home > Comic Book Characters
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History By Eric Diaz [10 more lists]
Marvel Comics' gay superheroes Rictor and Shatterstar finally kissing is an event that is still making headlines. So, in honor of homosexuality becoming more commonplace in the comic book medium, here are the 10 most important LGBT moments in comic book history.
For more from Eric Diaz, visit his column's page on Geekscape.net titled Gayscape, the best in Homosexual Geek Culture:
http://www.geekscape.net/features/gayscape
- 1
Batwoman - No Longer Just Batman's Beard
I might have been heavy on the gay boys and light on the lesbians on this list, but the #1 slot goes to none other than DC's Batwoman, so I hope that makes up for it. Why #1? Because she's an out character who wears the symbol of DC's most popular hero, a cultural icon no less, and has headlined the book that DC Comics is named after (Detective Comics) for a year now.
AND she's proven to be a kick ass character to boot. All of this would have been unthinkable just a decade ago.
DC had a Batwoman before; back in the 1950’s, to rebuff notions that Batman and Robin were a gay couple, Batwoman was introduced as a "girlfriend” to Batman. Introduced in 1956, Kathy Kane was as sexist as comics could get in the day. Her entire reason for super heroing was merely to get Batman to marry her, and instead of a utility belt, she had a “utility purse” with gadgets that looked like lipstick and compacts. After the whole “Batman and Robin are gay” paranoia ended in the early 60’s, editor Julius Schwartz retired Batwoman for good. Eventually, a new female version of Batman was introduced in the form of Batgirl, a character that everyone loved and stood the test of time.
But in an effort to create some diversity (and sales) DC introduced a new version of Batwoman; this time Kate Kane wasn't merely Batman's "beard", but an out lesbian. Gone was the utility purse; this Batwoman was an ex military chick who could kick anyone's ass. Considering her comics origins, the irony is delicious. DC took out a press release in all the major newspapers to not only announce her existence to the world, but also the fact that this new heroine was a “lipstick lesbian”. A little over the top, but still better than Marvel's Rawhide Kid debacle. Comics readers felt cynical about the whole affair, but in time, writer Greg Rucka made her a fan favorite by virtue of solid writng and great characterization.
And thus, the arrival of Batwoman is the most important LGBT event in mainstream comics. -
- 2
Rictor and Shatterstar
Both members of Marvel's X-Factor, heroes Rictor and Shatterstar are the gay super couple of the year. Although, despite what stories in the media might say, they are NOT the first gay super couple in comics (see the rest of this list). Both created to be members of Marvel's X-Force back in the early 90's, at some point writers began to imply that Rictor and Shatterstar were more than just friends. But for years, it was all between-the-lines innuendo.
Finally last year, current X-Factor writer Peter David decided that it was the 21st Century, and it was way past time to stop being coy about their relationship. Rictor and Shatterstar were lovers, end of story.
Except this is the age of Twitter, and it was NOT the end of the story, but the beginning. Shatterstar creator and all around douchebag Rob Liefield said "As the guy that created, designed and wrote his first dozen appearances, Shatterstar is not gay. Sorry. Can't wait to someday undo this. Seems totally contrived. Shatterstar is akin to Maximus in Gladiator. He's a warrior, a Spartan, and not a gay one" Note to Liefield: Read some history on the Spartans. Thanks.
Peter David had this to say on Rob's homophobic remarks about his creation now being gay: "I understand that some parents have the same reaction. They were responsible for their children's appearances and, when informed of their sexual persuasion, firmly declare it's impossible, they can't be gay." - 3
Green Lantern and the Gay Bashing
When Green Lantern's gay teen friend Terry Berg got brutally gay bashed in the Fall 2002 issue, it got a lot of press and stirred a lot of controversy amongst the more traditional comic book fans. Even fans who were pro gay couldn't help but feel as if the whole storyline was like a "very special episode" of an 80's sitcom, where we are introduced to a controversial subject matter, and then said controversial subject matter and character disappear as if they never existed.
Even if that's true, no one can argue that writer Judd Winnick and DC Comics at least had their heart in the right place with this one.
At the time, Green Lantern Kyle Rayner was working at a magazine and had a teenage assistant named Terry Berg, his very own Jimmy Olsen. Eventually, it was revealed that Terry was gay, and he eventually came out to GL. His own family not accepting of him, Terry became Kyle's token gay friend and confidant, only to be gay bashed by thugs a few issues later, leaving him in a coma. Clearly, this entire storyline was meant to be an homage to the late Matthew Shepherd, as the Terry Berg character even looked like him.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_Shepard
The whole storyline would send Kyle Rayner into a long "its all my fault, woe is me, I'm exiling myself to space" saga.
At the end of this storyline, Terry wakes from his coma and finds that Kyle has left him a duplicate power ring, implying that he will soon become the Teen Lantern (or something like that). But directions changed over at the Green Lantern book, Hal Jordan was soon back and Kyle's supporting cast was soon forgotten. It's a damn shame too, because it would have been great to have a gay hero on the Teen Titans and now Terry Berg is nothing more than a footnote in DC history.
I guess it was gonna be up to Marvel to make a gay teen hero and make it work....which they did in the form of the Young Avengers not soon afterwards. -
- 4
The Young Avengers Hulkling and Wiccan
When Young Avengers was announced back in 2005, readers scoffed at what appeared to be a Marvel version of DC's Teen Titans, with teenage versions of Captain America, Thor, Hulk, and Iron Man. But the book ended up being one of the best Avengers titles in years, surprising everyone with its quality. And also surprising everyone was the revelation that Young Avengers Hulkling and Wiccan were in fact boyfriends. Their entire relationship was handled without press or fanfare, they were just two (superpowered) boys in love.
While they no doubt lost a few readers because of the gay teen love, they no doubt gained a whole lot more who would be forever loyal. Gay writer Allan Heinberg made the characters gay simply so young gay readers would finally have someone to identify with on a super team, something he (and many young gay comics fans) never had growing up. - 5
Batman and Robin Secret Love
It has been the subject of a million lame jokes for decades, but in the early 50’s it was anything but, and nearly brought about the demise of the American comic book medium. In 1953, some asshole trying to make a name for himself named Frederic Wertham wrote a book called Seduction of the Innocent, about how comics were destroying America’s youth. One famously cited example was that Batman and Robin were actually lovers.
According to Wertham, Batman and Robin inhabited "a wish dream of two homosexuals living together."
They lived in "sumptuous quarters," without wives or girlfriends, with only an effeminate British butler for company.
They often shared living quarters, and lounged together in dressing gowns. Not to mention proclivities for costumes, dressing up, and fantasy role play; secretive behavior and double-lives; little interest in women; and of course depictions of Batman and Robin were frequently homoerotic, visually emphasizing Batman's physique and Robins bare legs and short pants.
Shit, this guy almost has ME convinced.
DC was forced to butch up Bruce and Dick, in a manner of speaking, by giving Batman the steady girlfriend of Batwoman, a character literally created to make concerned mothers say “oh, see? He has a girlfriend.” She was the comic book equivalent of Katie Holmes (maybe that is why they cast her ass in Batman Begins?)
Batwoman of course, is now famously a lesbian. Gotta love how things work out.
Showing items 1 - 5 of 10
Post a Comment
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/12/2010 3:47 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/05/2010 3:30 PM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 6/30/2010 3:15 PM
Queers.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 7/02/2010 7:10 AM
"Love & Rockets" wouldn't make the list because its characters have NEVER been marketed to kids, so gay characters aren't as groundbreaking in that series as they would be in, say, "Uncle Scrooge". I'd imagine that Gyro Gearloose could design a h**l of a vibe...
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/11/2010 8:46 AM
Fact is, though some of us in the press may praise it, gay heroes in comics hurt sales, Moon Knight tanked after 2 issues which explored one of his friends being gay. And on the Ric/Shatterstar front, they've never been gay, but like beast people have toyed with making them so. In the end, PD did it to get press cause that arc was dropping steadily in sales. Clearly your showing a bias by declaring Rob a homophobe, no one has ever done more hard to the gay movement in comics then what Marvel is doing right now.
They're taking classic NON gay heroes and making them gay, if you really want to make someone gay, then come up with a strong NEW gay hero, rather then make weaker cult favorites the gay heroes.
All this is pointless however when the only people who these story-lines bring in are gay and people who want to see what the fuss is about. X-Factor sold quite a it of those few issues, and now yet again it's sales aren't as good. Despite what some in the press say, being Gay in a comic doesn't help in the long run. Recent polls show that 60% of Americans are sick of the gay rights, "your with us or a homophobe we hate" mantra. Does that matter? No, because the pro-gay people are just going to keep shoving it (bad choice of words) in peoples faces until they die down and accept it. . . Which is why many of us just quit buying these books when they decide to blatantly use the "gay factor" to stir up a response.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 6/18/2010 11:26 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/14/2010 5:31 PM
Oh, and yeah...We WILL keep shoving it in people's faces" as you so cleverly put until people "die down and accept" or until WE die; civil rights and our right to be included in society is not exactly something I'm willing to get complacent about, EVER. And it isn't something like poll numbers showing that 60% of Americans are against me or whatever is going to make me stop fighting either. That's just fuel for the fire baby.
And one last thing Jef- If I were to quite buying a book because a character was black or a Jew, then there would be no argument that I was racist. But you dropping a book because of the "gay factor" doesn't make you a homophobe how exactly?
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 6/11/2011 7:37 PM
@Tom If I had a penny for everytime I heard a "straight" guy rant about gay people, but end up being gay himself...
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 7/02/2010 7:18 AM
Here's hoping the latter happens soon, then, assclown. And being a "homophobe" isn't the worst thing a person could be; it just is to you, because it affects YOUR KY-tinged little world, so the word holds as much meaning as being called a "broccoliphobe" or a "moviesstarringLindseyLohanphobe".
The ability to turn out in droves in elections and vote Liberal doesn't make you respectable. It merely makes you well-organized perverts, which is perfectly fine; just don't take a kink, turn it into a (snicker) "lifestyle" and then expect equal treatment from Normal Society. You made your bed, so sleep in it.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 7/27/2011 4:04 PM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 6/18/2010 11:26 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/29/2010 10:59 AM
I think I may have found one....
Notice how Bruce's arms are held over his head, like he's stretching. Then notice how "Dick's" arms are folded, or crossed. It kind of looks to me like Bruce is forming the "male" gender symbol, and Dick is forming the "female" gender symbol. Does that mean Bruce is the pitcher and Dick is the catcher?? hmmm.....
Green Lantern and the Gay Bashing at 3/15/2010 7:54 PM
http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=1675094&l=d0312dae2f&id=500651168
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/12/2010 10:21 AM
Green Lantern and the Gay Bashing at 6/18/2010 11:27 AM
Batwoman - No Longer Just Batman's Beard at 2/15/2011 12:35 PM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/08/2010 7:40 PM
This wasn't a list based on quality, otherwise the awful Rawhide Kid series or Alpha Flight's coming out issue wouldn't even be here. Those stories got headlines in the mainstream press. Stan Lee went on CNN to talk about their "gay cowboy" book. Rictor and Shatterstar were all over sites like Perez Hilton and similar ones.
To put in another way; there have been several actresses who have come out as lesbian before Ellen, however Ellen made nationwide headlines by being the first to do so while starring in a mainstream sitcom watched by millions. That is what made history. There have been a million gay indie flicks before Brokeback Mountain, but that is the one that crossed over into the mainstream and changed the notion that gay lead characters were only for a small niche audience. Brokeback made history. The others...not so much. Collectively? Sure, but not on an individual basis. That is not a judgment on their quality. This is not a "best" or "favorite" moments list, this is a list for the gay moments in comics that got attention outside the usual comics circles.
As for whether or not super hero comics are dying, that is really another argument. However, for the moment, the great majority of comics sold every month are still super hero books. Just look at Diamond's Top 100 each month...all are super hero titles, with the exception of a few things like Fables. Just sayin'.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/11/2010 12:01 AM
perhaps a follow up list of the 10 most gay moment in the history of Indie comics is in order?
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/09/2010 2:09 PM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 2/15/2011 12:28 PM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/06/2010 8:21 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/08/2010 11:45 AM
Yeah, I'm sure Alan Moore REALLY had a hard time getting through that storyline. Love and Rockets I'm sure REALLY had to fight hard to get their storyline in, etc. etc. (sarcasm)
The most important part was when gay storylines made it into the mainstream. This mean Liefeld was over and the biggest companies in the industry are wiling to treat something like it is the normative part of culture that it is when it used to be trivialized/demonized.
It's a MUCH bigger step forward coming from the big 2 or mainstream superhero comics than it is from indie comics who are writing for a niche audience anyway.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/08/2010 1:34 PM
Independent/alternative/literary/call-'em-what-you-want comics are the future. No, scratch that, they are the *present.* It is they, not the spandex titles, that get reviewed in major newspapers, that are influencing the next generation of cartoonists. So sites like this one, not to mention certain readers, can continue pretending that the only "real," non-"niche" comics are the "Absolute Final Civil Crisis World War of New Multiverse Gods and Wangst" sort. Good luck with that.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/11/2010 8:48 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/09/2010 2:08 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/08/2010 5:19 PM
The paradigm is shifting, but this list has something to do with comic book history, which takes into the account the old and its changes. These are pivotal points in comics history because first and foremost people still regard "comics" as a medium for fantasy.
You'll see many more people picking up the latest Green Lantern this month than you will a Daniel Clowes book.
This, then, boils down to influence. Who has the highest influence? The big 2. So which moments are most important? The ones that happen in the big 2 using characters and people that kids are growing up with. Not characters that, although arguably better and very deep, will just end up as an indie movie.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/09/2010 10:29 AM
Phat and Vivisector from XStatix at 10/18/2011 6:59 AM
Phat and Vivisector from XStatix at 10/18/2011 6:57 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/15/2010 12:46 PM
Namaste,
Lee
Green Lantern and the Gay Bashing at 10/18/2011 6:54 AM
Batman and Robin Secret Love at 10/18/2011 6:51 AM
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 3/08/2010 10:43 AM
Also, how the reintroduction of Batwoman, given its extremely cynical "huh huh lesbos r hawt" press campaign clearly designed to appeal to stereotypical male comics fans whose psychosocial development ended at age 13, can be remotely seen as an empowering event is beyond me.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 12/02/2010 5:25 PM
I would also include Rick Stone's coming-out in DC's (now Milestone's) Static- it came out before the GL story. Also, the writer was made to change it for the children's show because it was too controvertial.
The 10 Most Important Gay Moments in Comic Book History at 12/02/2010 5:17 PM
The Young Avengers Hulkling and Wiccan at 10/18/2011 7:02 AM
Rawhide Kid at 10/18/2011 7:00 AM