Total Nerd Actors Who Almost Got the Part in a Marvel Film  

Ranker Comics
52.2k votes 3.4k voters 1.4M views 20 items

List Rules Vote up the actors you wish had gotten the Marvel role.

Casting is truly an art form. Each and every cast member from starring, to supporting, to day-player affects the entire tone of the film. What would Tony Stark be without Robert Downey, Jr. who had to fight to be cast? And what would Marvel be without Iron Man's raging success? What would the superhero genre be without The Avengers movies redefining them? What would cinema be without the superhero tentpole? Casting is everything, and the actors on this list couldn't make the cut. If you want to see would-be casting choices for non-Marvel characters, check out this list of actors that almost played superheroes.

These are all of the shadows of that ideal, the people who were ALMOST legends, who almost had action figures and multi-picture deals and 10-year contracts, the actors up for Marvel films. These are the people who, for one reason or another, didn't end up playing the great characters of the comic book world.

Which actors almost became Marvel film heroes and villains? These films went on to be made, not ending up on the list of comic book movies we never saw, but the actors and actresses listed here weren't part of the fun. Which of these stars do you wish you had seen in Marvel hero and villain roles? Cast your votes below!
1 1,627 VOTES
Anne Hathaway is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Actors Who Almost Got the Part in a Marvel Film
Photo:  Mingle MediaTV/Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 2.0

Cast as: The Black Cat

Before she was Catwoman, she was the Black Cat. It's funny that she went from one comic publisher's take on a cat-burgling villain to the another's. When Spider-Man 4 fell apart, so did this role.
1,105 522
Wish they got the part?
see more on Anne Hathaway
2 1,607 VOTES
Summer Glau is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Actors Who Almost Got the Part in a Marvel Film
Photo:  Gage Skidmore/Flickr/CC BY-SA 2.0

Considered for: Kitty Pryde

Joss Whedon's favorite character, Kitty Pryde, was almost played by one of his alumna: “So the girl I turned into sort of a superhero in my movie was going to read for the character that most influenced ALL my girl-heroes, Kitty Pryde. Karmically funky. Anyhoo, she called me after and said it was very emotional and kind of like when she read for 'Firefly,' she just got into a very intense groove. She started telling me about the scene she read and that’s when I realized why it was kind of like she read for 'Firefly.'”

It turns out they had adapted Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men #5 for the sides.

1,074 533
Wish they got the part?
see more on Summer Glau
3 1,550 VOTES
Alice Eve is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Actors Who Almost Got the Part in a Marvel Film
Photo:  Gerald Geronimo/Flickr/CC BY-SA 2.0

Was cast as: Emma Frost

This was something else entirely. Before we saw January Jones zombie-walk through the role of Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class, they had something else in mind. Alice Eve had actually been cast and had even been on set. It was rumored she had even filmed some scenes, when dozens of rewrites came through, and she felt the part was no longer worthwhile, as the character was basically being relegated to a scantily clad sidekick. So, Alice Eve walked away and January Jones... happened.

1,026 524
Wish they got the part?
see more on Alice Eve
4 1,309 VOTES
Rachael Leigh Cook is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Actors Who Almost Got the Part in a Marvel Film
Photo:  Lloyd Klein/Flickr/CC BY 2.0

Considered for: Rogue

How different the X-Men films would have been with Rachel Leigh Cook as Rogue instead of "True Blood's" Anna Paquin. She was outright offered the role when a slew of young stars were vying for it, including Sarah Michelle Gellar and Katherine Isabelle, but ended up turning it down, thinking there would be too much CGI involved.
800 509
Wish they got the part?
see more on Rachael Leigh Cook