Heartthrobs From The '90s Ranked By How Much We're Still Crushing

Voting Rules
Vote up the former heartthrobs you're still way into.

Was there a better era for heartthrobs than the '90s? The decade was a magical time for teen boys who were total dreamboats. But as hot as your fave '90s boy toy may have been on TGIF, would you hook up with your '90s crush now? Not only are you different people these days, but most of your boy crushes from the '90s peaked in 1996. What do your '90s crushes look like now? And do you really want to spend a night in Sherman Oaks making out with a guy who won't stop talking about the buffet at Danielle Fishel's wedding?

Is your '90s boy crush still hot? You want to pretend like it doesn’t matter. You want to act like nothing's changed, even if they no longer resemble that Tiger Beat poster you smooched every day before leaving to catch the bus. But deep down, you know you can’t stop thinking about whether Devon Sawa still has those haunting eyes, or if he just looks haunted. Read to the end to find out if your '90s teen boy crushes are still cutie pies, and maybe consider printing out this list and taping it to your mirror. No judgment.

Photo: Universal Pictures / Shutterstock.com

  • 1
    44,385 VOTES

    Then: Back in the '90s, this curly-haired waif jumpstarted puberty for a nation of sixth graders, and the world is better for it. Maybe Justin Timberlake's bleached white hair was questionable, but who cares when he's got a smile that can turn on the sun. 

    Now: It took almost two decades, but Timberlake finally learned what not to do with his hair. He's still looking good, still insanely successful, and that smile is still poppin'. 

    Would You Still Hit It?: Will he wear marionette strings? Either way, yes.

    • Age: 42
    • Birthplace: Memphis, Tennessee, United States of America
    • Credits: Love Actually, Get Smart, Inside Llewyn Davis, Bad Boys II
    44,385 votes
  • 2
    43,403 VOTES
    Mark-Paul Gosselaar
    Photo: NBC / ABC

    Then: MPG was already a little old in the '90s to be a heartthrob, but who cares when he can freeze time and has that immaculate sandy blond hair?

    Now: After Saved by the BellGosselaar managed to keep himself from turning into a joke by taking jobs on a ton of different shows. He's appeared in everything from his very own USA lawyer show to Happy Endings - and he still has that hair.

    Would You Still Hit It?: Sure, as long as he didn't try to pull any "time out" stunts.

    • Age: 49
    • Birthplace: Panorama City, California, USA
    • Credits: Saved by the Bell,NYPD Blue,Franklin & Bash,Dead Man on Campus
    43,403 votes
  • 3
    43,159 VOTES

    Then: Did Leonardo DiCaprio come out of the womb with a squinty pout? It's pointless to argue about whether or not Leo was a babe in the '90s. The only conversation to have is which Leo do you think is hotter: Romeo, Jack, or Arnie?

    Now: Leo can still be hot when he wants to be, but he's moved from "steaming hot piece of meat" more into the realm of "serious, Oscar-winning actor." 

    Would You Still Hit It?: Of course you would! It's not like the beard from The Revenant is that much of a turn-off.

    • Age: 48
    • Birthplace: Los Angeles, California
    • Credits: Inception, The Wolf of Wall Street, Titanic, The Departed
    43,159 votes
  • 4
    41,731 VOTES
    James Van Der Beek
    Photo: The WB / ABC

    Then: Was James Van Der Beek actually hot in the '90s, or was his hotness simply a creation of Big Heartthrob? He's arguably not the hottest guy on Dawson's Creek, but somehow he became the guy. The '90s were weird. 

    Now: More like James Van Der Babe, right? The Beek has somehow reinvented himself into a hot basic bro who has a sense of humor. Who said there were no second acts? 

    Would You Still Hit It?: Turn up the Paula Cole and let's get weird. 

    • Age: 46
    • Birthplace: Cheshire, Connecticut, United States of America
    • Credits: Dawson's Creek,Castle in the Sky,The Rules of Attraction,Varsity Blues
    41,731 votes
  • 5
    40,075 VOTES

    Then: Devon Sawa was such a '90s spooky babe; if you were into ghosts, demon-infested hands, or movies where death slowly stalked a group of sexy teens, then you had a whole thing for Sawa. Why was he such a babe? It probably had something to do with that ocean wave-styled hair part. 

    Now: After his heyday came to an end, Sawa seemed like he was doing anything he could to keep from becoming a child actor cliché. Apparently that means mostly playing detectives and guys that scowl. Good for him. 

    Would You Still Hit It?: Bring back the tidal wave hair and we'll talk.

    • Age: 44
    • Birthplace: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
    • Credits: Final Destination, Idle Hands, Slackers, Extreme Ops
    40,075 votes
  • 6
    40,591 VOTES

    Then: Freddie Prinze, Jr. was a jock with heart of gold, and a lot of pre-teens in the '90s were totally into that - at least, until he put on a yellow Fred Jones wig and freaked everyone out. 

    Now: After the '90s, Prinze more or less disappeared from the film world to do voiceover work, have kids with Sarah Michelle Gellar, and count his money. He's the one heartthrob who figured out how to get out of this world alive.

    Would You Still Hit It?: That depends on how you feel about someone calling you "bro" mid-hookup.

    • Age: 47
    • Birthplace: Los Angeles, California, United States of America
    • Credits: Scooby-Doo, She's All That, I Know What You Did Last Summer, I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
    40,591 votes