The Best Ice Cream Toppings Foods
Ultimate List
12  reranks 6,025 votes 462 voters 46,757 views by  Power
Ranker
more info

The Best Ice Cream Toppings

What are the best ice cream sundae toppings? At a toppings bar, it seems everyone chooses a different combination of syrup, candy, fruit, and nuts. This list of ice cream fixings includes those you absolutely, positively cannot live without. This ice cream sundae toppings list is ranked by fans of food around the world. Your votes decide the popularity of the ice cream bar options, so decide accordingly. Can't nom out without whipped cream? Vote it up! Can't stand nuts, pea or otherwise? Vote them down. And, if you have a personal favorite ice cream topping that isn't listed, by all means, add it!

Vote: The Most Delicious Ice Cream Flavors

Whether your base flavor is vanilla, chocolate, or something wacky, the best ice cream sundae is made by great toppings. Some toppings are from popular ice cream chains and parlors (like Dairy Queen, MaggieMoo's, and Cold Stone Creamery) are just things that people might like to add as part of their own, personal, best ice cream sundae recipes. Not everyone's going to like the same ice cream fixins. Pineapple? Well, that's kind of a toss up, isn't it?

The best frozen yogurt toppings buffet has a variety of options to suit every palate. Some of the most popular ice cream fixins include hot fudge, sprinkles (or jimmies, rainbow or chocolate) and of course, a cherry on top. And yeah, flavored syrups open up a whole new world of ice cream combo possibilities. From chocolate to butterscotch to strawberry, this sweet sauce adds a whole new layer of awesome to an already outstanding sundae.

What are some delicious ice cream sundae toppings? These popular toppings are a hit with ice cream lovers.

Again, vote for your favorites on this best ice cream sundae list. Bon appetit!

Check out more lists like the most delicious ice cream flavors, the best ice cream parlors in America, and even check out which celebrities have their own ice cream flavor
List is ranked by a combination of each item's votes & positioning in reranks
  • 12 ReRanks
    • Women
    • Men
    • Age
    • Region
  • See list ranked by
</> Rerank List
Score
  1. 13
    Up 109
    Down 70
    61
  2. 22
    Up 59
    Down 81
    46
  3. 7
    Up 164
    Down 42

    Brownie bits

    75
  4. 18
    Up 110
    Down 69

    Butterscotch syrup

    53
  5. 35
    Up 18
    Down 16
    31
  6. 4
    Up 187
    Down 42

    Caramel syrup

    91
  7. 30
    Up 30
    Down 46

    often listed
    Cashew

    36
    added by: deligiannismike
  8. 41
    Up 17
    Down 23

    Cheesecake Bites

    29
  9. 40
    Up 16
    Down 19

    new! Cherries

    30
  10. 23
    Up 43
    Down 33

    Cherries

    45
  11. 34
    Up 31
    Down 55
    35
    added by: mergirl54321
  12. 25
    Up 35
    Down 8

    ranked low on reranks
    Chocolate brownie

    40
  13. 21
    Up 37
    Down 11
    49
  14. 9
    Up 125
    Down 71

    Chocolate sprinkles

    69
  15. 2
    Up 191
    Down 50
    93
  16. 24
    Up 64
    Down 89
    43
  17. 31
    Up 28
    Down 14

    ranked low on reranks
    Gummy Bears

    35
  18. 36
    Up 19
    Down 20

    Gummy Worms

    31
  19. 1
    Up 370
    Down 59

    the people's #1 &most listed
    Hot Fudge

    100
  20. 19
    Up 42
    Down 12

    Hot Fudge

    52
  21. 15
    Up 49
    Down 13
    55
    added by: killerbisexualpoptart
  22. 5
    Up 133
    Down 65
    81
  23. 29
    Up 23
    Down 46

    often listed &ranked high on reranks
    Maple Walnut

    37
  24. 6
    Up 139
    Down 76

    Maraschino cherry

    81
  25. 38
    Up 18
    Down 23

    Marshmallows

    30
  26. 37
    Up 18
    Down 20

    Nilla Wafers

    31
  27. 8
    Up 162
    Down 51
    74
  28. 27
    Up 30
    Down 14

    Peanut M&M's

    37
  29. 11
    Up 136
    Down 57
    66
  30. 10
    Up 89
    Down 80

    Peanuts

    68
  31. 28
    Up 41
    Down 96

    often listed &ranked high on reranks
    Pineapple

    37
  32. 14
    Up 69
    Down 25

    Rainbow Sprinkles

    60
    added by: wiabux
  33. 20
    Up 82
    Down 68
    49
  34. 33
    Up 26
    Down 15
    35
  35. 17
    Up 68
    Down 85

    often listed &ranked high on reranks
    Sliced almonds

    54
  36. 39
    Up 17
    Down 24

    Soda

    30
  37. 32
    Up 26
    Down 10

    ranked low on reranks
    Sprinkles

    35
  38. 16
    Up 77
    Down 35
    55
  39. 26
    Up 16
    Down 19

    Strawberry Sauce

    38
  40. 12
    Up 103
    Down 75

    Strawberry sauce

    62
  41. 3
    Up 276
    Down 69
    92
  42. 42 +

    Something missing? Add it!

Is this list missing something?
RANKERS WHO ADDED ITEMS

items 1 - 41 of 41

think you can do better?

Rerank This List
why?

got a blog or website?

embed this list
why?

viewers of this list also saw

more popular lists