- 4 ReRanks
- 2 See list ranked by
- 1+ 139- 22
Erik Gives Up Immunity (Fans Vs. Favorites)Oh Erik the Ice Cream Scooper. He may have been a challenge monster, but he was a naive challenge monster. When this fluffy haired kid got in the way of the infamous Black Widow Brigade, he stood no chance. They played him like a piano. When Cirie (who remains in my top 5 players of all time) turned her eye on him and suggested that they get him to give his immunity to Natalie... even Natalie didn't believe it. I certainly didn't. I thought there was no way Erik would ever do something so hilarious. The logic just... I still don't know how he could have ever thought... it's really amazing. When he gave it up in Tribal, I was on the floor. And the editors showed us every single vote when they were cast, complete with the girls' commentary. Just incredible. Loved it.
- 2+ 141- 25
Pavarti Plays Two Idols (Heros Vs Villains)Too good. Just too good. How great a player is Parvati? Sure, I never really liked her that much before this season -- mostly because she took a lot of credit for all Cirie's machinations in Fans vs. Favorites. That pissed me off. But she IS a great player. This scene alone is all you need to know it. Not like Amanda is a great actress, of course, she was RIDICULOUS when she tried to tell Parv that she should play her idol that night. My 10 year old would have known she was lying. Hilarious! But then, for her to take Russells idol and not tell him she already had her own, brilliant. No one else would have kept that info to themselves. No one else would have given two away to protect their alliance. Amazing how she could read the situation and make the exact right play. Just awesome. What a great, great moment.
- 3+ 127- 21
Jason's Stick (Fans vs. Favorites)
Jason. Jason. Was there ever a more clueless dude to play the game? He came out strong, but... wow. When Ozzy scratched that face into a stick and hid it in the Idol's spot, I barely took notice. No way was someone going to think that thing was an idol, and Ozzy was going to be outed as soon as whoever found it as having the thing. That didn't happen because BrainTrust Jason found it, and -- to the shock of the editors, the producers and everyone watching at home -- he just thought he'd found the real thing. When he gave it to Eliza to play... her reaction is one of the funniest things I've ever witnessed. When he went to get it and show it to her, I was breathless with anticipation over what she was going to say. Wow. Just... wow. She did not disappoint.
- 4+ 121- 32
J.T. Gives Idol to Russell (Heroes & Villains)This was spectacular on so many levels. Watching JT just assume that Russell was alone in his tribe, that he was struggling for his position... that was funny enough. But that it was RUSSELL he was offering to save, that he actually GAVE AWAY his idol to RUSSELL. I am still laughing just thinking about it. Sure, I know that JT didn't know Russell and had not, at that point, seen Russell's season and how he played... but come ON. That was a spectacularly risky thing to do, and had about a 5% chance of working. JT should have known better. Plus... the letter itself sounded like JT was writing a furtive love letter. It was so good, and so hilarious. They could not have scripted something better.
- 5+ 108- 26
Randy Plays Bob's Fake Idol (Gabon)Raise your hand if you hated Randy. He was horrid, angry, awful, misogynist, and just an asshole. So when Sugar saw the chance to feed him Bob's fake idol, she took it. And Bob's idol was no stick with a face on it. It looked LEGIT. Randy took it and played it, and wow, SO SATISFYING. Make sure to watch all the faces in this clip. Just. Fantastic.
- 6+ 96- 24
James Blindsided With Two Idols (China)This was tragic. And awesome. How do you have TWO idols and not play even one of them? Ask James Clement. One of the blindsides to beat all blindsides.
- 7+ 95- 25
Stephanie Is the Last Member of Her Tribe (Palau)Stephanie's tribe was lame in Palau. The lamest of the lame. So lame their tribe name of Ulong has gone down in Survivor history as one of, if not THE, worst tribes ever. They never won a single challenge. And Stephanie... the toughest one on their tribe ended up being the last one standing. It was awesome to watch her struggle as hard as humanly possible to win for her tribe and have them fail around her, every time. Stephanie's story is epic. And the producers' cruelty to not let the merge happen until after she was all alone was kind of brilliant TV.
- 8+ 91- 29
Fairplay's Dead Grandma (Pearl Islands)Classic moment that will never be forgotten in the Annals of Survivor History. Jon's dead grandmother.