Undeserving Members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame Football Players (American)
Vote List
30  items 1,144 votes 137 voters 7,080 views by  more info

Undeserving Members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame

List Criteria: The players at the top of the list are the ones who are the most undeserving members

The most undeserving members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame are all great players who have contributed great things to the game, but are not quite up to that elite level deserving of enshrinement. While most of the time the Board of Selectors gets their inductions right, occasionally and especially in these cases, they might be a little too lenient on who they add to the wall of bronze busts in Canton, Ohio.

There is no question that all of these men are stellar NFL players, even some of the best football players of all time who have played for the greatest pro football teams of all time. However, when you compare their contributions to the league to the stars of today, they fall quite short.

Lynn Swann, for example, had a decorated career as a receiver for the Pittsburgh Steelers but really only had a few Hall of Fame-worthy games and never finished in the top five among receivers during his career. Bob Griese, the Super Bowl-winning quarterback for the Miami Dolphins, is another good example. Completing only 77.1% of his passes, Griese never topped 2,500 passing yards in a season. For reference, in 2011, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees passed for 5,476.

Then there are others who are deserving of enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but not for the reasons they were inducted. Dick LeBeau is arguably one of the best defensive coordinators in the history of the National Football League but was inducted after a less-than-impressive playing career as a defensive back with the Detroit Lions.

So for all the greats in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, there are also some duds. In the end, the Gale Sayers, Joe Namaths and O.J. Simpsons are all above average players but when you really get down to comparing their careers to the top football players of today, they simply are undeserving of being members of the Pro Football hall of Fame.
  • 1 ReRanks
  • See list ranked by
</> Rerank List
  1. 1
    Up 43
    Down 20

    1935

    open
  2. 2
    Up 46
    Down 28

    1943

    open
  3. 3
    Up 49
    Down 32

    1952

    open
  4. 4
    Up 30
    Down 15

    1952

    open
  5. 5
    Up 22
    Down 12

    1949

    open
  6. 6
    Up 18
    Down 10

    1946

    open
  7. 7
    Up 27
    Down 20

    1945

    open
  8. 8
    Up 16
    Down 13

    1942

    open
  9. 9
    Up 14
    Down 13

    1947

    open
  10. 10
    Up 12
    Down 11

    1942

    open
  11. 11
    Up 16
    Down 16

    1945

    open
  12. 12
    Up 20
    Down 21

    1941

    open
  13. 13
    Up 11
    Down 10

    new! 1921

    open
  14. 14
    Up 14
    Down 14

    1959

    open
  15. 15
    Up 17
    Down 20

    1942

    open
  16. 16
    Up 11
    Down 14

    1941

    open
  17. 17
    Up 20
    Down 27

    1926

    open
  18. 18
    Up 9
    Down 13

    1946

    open
  19. 19
    Up 10
    Down 15

    1941

    open
  20. 20
    Up 9
    Down 16

    1953

    open
  21. 21
    Up 7
    Down 14

    1959

    open
  22. 22
    Up 8
    Down 16

    1937

    open
  23. 23
    Up 9
    Down 20

    1951

    open
  24. 24
    Up 13
    Down 26

    1951

    open
  25. 25
    Up 9
    Down 22

    1957

    open
  26. 26
    Up 21
    Down 41

    1943

    open
  27. 27
    Up 21
    Down 44

    1947

    open
  28. 28
    Up 12
    Down 32

    1956

    open
  29. 29
    Up 10
    Down 30

    1967

    open
  30. 30
    Up 7
    Down 28

    1957

    open
  31. 31 +

    Something missing? Add it!

Is this list missing something?
BE THE FIRST TO ADD AN ITEM

items 1 - 30 of 30

think you can do better?

Rerank This List

got a blog or website?

embed this list

viewers of this list also saw

more popular lists