Actors Whose Deaths Became Storylines  

Ann Casano
1.2M views 15 items

It’s bound to happen: unfortunately, people pass away, sometimes suddenly. Characters get killed off television programs all the time, but what happens when an actor dies in real life? Plots need to be reworked and producers must decide if a replacement character needs to step in. Here are 15 actors whose deaths became storylines.

There have been several iconic TV actors who died during their shows: John Ritter, Phil Hartman, Redd Foxx. But how were their deaths handled and could the show survive without them? In all of the above cases, the shows did not make it very far without their star actors. 8 Simple Rules lasted only one more season without Ritter, NewsRadio also just one more season, and The Royal Family did not even complete the rest of Season One without Foxx’s star power.

Of course, then there are the shows that delay the announcement of a character’s death while producers and writers try to figure out how they are going to reshape the show’s storyline. After Freddie Prinze’s shocking suicide, producers from Chico and the Man simply explained away his absence, until his death was addressed on the program one year after Prinze died. Producers from the nighttime soap Dallas did the same after Jim Davis (patriarch Jock Ewing) passed away.

There are a couple of film actors worth mentioning on this list as well, when narratives needed to be reworked because the actor died during the movie’s production. 

Check out the different ways an actor's death can be handled by the TV or film writers he leaves behind.
Phil Hartman is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Actors Whose Deaths Became Storylines
Photo:  NBC

Phil Hartman died in 1998 after being shot by his wife, Brynn Hartman. At the time of his death, Hartman played news anchor Bill McNeal on the comedy NewsRadio. His death was addressed during the premiere of Season 5 in an episode called "Bill Moves On," where it's revealed that McNeal died from a heart attack.

After McNeil's funeral, each character reads personal notes left for them by the news anchor. The producers opted to replace Hartman's character with fellow SNL alum Jon Lovitz, who played an old friend of McNeal's. NewsRadio wrapped after its fifth season.

More Phil Hartman

#22 of 362 on The Funniest People of All Time #85 of 297 on Which Actor Would You Bring Back for One Final Movie? #4 of 96 on The Best SNL Cast Members of All Time featuring All the Films You Might Remember Troy McClure From

see more on Phil Hartman
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Cory Monteith died in 2013 at the age of 31 from a drug overdose. He passed before the start of Season 5 of Glee. Initially, producers opted to delay shooting the new season so they could figure out how to handle Finn Hudson's storyline. They opted to not mention Finn's death until the third episode of the season, after the two-part Beatles premiere episode. In the end, producers ultimately decided not to reveal exactly how Finn died.

In a move that mirrored real life, Rachel Berry (Lea Michele) sang the tear-filled "Make You Feel My Love." Finn's stepbrother Kurt said during the show's opening scene, "Everyone wants to talk about how he died, but who cares? It's one moment in his whole life." The show's lack of closure regarding Finn's death was met with some fan outrage. Glee's co-creator Ryan Murphy explained the producer's tough decision on how to deal with Finn's death: "How somebody died is interesting and maybe morbid, but we say very early on in the episode, 'This is about a celebration of that character's life.' That might be weird for some people, but it felt really exploitative to do it any other way."

More Cory Monteith

#11 of 18 on Rank All of Taylor Swift's Exes #12 of 15 on The Oldest Actors Cast As High Schoolers, Ranked By How Much They Aren't Fooling Anyone #37 of 81 on Famous Taurus Male Celebrities #84 of 432 on Famous Tall Men Over 6'2

see more on Cory Monteith
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

John Ritter died of complications from an aortic dissection in 2003 at the age of 55. At the time of his death, Ritter played a sports writer by the name of Paul Hennessy on the sitcom 8 Simple Rules for Dating My Teenage Daughter. He was in the middle of a rehearsal during the second season when he complained of pain and needed to be taken to the hospital.

On the show, Ritter's character suffers from a heart condition and dies in an episode titled "Goodbye." The sitcom continued on without Ritter. Several different replacement characters followed including James Garner, who played Paul's father, and David Spade. The sitcom even changed its name to 8 Simple Rules. The show never recovered from Ritter's death, however, and was subsequently cancelled after the third season in 2005.

More John Ritter

#88 of 932 on People We Wish Were Still Alive #28 of 297 on Which Actor Would You Bring Back for One Final Movie? #35 of 72 on Surviving Tragedy: Resilient Children of Dead Celebrities #17 of 34 on The Funniest Slapstick Comedians of All Time

see more on John Ritter
Redd Foxx is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Actors Whose Deaths Became Storylines
Photo: CBS

Redd Foxx died of a heart attack at the age of 69 while filming his comeback series The Royal Family. The sitcom was only seven episodes into its premiere season when Foxx collapsed on the set during rehearsal. Jackée Harry was brought in as a replacement for Foxx (who played the character Al), as the younger sister to Al's wife, Victoria. Harry's character was there to help her sister deal with the loss of her husband, and his passing became a storyline in the show.

The retooling of the show was unsuccessful, however, and was cancelled later that same season.


More Redd Foxx

#60 of 362 on The Funniest People of All Time #17 of 411 on The Funniest Stand Up Comedians of All Time #35 of 80 on The Best African American Actors in Film #24 of 83 on The Greatest Actors Who Have Never Won an Emmy (For Acting)

see more on Redd Foxx