conspiracies Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind

3.8k votes 1.2k voters 220k views 10 items Embed

List Rules Vote up the fan theories that make the most sense.

Any cult favorite movie or TV show usually has lots of fan theories, but in some instances, fans speculate about video games too. When you’ve got a massively popular series that has an extensive story, you’re bound to get a response, which is why there are so many fan theories about Grand Theft Auto.

Some of these are so out there that they could easily be classified as Grand Theft Auto conspiracy theories. But some of them make a surprising amount of sense. Vote up the GTA fan theories that are most plausible.
+ - 545 199

15 people just voted on The Three Characters in GTA V Represent Three Generations of GTA

The Three Characters in GTA V ... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
This was a widely enjoyed theory that suggested the entire game was “a celebration of the series’ history.” Redditor CitizenWolfie breaks down Trevor as GTA 1 and 2, Franklin as GTA 3, Vice City, and San Andreas, and Michael De Santa as a postmodern GTA character. It’s pretty in-depth and was sensible enough to draw attention from gaming sites and GTA fans across the web. Here's how CitizenWolfie explains his idea [sic throughout]:

"Trevor Phillips: Trevor is the crazy, unhinged, old school maniac of the trio. He represents the original, top-down games from GTA1 to GTA2. Those games were all about the thrill of running wild in an open city and featured a cast of wacky characters to interact with. Trevor is a throwback to these games, even to the point of having his very own rampage missions similar to the "Kill Frenzy" side-missions of old and even his special skill of invincibility reflects that feeling you get when you play those old games. He's angry, brutal and butt-ugly, much like those first few games. Sure, they both have their story missions, but really it's all about having fun.

Franklin Clinton: Franklin's story is the fairly typical rags-to-riches story that was a common theme in the PS2 generation GTA games spanning GTA3, Vice City and particularly San Andreas. We see a good natured guy who wants to rise above his position in life and move beyond his deadbeat friends who are holding him back. And when he is introduced to a successful career criminal, it's his key to making a better life for himself at the risk of pulling off bigger and badder crimes. This theme is similar throughout the above games, though as mentioned Franklin is most similar to CJ from San Andreas, right down to living in a crappy area at the start to getting hold of a mansion in the hills. It's interesting too that Franklin's special skill is driving - one of the main focuses of the PS2-gen games.

Michael De Santa: Michael is almost a postmodern GTA character - the aftermath of the "GTA lifestyle;" a man who has risen from the bottom and done it all in the criminal world, done some terrible things in the past and is trying really hard to change his ways only to find that things aren't always so easy. Michael represents the "new" GTA that was started from GTAIV (and DLC stories) - a focus on story-driven, multi-faceted characters who are struggling to make amends in an environment that moves too fast. IV's Niko, while certainly not starting from the top, is nevertheless making a new start in Liberty City, but thanks to his idiotic family and criminal connections can't quite stay out of trouble. Both men find that it's impossible for their loved ones not to end up staring down the barrel of a gun at some point and it's interesting to note that Michael's shooting skill mirrors the more gun-based gameplay of IV and V. And on a purely superficial level, both games feature some awesome heists. Likewise, the GTAIV add-ons feature protagonists who have done most of their criminal work long before their stories begin and are just trying to survive in a changing world."
+ - 332 175

The Islands in GTA Are a Metaphor

The Islands in GTA Are a Metap... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
Redditor angrypuppy points out that, as anyone who plays GTA knows, the world in the game is a huge landmass surrounded by water. This person’s theory suggests that Rockstar is actually using the islands as a metaphor, stating:

“In GTAV while walking around the streets you hear people consumed entirely by celebrities, media, social media, gossip, etc. In the grand scheme of things these issues aren't at all important, yet the citizens of Los Santos are entirely preoccupied with them. So Rockstar is basically saying that the American people don't really care for what's happening outside of their little world. They don't actually live on an island, but they might as well because they are isolated from the actual problems that plague the rest of the world. They are individualistic, ignorant, and oblivious to the rest of the world, so they might as well live on an island away from it all.”
+ - 293 152

Some Rockstar Games Are Set in the Same Universe as GTA

Some Rockstar Games Are Set in... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
Redditor DrTatertots suggests that it essentially boils down like this.

Red Dead Revolver = the 1880s

 Red Dead Redemption = 1911

L.A. Noir = 1947

They point out that GTA has multiple universes – 2D (GTA and GTA 2), 3D (GTA 3 and its spin-offs) and HD (GTA IV and GTA V). Red Dead Redemption is tied to HD, through the "Red Dead" book seen in GTA V. They further support this point with great notes such as the fact that Bullworth Academy from the video game Bully is mentioned on the radio in GTA IV.
+ - 267 163

9 people just voted on Insurance Companies are Constantly Monitoring People’s Heartbeats and Locations

Insurance Companies are Consta... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
This superb theory by gallagher222 begins by pointing out that killing a civilian in GTA gets an immediate one-star rating – even when you’ve murdered a civilian with no witnesses. The police are alerted even if there’s nobody there to report it, so this idea suggests that life insurance companies monitor their clients’ vital signs and whereabouts through some sort of tracking chip implanted in their bodies. It goes more in depth, but the gist of it is a heck of an idea.
+ - 205 119

6 people just voted on One GTA V Plot Point Was Written Solely to Encourage Fan Theories

One GTA V Plot Point Was Writt... is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
Could GTA V have been indulging the conspiracy theorists? Redditor Black_Hipster points out the rumors and secrets in the GTA series, from Bigfoot and aliens to Ratman and haunted warehouses. This user also notes that occasionally the game features characters who are big into conspiracy theories, particularly on radio stations.

The belief here is that Rockstar poked fun at that fan base by incorporating the Mount Chiliad mystery into GTA V. There are ghosts and alien spaceships in the sky, but seemingly no order to the things connected to Mount Chiliad. This user believes that was intentional, to get theorists like himself discussing, debating, and reading about conspiracy theories.
+ - 187 139

All of Rockstar’s Non-GTA Games Are Just Entertainment in the GTA Universe

All of Rockstar’s Non-GTA Game... is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
The creator of this theory points to Red Dead Redemption, Max Payne, L.A. Noire, and Rockstar Games Presents Table Tennis for support. In this scenario, the fact that there’s a book titled ‘Red Dead’ visible in GTA supports the concept, but the rest is speculative, suggesting L.A. Noire is a TV show, Rockstar Games Presents Table Tennis is a sports broadcast, and Max Payne is a movie. It’s an interesting idea, at the very least.
+ - 138 142

The Protagonists of Grand Theft Auto V Represent Physical Forms of Money

The Protagonists of Grand Thef... is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list Grand Theft Auto Fan Theories That'll Blow Your Mind
Photo: Rockstar Games
Redditor Choppy_LaStatch explained why they think Trevor, Michael, and Franklin are representative of “Gold, Silver and the Greenback, respectively.” He points out that Rockstar Games stated during a GTA V press conference leading up to the game's release that a large focus of the game will be money. From the color that covers the screen when each character’s special ability is activated (Franklin/Green, Trevor/Gold, and Michael/Silver), to other details, like Michael having a few silver hairs and enjoying black and white films. It’s really well-thought out, and the theory isn’t limited to color schemes. It touches on the characters’ personalities as well.
+ - 124 150

7 people just voted on GTA Is so Violent Because Its Universe Is a Collection of Islands

Ranker Video v
Video: YouTube
The creator of this theory proposes that Island Nations (e.g. Japan and Great Britain) have violent histories because as island nations, they had fewer resources and conquered other places to attain them. He says that perhaps GTA’s world, along with Manhunt and Red Dead Redemption, has so little regard for human life because violence is simply a part of their culture.