Graveyard Shift

Actors Who Played Satan, Ranked By How Much The Devil Would Approve 

Brent Sprecher
Updated November 29, 2018 48.3k votes 9.5k voters 122.6k views 24 items

List Rules Vote up the performances that the Dark Prince himself would applaud

Satan. Lucifer. The Evil One. Mephistopheles. The Prince of Darkness. Old Scratch. Whatever you call him, historians claim that Satan has preoccupied humanity since roughly 2000 BCE.

The eternal nemesis of all that is right and good, the Devil has been the key figure in countless poems, plays, and novels throughout history and is equally prominent in modern cinema. Actors who have played the Devil include some of the most revered of all time, though their portrayals of Satan on film are as different as the many names and incarnations of the Beast himself. 

Peter Stormare is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Actors Who Played Satan, Ranked By How Much The Devil Would Approve
Photo:  Warner Bros.

In many movie appearances, the Devil is depicted in the midst of one of his many plots to corrupt humanity and rule the Earth. In Constantine, Peter Stormare's creepy casually Lucifer only wants one thing: exorcist John Constantine's (Keanu Reeves) immortal soul.

Resurrected after a suicide attempt in his teens, John believes he can "buy" his way into heaven if he uses his abilities to wage war against the demons that attempt to influence humanity before the cancer in his lungs kills him a second time.

In order to stop an even worse fate from befalling the Earth, John commits suicide a second time to warn Lucifer about those conspiring against him. To reward John, Lucifer grants him one favor. Rather than use the favor to save himself, he uses it selflessly, which grants him admission into heaven. Furious, Lucifer heals John and cures him of cancer so that he will live long enough to earn his place in Hell once again, proving the adage "the Devil is patient."

Critics were quick to damn the film, while others, like Peter Travers of Rolling Stone, said it still managed to "scare up some devilish fun."



More Peter Stormare 

#18 of 25 The 25 Best Comic Book Villain Movie Performances of All Time #1,813 of 2,004 The Greatest Actors & Actresses in Entertainment History #256 of 465 Celebrities You Didn't Know Use Stage Names

Mark Pellegrino is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Actors Who Played Satan, Ranked By How Much The Devil Would Approve
Photo:  Supernatural/Warner Bros. Television

The long-running TV series Supernatural changed the established origin of the Devil in several ways, including having Lucifer initially battle alongside Heaven's archangels against the Darkness, an evil older than God. Rather than destroy the evil, God locked it away with a mark that he gave to Lucifer, and it was the Darkness that corrupted Lucifer and caused him to argue with God and be cast out of Heaven.

The version of the character Mark Pellegrino portrays appears in Season 5 of the series, when Lucifer inhabits a depressed widower named Nick. Pellegrino's Devil claims he is the victim of God's capricious nature and not evil incarnate as he is portrayed. His essence proves to be too powerful for Nick's human body, however, and it degrades and he eventually dies. Six seasons later, demons reconstitute and reinforce Nick's body to use as a permanent vessel for Lucifer.


More Mark Pellegrino 

#670 of 771 American Public Figures Who Are National Treasures #5 of 19 How the Cast of 'Supernatural' Has Aged from the First Season to Now #26 of 50 Male Celebrities Who Are 6’1"

Al Pacino is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Actors Who Played Satan, Ranked By How Much The Devil Would Approve
Photo: The Devil's Advocate/Warner Bros.

Al Pacino plays the Devil as one John Milton, which is also the name of the English writer who penned the epic 1667 poem Paradise Lost about the Fall of Man. Pacino plays Satan as a slick-talking head of a successful New York City law firm giving the Devil a modern take. But Pacino's Devil is still up to his old tricks as he tempts Kevin Lomax (Keanu Reeves) with promises of material wealth and power while simultaneously destroying his loving wife's (Charlize Theron) sanity. The Devil's endgame in the movie is about as horrible and terrifying as they come: to have his son Kevin sleep with his half-sister to conceive the Antichrist.

Pacino's version of Satan is a slippery conman. As James Kendrick of Q Network Film Desk noted, "Pacino puts on a great show, investing enough in his character to make him evil, but not so much that we think he's truly serious."


More Al Pacino 

The Best Al Pacino Movies #35 of 289 The Best (Male) Actors Working Today #27 of 181 The Best Living American Actors

Tom Ellis is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Actors Who Played Satan, Ranked By How Much The Devil Would Approve
Photo:  Lucifer/Warner Bros. Television
Tom Ellis, 'Lucifer' (2016- )

Instead of a relentless force of evil perpetually scheming to take over the Earth and topple God from Heaven, Tom Ellis's version of the Devil on the Fox TV series Lucifer is more of a bored absentee CEO slumming with humans for some different sort of thrills.

Based on the popular comic book, Ellis's Lucifer Morningstar abdicated his throne in Hell to run a nightclub in Los Angeles called "Lux." He becomes infatuated with an LAPD detective (Lauren German) when he discovers his powers of persuasion don't work on her. Ellis's Devil typically presents as a very suave, good-looking human with a witty sense of humor, but his true demonic nature comes out every so often.


More Tom Ellis 

#26 of 256 The Hottest Men Of 2020, Ranked #87 of 242 The Hottest Men Of 2019, Ranked #171 of 532 Famous Men You'd Want to Have a Beer With