Horror movie villains are something of an anomaly in the film world; more often than not, the less you know about them, the more frightening they are. Unlike characters in any other genre of film, they operate on pure dream logic, and – because of that – they don’t require a raison d’être beyond terrorizing the characters in their films. Unfortunately, thanks to the sequelization of literally every modern horror film, every terrifying horror villain has received some kind of terrible backstory. In most instances, characters ruined by backstory are given three or more films before a writer doles out an unnecessary backstory for a creature that’s meant to exist as a pure metaphor, but some horror writers don’t even wait for a sequel to wreck a perfectly fine film and provide a sad-sack story for the creature handing out ironic punishments to sexy teens in the original property.
If you’re the kind of audience member who wants a backstory for the characters you’re watching onscreen, that’s totally fine. It’s human nature to be curious about why something is happening, but the horror genre is meant to create tension by asking questions, not answering them definitively. Most of the backstories that are given to horror villains seeks to provide a reason as to why they’re hacking up strangers, but these are characters you don't need sympathy for. They’re meant to act as sign posts that say “go the other way,” not “love me and my knife hands.” Continue reading to explore the worst origins of some of your favorite characters. And, to the writers who ruined a good thing, don't quit your day job.
The Women Of Paranormal Activity
The Backstory, In a Nutshell: Over a series of six films, it's revealed that the women of Paranormal Activity are actually members of a cult called The Midwives who are raising young girls to give birth to possessed sons in order to time travel around the late-20th and early-21st centuries murdering people.
Why It Ruins the Character: What are you doing, Paranormal Activity? The first film in this series is a pretty boring but uniquely filmed ghost story that takes its time frightening the audience without providing any rhyme or reason for the appearance of a demonic entity. By building a convoluted (and very dumb) backstory that features witches brainwashing young women to have possessed sons in order to hang out with a demon named Toby, the only thing you're doing is confusing your audience. The reason the first film works is because nothing is explained; if the producers would have simply left it as is, they could have created a one-and-done film that forever contained an air of mystery.
The Backstory, In a Nutshell: According to Hellraiser: Hell on Earth, Pinhead's real name is Elliott Spencer, a captain in the British Expeditionary Force suffering from PTSD and survivor guilt. After losing his faith in humanity, he wanders the Earth sleeping with anything that moves and doing all of the opium that the early 20th century has to offer. At some point, he stumbles upon the Lament Configuration, and then he's off to the races.
Why It Ruins the Character: In the first and only good (fight me) Hellraiser film, Pinhead is nothing more than an otherworldly entity that shows up and BDSMs people to death. Trying to piece together what the character of Pinhead is supposed to mean in a few sentences is futile (is he pro-sex? anti-sex? a Home Depot representative?), but the one thing that's immediately obvious is the visceral fear that the initial appearance of Pinhead creates. He's not just spooky; he's a legitimately frightening characterization of humanity when it grows bored of everyday life. He's you on a Pornhub binge; he's your late night shopping jags; he's Bukowski when he quit the post office. Learning that he's a soldier from the First World War removes all the bite from a character who should be nothing but.
Also Rankedsee more on Pinhead
The Backstory, In a Nutshell: Myers has had the unfortunate fate of having his backstory written and rewritten by people who were not his creator. Depending on which storyline you follow, Myers was either a child psychopath who killed his family and later developed a love of paper-mâché masks while he was in a mental institution, or he's a child that was infected by the "Thorn," a druid curse that drives those infected to kill their next of kin each Halloween. And sometimes he has a psychic link with his cousin or sister or whatever.
Why It Ruins the Character: It should go without saying that adding a supernatural, druid, hocus-pocus backstory to Michael Myers is a waste of everyone's time and a complete betrayal of the original character. It doesn't make the character more frightening; it just makes the audience confused. So putting that aside, the lengthy backstory provided by Rob Zombie in his completely fine but unnecessary Halloween remake tells the story of a child born with preternaturally dark impulses who is raised by wolves. The fact that Zombie spends an hour plus telling this story is insane. John Carpenter accomplished the feat of telling the audience that Myers was a child psychopath in about five minutes and moved on to the meat of the story, but, for some reason, Zombie felt that he really needed to flesh out the story of a mute killer that still ends in the same way as the original film. As Tom Petty once said, "don't bore us, get to the chorus."
Also Rankedsee more on Michael Myers
The Backstory, In a Nutshell: Born to an unknown mother and left for dead in a dumpster, Leatherface gets a job at a slaughterhouse only to see it shut down. At some point on a murder spree, he cuts off a guy's face and wears it as a mask.
Why It Ruins the Character: Leatherface is meant to be a manifestation of the changing masculine and feminine mores of the '70s; he doesn't need a reason to exist. He's essentially the Minotaur in King Minos's maze, and regardless of the fact that the characters are already doomed the moment they appear on screen, he's the final signifier that no one will leave the film alive... or unscarred. Giving Leatherface such a maudlin backstory deflates the character to something more akin to Norman Bates with a subscription to 24 Hour Fitness and a penchant for chainsaws. The audience begins to pity Leatherface – and even side with him – rather than fear the destruction he wields at all times.
Also Rankedsee more on Leatherface