Harry Potter

19 Actors Who Were Incredibly Close To Playing Harry Potter Characters 

Zack Howe
May 8, 2017 46k views 19 items

Believe it or not, there actually were some British people who weren't in Harry Potter. Behind-the-scenes stories are shared about the actors who nearly landed parts in the series, but didn't due to scheduling or a director's vision. Some Americans even got close to snagging some famous roles, though any fan who knows their Harry Potter facts can tell you that author J.K. Rowling wouldn't have stood for that.

It's fun to speculate about some of the actors offered Harry Potter roles. What if Harry was American? What if Hermione hadn’t been played by Emma Watson? What if Sir Ian McKellen had been Dumbledore? Even the late, great Robin Williams numbers among the actors almost in Harry Potter.

True, some actors missed out on big roles in the Harry Potter universe. But the movies are arguably perfect the way they are, continuing to win over viewers and inspire countless pieces of fan art. Most movie-goers wouldn't have their Harry Potter casts any other way.

back to page 1
Kate Winslet is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list 19 Actors Who Were Incredibly Close To Playing Harry Potter Characters
Photo: Paramount Pictures/Warner Bros.

According to reports, Kate Winslet was asked to appear as the ghost of Rowena Ravenclaw in the final Harry Potter film. Apparently, her reps rejected the offer without even telling her.

More Kate Winslet 

#118 of 320 The Most Beautiful Women Of 2020, Ranked #3 of 185 The Best Living English Actresses The Best Kate Winslet Movies

Ian McKellen is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list 19 Actors Who Were Incredibly Close To Playing Harry Potter Characters
Photo: New Line Cinema/Warner Bros.

Sir Ian McKellen proved he knew his way around a wizardly role with The Lord of the Rings. He was reportedly offered the part of Dumbledore after Richard Harris passed away, but politely turned it down. His reason? Harris didn't approve of his acting, and McKellen didn't think it would be appropriate to take over his character.

More Ian McKellen 

#101 of 330 The Coolest Actors Ever #16 of 282 The Best (Male) Actors Working Today

Hatty Jones is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list 19 Actors Who Were Incredibly Close To Playing Harry Potter Characters
Photo: TriStar Pictures/Warner Bros.

Hatty Jones starred in the 1998 film version of Madeline. She auditioned for the role of Hermione, and seemed a shoo-in for the role, but the part went to the unknown Emma Watson instead.

Robin Williams is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list 19 Actors Who Were Incredibly Close To Playing Harry Potter Characters
Photo: TriStar Pictures/Warner Bros.

Apparently, Robin Williams reached out to Warner Bros. with an offer to play Hagrid. But the studio decided to enforce a strict "Brits only" policy, and the role of the half-giant caretaker went to Robbie Coltrane instead.

More Robin Williams 

#45 of 274 The Most Trustworthy Celebrities in the World #7 of 1,139 The Best Actors in Film History The Best Ever Robin Williams Movies