Anime Underground

13 Anime That Greatly Differ From The Manga They're Based On  

Anna Lindwasser
1.7k votes 570 voters 17.3k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up the anime that diverge the most from their manga source material.

Though many anime derive from manga, not every one of those anime follows its source manga closely. When it comes to anime that are different from the manga, plenty of examples come up. Differences between manga and anime versions can arise for all sorts of reasons: an anime geared towards kids may omit the violence seen in the manga or a studio may need to create filler episodes while awaiting the next manga chapter. You may not realize it, but Pokémon's anime and manga versions differ wildly.

Fans often bristle when their favorite manga aren't replicated faithfully. Imagine waiting for your favorite scene from the manga only to find it's substantially changed or entirely cut from the anime version. On the other hand, such differences mean each version can tell a vastly different story. Just look at the details left out of Akira from manga to anime. Occasionally, the original manga falls short of the anime, which can shift up the plot with exciting and unique filler sagas. 

1 352 VOTES
Fullmetal Alchemist is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 13 Anime That Greatly Differ From The Manga They're Based On
Photo:  Fullmetal Alchemist/Studio Bones

The 2003 version of Fullmetal Alchemist quickly goes off in a different direction from the source manga, a shift that led to the 2009 reboot Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. While the 2003 version retains many of the main characters from the manga, Fullmetal Alchemist features a new antagonist named Dante, a different method for creating Homunculi, and an ending that drops the protagonist into the middle of World War I.

Though a great story, the original Fullmetal anime is not even remotely the same as the manga - if you want to watch that story unfold on-screen, you'll find it in Brotherhood.

More Fullmetal Alchemist

#15 of 928 on The Best Anime Series of All Time #87 of 120 on Sci-Fi Shows You Should Be Watching Now featuring The Biggest Differences Between The Two Fullmetal Alchemist Anime The Best Fullmetal Alchemist Fanfiction, Ranked

Is this a major difference?
see more on Fullmetal Alchemist
2 236 VOTES
Tokyo Ghoul is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 13 Anime That Greatly Differ From The Manga They're Based On
Photo:  Tokyo Ghoul √A/Studio Pierrot

The first season of Tokyo Ghoul sticks more or less to the manga, but that changes dramatically during the second season, Tokyo Ghoul √A. In the manga, Ken Kaneki works against Aogiri Tree, an organization attempting to bring liberation to ghouls through violent means, including kidnapping and terrorism. In the anime, Kaneki takes the opposite approach, joining Aogiri Tree instead.

On one hand, Tokyo Ghoul √A presents a fresh storyline for Kaneki; on the other, it's frustrating not to see the manga's storyline adapted. In addition to tweaking Kaneki's story, the Tokyo Ghoul anime also removes many of the more violent scenes seen in the manga.

More Tokyo Ghoul

#13 of 928 on The Best Anime Series of All Time #92 of 120 on Sci-Fi Shows You Should Be Watching Now #1 of 290 on The 100+ Best Anime Intros of All Time featuring The 12 Craziest 'Tokyo Ghoul' Fan Theories

Is this a major difference?
see more on Tokyo Ghoul
3 178 VOTES
Black Butler is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 13 Anime That Greatly Differ From The Manga They're Based On
Photo:  Black Butler/A-1 Pictures

The first season of Black Butler is a fairly straightforward adaptation of its source material, though many of the episodes do involve filler. The big changes come in the second season, when new characters who never appear in the manga dominate the storyline. Alois Trancy and his demon butler Claude Faustus appear; Claude and Sebastian Michaelis compete for Ciel Phantomhive's soul.

Most of this material is unrelated to the storyline of the first season, which focused on Ciel's powerful need for revenge against the people who killed his family. A 10-episode OVA, Book of Circus, ignores the second season, instead working straight from the manga. 

Is this a major difference?
see more on Black Butler
4 164 VOTES
Fruits Basket is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 13 Anime That Greatly Differ From The Manga They're Based On
Photo:  Fruits Basket/Studio Deen

The Fruits Basket manga went on hiatus when artist Natsuki Takaya broke her arm, so the anime ends less than a third of the way through the manga's plotline. Because of this, the Fruits Basket universe differs wildly from anime to manga. The most pronounced differences involve the main villain of the show, Akito Sohma. 

In the manga, Akito reveals their identity as a woman, a woman capable of lifting the curse that afflicts the whole family. Yet she remains unwilling to do so because her abusive mom led her to believe that Akito must bind the family to her through the curse, or else face abandonment. In the anime, however, Akito is a man, and is unable to lift the curse - which makes him physically ill - despite a desperate desire to do so.

That's just one of many differences between the two versions of Fruits Basket, but few change the tone as dramatically.

More Fruits Basket

#85 of 928 on The Best Anime Series of All Time #42 of 126 on The Best Fantasy Anime of All Time #16 of 257 on The Best Romance Anime Ever Made featuring The Best Fruits Basket Fanfiction, Ranked

Is this a major difference?
see more on Fruits Basket