year, not all of them can be good apples—and some of them might even be monsters.

Compiled here are the strangest true crime tales, urban legends, and lore surrounding The People's Park, including a monstrous fish, an unsolved murder, a mysterious cave, and a pair of sibling ghosts who prefer the chilliest months. If you're feeling brave, try reading this list in The Ramble after dark.

+ - 44 13

Ghostly Siblings on Ice

Ghostly Siblings on Ice is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: 2.0

Janet and Rosetta Van Der Voort are two sisters who supposedly haunt Central Park. So the story goes, their father was so protective of his daughters that the only place he let them go alone was to the Central Park Pond for ice skating. The women never married and died months apart of old age in 1880. Legend has it you can sometimes catch a glimpse of their ghosts, still wearing the same red and purple ensembles they wore decades before, skating around the pond.

+ - 38 12

A Brutal Crime and Five Wrongful Convictions

Ranker Video v
Video: YouTube

One of the nation's most horrifying and notorious crimes occurred in Central Park on April 19, 1989. Trisha Meili, a 28-year-old investment banker, was jogging through the park when she was brutally raped, beaten, and left for dead. In a bizarre twist, five young black and Hispanic men were convicted of the crime in 1990, each spending a number of years in prison.

However, in 2002, Matias Reyes confessed, saying he had acted alone when he attacked Meili. New York City settled with the five wrongfully convicted men in 2015 for $40 million, the New York Times reported. The case was explored in the documentary The Central Park Five, directed by filmmaker Ken Burns, his daughter Sarah Burns, and her husband David McMahon.

Meili now works as an inspirational speaker and wrote a book titled I Am the Central Park Jogger: A Story of Hope and Possibility.

+ - 24 7

A Festive Tribute to Deceased Pets

A Festive Tribute to Deceased ... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: Moyan Brenn/flickr/CC-BY 2.0
This one's more heart-warming than Pet Sematary. There's a hidden Christmas tree nestled in The Ramble that people adorn with ornaments commemorating their furry friends that have passed. When writers from the blog Untapped Cities found the tree, they noted it mostly contained laminated photos of gone-but-not-forgotten pets, carefully hung from the branches.
+ - 30 13

A Mysterious Secret Hidden Decades Ago

A Mysterious Secret Hidden Dec... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: Andrew Holmes/flickr/CC-BY-NC 2.0

Calvert Vaux, Central Park's co-designer, supposedly wrote a letter dated September 24, 1895, stating that he and a friend had hidden "a secret of great historical importance" in the park. He instructed its potential finder to use a set of papers, known as the Central Park Papers, to find the secret—but not until 1965, and then to keep quiet about the findings for another decade. At the close of the letter, Vaux said he feared for his life and that the papers were the best way he could make sure someone eventually discovered the secret, despite certain men who wished it to remain hidden forever. Vaux drowned on November 19, 1895, in Gravesend Bay.

Is any of it real? Well, Vaux really did drown, but the rest might be a tall tale via David Wise, who supposedly sells the papers via his website—which is under 'renovation.'

+ - 19 4

An Antique, Yet Loaded, Weapon

An Antique, Yet Loaded, Weapon is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: Jim Grey/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0
There was an old cannon, once operational on British Navy ship HMS Hussar, in storage in the park's Ramble shed. The cannon hadn't been used for its intended purpose in over 200 years, but in 2013, crews from the Central Park Conservancy went to clean the antique weapon and found it prepped for battle.

According to CBS, they discovered a cannonball, wadding, and about 1.8 pounds of active gunpowder. The bomb squad responded and no one was hurt, but prior to storage, the cannon had been on display from the 1860s until 1996.
+ - 26 10

The Frankenfish Invaded the Waters (And Land) of Central Park

The Frankenfish Invaded the Wa... is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: Wie146/Wikimedia Commons

The snakehead fish, better known for its ghastly visage as the Frankenfish, terrorized Central Park in 2013. Those who chose to fish at Harlem Meer were warned not to release a captured Frankenfish back into the wild, but rather "kill it immediately, freeze it and report your catch," according to New York magazine. While the species mainly eats frogs and crayfish—not people or pets—it is an extremely invasive species not native to New York. They can also breathe air, and are capable of surviving out of water for up to four days at a time.

+ - 21 8

Central Park's Weirdest Tour Guide Comes Out at Night

Central Park's Weirdest To... is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: Christopher Porter/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0

On the right night, at the right time, you might get the chance to go on a night-time tour with Bernard Herman. He is actually musician Barkev Gulesserian, but becomes the bizarre Herman character when leading his Haunted New York tours, according to the Village Voice. These one-on-one jaunts through Central Park may or may not involve handcuffs and being blindfolded. And they're cheap: the last one, held around Halloween, apparently cost "$9 or 9 pennies and a piece of bedding."

+ - 16 4

The Unsolved Murder of a Jogger

The Unsolved Murder of a Jogge... is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list The Creepiest Central Park Stories and Legends
Photo: AlexVan/Pixabay

In September 1995, a 44-year-old jogger named Maria Alves was found dead in Central Park. Investigators believed that she was attacked as she ran on East Drive near Lasker Rink, then pulled down a nearby embankment. Her attacker sexually assaulted and killed her, and her body was discovered hours later under a bridge near East Drive, facedown in a stream. Her killer was never caught.