Shake Shack Secret Menu Items

Secret Menu Items 27,163 views 10 items

popular in New York City, Shake Shack rivals the ever-popular In-N-Out Burger in more ways than one, including by offering their own hush-hush Shake Shack secret menu. These off-menu items will tantalize your taste buds like never before by combining sweet and savory flavorings, something even the special In-N-Out secret menu cannot claim.

Shake Shack can accomplish this feat with their slightly larger menu including ice creams, hot dogs and even alcohol. But like other secret menus from rival fast food establishments, getting the individual restaurant to prepare these specialty items is often half the battle. Sure they have the ingredients, but asking nicely and getting an easy going cashier helps tremendously.

When all else fails, order the ingredients to reproduce these Shake Shack special menu items separately and assemble these tasty treats yourself. Trust us, once you eat off the secret menu, you'll never go back.

< >

Show: 5 25 View:

More Options

6

Chili Pepper-Cheese Fries

They have chili peppers, they have fries and they have cheese. Why not combine all three for a play on chili cheese fries? Ordering this one may depend on how easy going your cashier is, but it can be easily duplicated by ordering cheese fries and asking for a slide of sliced peppers. Dump the peppers on the fries and you're good to go!
7

Protein Style

Taking a cue from the In-N-Out protein-style "burger," the Shake Shack protein-style burger is pretty much the same. Ask for your burger of choice without a bun and with extra lettuce. Save your carbs for a rainy day and use the lettuce leaves as your bun to devour a tasty burger without the guilt.
8

Extra Shake Shack Sauce

Like the Big Mac Sauce or other wonder condiments, an extra serving of this sauce can turn normal menu items into magical ones. Spread this goodness over your burger or throw it on top of your cheese fries for instant happiness in your mouth.
9

Corn dog

While not so secret, the Shake Shack corn dog is the equivalent of the McDonald's McRib or Shamrock Shake in that it's only available at certain locations for a limited time. If you're a corn dog enthusiast, and with all the politicians eating them these days who isn't, keep your eyes peeled for corn dog season at Shake Shack.
10

Ice Cream Sandwich

Like no other ice cream sandwich you've ever had, this one will confuse and entertain your taste buds all at the same time. While Shake Shack does not stock the chocolate wafers in a traditional ice cream sandwich, they do have warm and toasty buns. Order a bun plus a side of your favorite frozen custard. Put the cool cream between the two layers of bread and enjoy. Far from normal and quite messy, but absolutely amazing.