Anime Underground

The 13 Best Anime Like Black Butler 

Ranker Anime
Updated November 5, 2019 826 votes 224 voters 5.7k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up the best anime recommendations for fans of Black Butler.

Black Butler is one of the classic gothic anime series out there that provides an interesting, if not twisted, storyline guaranteed to draw in any viewer. Ciel Phantomhive has gone through a tragedy no one should ever have to suffer. Disappearing after the brutal murder of his parents, he was thought to be lost from the world. Living in a world of nightmares, the young boy is pushed into making an impossible choice; continue living in a real world hell, or make a deal with a demon in order to regain freedom and vengeance. Returning to his abandoned estate with a strange man named Sebastian, whom he claims is his butler, Ciel takes to being "the Queen's Guard Dog," investigating some of the strangest cases Victorian England has to offer. 

If you've already binge-watched this series, which is completely understandable, you may have a hole left behind that another anime needs to fill. Luckily, we have some recommendations for anime like Black Butler that's a perfect follow up. Shows like Gosick that have a very gothic-Victorian look or supernatural vibe, or even shows like Death Note where the lead has a sense of justice that could push them down a dark path are all wonderful series that deserve to be added to your watchlist. Vote up your favorites to let us know which ones you like the most! 

Tokyo Ghoul is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The 13 Best Anime Like Black Butler
Photo:  Funimation/Funimation

Most anime fans have heard of Tokyo Ghoul for plenty of reasons; namely, it's messed up plot and dark storyline. Because of this, it's a perfect show to pair with Black Butler, having both myster and demon-like creatures to compare. In this modern world, humans must learn to live with the terrifying creatures known as "ghouls" roaming their cities. Appearing much like a human, they long to feast on the flesh of humans, killing thousands in the process. When Ken Kaneki finds out he's turned into a ghoul-like creature; perhaps even something more. Now he must learn how to navigate this new life and find out more about the very creatures he's become a part of. 

Is this a great next watch?
The Promised Neverland ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The 13 Best Anime Like Black Butler
Photo:  Crunchyroll/Crunchyroll

If you're looking for something a little more recent, The Promised Neverland has recently aired and is one of the creepier new releases out there. Life at the Grace Field House seems to be perfect. With tons of children all dressed in white playing with each other, it almost seems like the ideal image of peace. Every child is well cared for and loved, each one promised a home by the age of twelve. Emma wouldn't change her life for the world, but she is about to discover a horrific truth. Venturing past the forbidden gate, they realize that their lives are nothing but lies and the outside world is a place of nightmares. With incredibly smart children that have an urgency to survive, as well as a very twisted plot, this is a perfect anime to watch after Black Butler

Is this a great next watch?
Death Note is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The 13 Best Anime Like Black Butler
Photo:  Holly Wood/YouTube

If you need a series where the lead character goes down a dark path in order to achieve their idea of justice, Death Note is a classic that would make an excellent follow up to Black Butler. When Light Yagami finds a mysterious notebook, known as the Death Note, his entire world changes. Now able to see the shinigami attached to the book, known as Ryuk, Light is told that whoever's name he writes in the journal will die. Fed up with the injustice in the world, Light decides to take matters into his own hands and write down the names of those he finds to be guilty. But as time goes on, his morals seem to warp, leaving nothing but the husk of a young man once sane. 

Is this a great next watch?
Gosick is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The 13 Best Anime Like Black Butler
Photo:  Funimation/Funimation

As a foreign student at Saint Marguerite Academy, Kazuya Kujou is often shunned by his peers and referred to as the "Black Reaper" for his striking appearance. The name refers to a legend of a traveler who brings death in the spring. When he meets Victorique de Blois by chance in the library, his fate suddenly changes. Now, his life is bound with this doll-like girl who has an ability to predict the future. When mysteries begin to pop up everywhere, the two rely on each other to solve them! Much like Black Butler, there's a gothic feel that pairs with a sense of mystery. 

Is this a great next watch?