Top All-Time Players To Build Team Around Baseball Players

Top All-Time Players To Build Team Around

2,179 views 50 items 69reranks
We started a friendly debate but it quickly escalated into a slap fight... The question: "If you were building a team, what player would you pick to build your team around?" There were five of us in the slap fight, so we did "One Potato" to see who would pick where. That's what got us to put this together... So, your task is to pick your #1 guy to build your franchise around. Imagine that the guy is just about to go into his prime - so he's at his best. And we'll take some of the pressure off - you can pick your Top Five to be your #1... Feel free to add a player to the list. Good luck and no slap fights!
< >
Show:   25   100
  • the list
  • comments
  • </> embed
Rerank This List
View as a
Rank   Name
  1. 1
    1925 More
    #24 on the ultimate list
  2. 2
    1934 More
    #6 on the ultimate list
  3. 3
    1974 More
    #43 on the ultimate list
  4. 4
    1918 More
    #2 on the ultimate list
  5. 5
    1895 More
    #1 on the ultimate list
  6. 6
    1975 More
    #90 on the ultimate list
  7. 7
    1964 More
    #58 on the ultimate list
  8. 8
    1903 More
    #4 on the ultimate list
  9. 9
    1874 More
    #10 on the ultimate list
  10. 10
    1941 More
    #20 on the ultimate list
  11. 11
    1931 More
    #3 on the ultimate list
  12. 12
    1969 More
    #17 on the ultimate list
  13. 13
    1958 More
    #28 on the ultimate list
  14. 14
    1980 More
    #44 on the ultimate list
  15. 15
    1935 More
    #26 on the ultimate list
  16. 16
    1934 More
    #15 on the ultimate list
  17. 17
    1944 More
    #25 on the ultimate list
  18. 18
    1935 More
    #16 on the ultimate list
  19. 19
    1947 More
    #18 on the ultimate list
  20. 20
    1984 More
    #139 on the ultimate list
  21. 21
    1991 More
    #100 on the ultimate list
  22. 22
    1988 More
  23. 23
    1992 More
  24. 24
    1983 More
    #185 on the ultimate list
  25. 25
    1985 More
    #141 on the ultimate list

items 1 - 25 of 50

think you can do better?

Rerank This List
why?

got a blog or website?

embed this list
why?

viewers of this list also saw

from our partners

more popular lists