Actresses 20 Actresses Who Pretty Much Play Themselves In All Of Their Films  

Lisa Waugh
1.2k votes 526 voters 7.8k views 20 items

List Rules Vote up the actresses who seem most similar IRL to the characters they play.

The entertainment industry isn’t known for churning out tons of interesting roles for women; although, it’s getting better to some degree. This, in part, creates a situation in which actresses who are a lot like their characters get pigeonholed into roles. The biggest culprit is profits. To guarantee box office returns, studios tend to play it safe and choose actresses who are the same as their characters. If the picture needs a hopeful mother, call Jennifer Garner. If it calls for a quirky millennial, call Ellen Page. Fair or not, that’s how a lot of films get made, and even the greatest American actresses are not exempt. It has become what audiences expect. 

One shining example of actresses known for roles similar to their real personalities is Felicia Snoop Pearson from The Wire. After meeting Wire star Kenneth Michael Williams at a Baltimore bar, Snoop found her way onto the series, playing a version of herself. Jennifer Lopez probably solves crime at night on the way to set, right? And every time we see Kristen Stewart, she's in the middle of something important and doesn’t want to be bothered, okay? 

Melissa McCarthy, Cameron Diaz, and Zooey Deschanel are just a few examples of actresses who are a lot like their characters... we’re guessing. It feels true, anyway. 

Anne Hathaway is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 20 Actresses Who Pretty Much Play Themselves In All Of Their Films
Photo: BBC/Warner Bros.

In real life: Can’t tell if she’s on all the time or an excellent piece of A.I., but Hathaway appears to be so nice and happy that it’s creepy. 

In film and TV roles: She roamed the edges of edgy in Rachel Getting Married and Les Miz, but it's hard to buy Hathaway as deeply unhappy onscreen. We don’t know about her as a person, though. Maybe she cries into a large, expensive pillow hourly to make way for that million-watt smile. Even getting stuck in space with Matthew McConaughey didn’t dampen her spirits. Hopefully, she’ll be allowed to cut loose one day and play the serial killer she’s capable of portraying. 

Notable quote: “There's something very addictive about people pleasing. It's a thought pattern and a habit that feels really, really good until it becomes desperate.”

Also Ranked

#2 on The Best American Actresses Working Today

#94 on The Best Actresses in Film History

#34 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#43 on The Hottest Celebrities of All Time

412 12
Agree or disagree?
see more on Anne Hathaway
Jennifer Garner is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 20 Actresses Who Pretty Much Play Themselves In All Of Their Films
Photo: NBC/Sony

In real life: The girl next door married Ben Affleck, had three children with him, and then realized that nannies just can’t be trusted. Like many ladies on this list, Garner is one of those people whose brand is niceness. 

In film and TV roles: And she can’t escape it, which is fine with audiences. We don’t normally see the gritty side of Garner as most of her roles are an extension of her wholesomeness. Now that’s she’s dropped Ben, it might be time for some onscreen cussing and fighting. 

Notable quote:I do all my own stunts!”

Also Ranked

#71 on The Best American Actresses Working Today

#68 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#87 on The Hottest Celebrities of All Time

#40 on The Most Trustworthy Celebrities in the World

22 26
Agree or disagree?
see more on Jennifer Garner
Scarlett Johansson is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 20 Actresses Who Pretty Much Play Themselves In All Of Their Films
Photo: NBC/Disney

In real life: Johansson leads a fairly measured life, avoiding scandal while also being accessible. She’s the girl you want to have a cocktail with or marry. 

In film and TV roles: Neither method or simply a movie star, Johansson commands a presence onscreen. Whether she’s donning a super hero leather jumpsuit or her underwear in a Japanese hotel room, Scar-Jo is always fully formed as Scar-Jo, smoky of both voice and eye.

Notable quote: “I just want to work on things that are really hard, and when I'm not working on things that are really hard, I want to hang out with people I like to be with, and that's it.”

Also Ranked

#23 on The Best American Actresses Working Today

#22 on The Most Beautiful Women of All Time

#1 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#1 on The Hottest Celebrities of All Time

24 29
Agree or disagree?
see more on Scarlett Johansson
Zooey Deschanel is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 20 Actresses Who Pretty Much Play Themselves In All Of Their Films
Photo: NBC/Dreamworks

In real life: Adorable nerd princess with a lovely voice everyone wants to either date, marry, or be besties with. What's more, Zooey Deschanel, like her characters, always seems to have more up her sleeve than you expect, given her scatter-brained nature – she plays ukelele, works 16-hour days, and gets really irritated when people assume she can't be a feminist and girlie at the same time.  

In film and TV roles: Since audiences first laid eyes on her in Mumford in 1999, Deschanel seems to have been caught in amber, with her hands on her hips, her bangs freshly shorn, and her head cocked to the side.  

Notable quote: “If I'm going to be 'too' anything, 'too cute' is fine. I love puppies. So what? Who hates puppies?”

Also Ranked

#65 on The Most Beautiful Women of All Time

#72 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#35 on The Hottest Celebrities of All Time

#35 on The Most Trustworthy Celebrities in the World

49 66
Agree or disagree?
see more on Zooey Deschanel