107 voters

The Best Alyson Hannigan Movies

Updated June 11, 2019 801 votes 107 voters 9.1k views17 items

List RulesVote for your favorite movies, regardless of critic reviews or how big the role was.

List of the best Alyson Hannigan movies, ranked best to worst with movie trailers when available. Alyson Hannigan's highest grossing movies have received a lot of accolades over the years, earning millions upon millions around the world. The order of these top Alyson Hannigan movies is decided by how many votes they receive, so only highly rated Alyson Hannigan movies will be at the top of the list. Alyson Hannigan has been in a lot of films, so people often debate each other over what the greatest Alyson Hannigan movie of all time is. If you and a friend are arguing about this then use this list of the most entertaining Alyson Hannigan films to end the squabble once and for all.

If you think the best Alyson Hannigan role isn't at the top, then upvote it so it has the chance to become number one. The greatest Alyson Hannigan performances didn't necessarily come from the best movies, but in most cases they go hand in hand.

Examples include In the Game and Farce of the Penguins.

"This list answers the questions, "What are the best Alyson Hannigan movies?" and "What are the greatest Alyson Hannigan roles of all time?"


  • 1

    My Stepmother Is an Alien

    Alyson Hannigan, Kim Basinger


    Directed byRichard Benjamin

    My Stepmother is an Alien is a 1988 American comedy science fiction film produced by the Weintraub Entertainment Group for release through Columbia Pictures, directed by Richard Benjamin and starring...  more

    More My Stepmother Is an Alien 

    #158 of 305 The Funniest '80s Movies#327 of 512 The Greatest Movies Of The 1980s, Ranked

  • 2

    Dead Man on Campus

    Alyson Hannigan, Poppy Montgomery


    Directed byAlan Cohn

    This filmd is a 1998 dark comedy film starring Mark-Paul Gosselaar and Tom Everett Scott. It centers on the urban legend that a student gets straight As if his or her roommate who take his own life....  more
  • 3

    The Stranger Beside Me

    Alyson Hannigan, Tiffani Thiessen


    Directed bySandor Stern

    The Stranger Beside Me is a 1995 American made for television movie that stars Tiffani Amber Thiessen as a young newlywed who suspects her charming husband is not as charming or innocent as he seems....  more
  • 4

    Boys and Girls

    Alyson Hannigan, Claire Forlani


    Directed byRobert Iscove

    Boys and Girls is a romantic comedy film that was released in 2000, directed by Robert Iscove. The two main characters, Ryan and Jennifer meet each other initially as adolescents, and later realize...  more
  • 5

    Impure Thoughts

    Alyson Hannigan
  • 6

    Love, Wedding, Marriage

    Julia Roberts, Mandy Moore


    Directed byDermot Mulroney

    Love, Wedding, Marriage is a 2011 American romantic comedy film directed by Dermot Mulroney and starring Mandy Moore, Kellan Lutz, James Brolin, Jane Seymour and Christopher Lloyd....  more
  • 7

    In the Game

    Jennifer Love Hewitt, Alyson Hannigan


    In the Game was a proposed sitcom that was to have been produced for ABC by Touchstone Television and was to star Jennifer Love Hewitt as an up-and-coming sports producer and single mother who...  more
  • 8

    Switched at Birth

    Alyson Hannigan, Allison Mack


    Directed byWaris Hussein

    Switched at Birth is a 1991 American television film directed by Waris Hussein. It is based on the true story of Kimberly Mays and Arlena Twigg, babies switched soon after birth in a Florida hospital...  more
  • 9

    Rip It Off

    Alyson Hannigan, Nastassja Kinski


    Directed byGigi Gaston

  • 10

    For My Daughter's Honor

    Alyson Hannigan, Sara Rue


    Directed byAlan Metzger

    For My Daughter's Honor, also released as Indecent Seduction, is a 1996 American television film directed by Alan Metzger....  more
  • 11

    A Case for Life

    Alyson Hannigan, Valerie Bertinelli


    Directed byEric Laneuville

    A Case for Life is a 1996 film directed by Eric Laneuville....
  • 12

    Date Movie

    Carmen Electra, Alyson Hannigan


    Directed byAaron Seltzer, Jason Friedberg

    Date Movie is a 2006 American parody film directed by Aaron Seltzer. Much of the story line was based on that of the romantic comedy My Big Fat Greek Wedding and Meet the Fockers. It stars Alyson...  more

    More Date Movie 

    #5 of 44 The Worst Movies Released on Valentine's Day#20 of 23 The Best Fat Movies

  • 13

    Farce of the Penguins

    Christina Applegate, Whoopi Goldberg


    Directed byBob Saget

    Farce of the Penguins is a 2007 American direct-to-video parody of the 2005 French documentary film March of the Penguins. The film features Samuel L. Jackson as narrator, with the two main...  more

    More Farce of the Penguins 

    #51 of 119 The Best Samuel L. Jackson Movies, Ranked List#10 of 181 The Best R-Rated Parody Movies

  • 14

    American Pie

    Alyson Hannigan, Tara Reid


    Directed byChris Weitz, Paul Weitz

    American Pie is a 1999 teen comedy film written by Adam Herz and directed by brothers Paul and Chris Weitz, in their directorial film debut. It is the first film in the American Pie theatrical...  more

    More American Pie 

    'American Pie' Is A Nightmarish Vision Of Late '90s High School Life#349 of 549 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made

  • 15

    American Wedding

    Alyson Hannigan, January Jones


    Directed byJesse Dylan

    American Wedding is a 2003 American romantic comedy film and a sequel to American Pie and American Pie 2 as part of the American Pie theatrical series. It was written by Adam Herz and directed by...  more

    More American Wedding 

    #509 of 925 The All-Time Greatest Comedy Films#543 of 1,506 The Most Rewatchable Movies

  • 16

    American Reunion

    Alyson Hannigan, Neil Patrick Harris


    Directed byHayden Schlossberg, Jon Hurwitz

    American Reunion is a 2012 ensemble comedy film written and directed by Jon Hurwitz and Hayden Schlossberg. It is the fourth installment in the American Pie theatrical series and eighth installment...  more
  • 17

    American Pie 2

    Alyson Hannigan, Tara Reid


    Directed byJames B. Rogers

    American Pie 2 is a 2001 American comedy film and the sequel to the 1999 film American Pie and the second film in the American Pie film series. It was written by Adam Herz and directed by James B....  more

    More American Pie 2 

    #78 of 182 The Best Movie Sequels Ever Made#8 of 13 12 Comedy Sequels That Might Actually Be Better Than The Originals