Anime Underground

13 Anime That Don't Deserve All Of The Hate  

Anna Lindwasser
17.3k votes 3.7k voters 46k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up anime that get a lot of hate but are actually great.

Anime fans have distinct tastes and may not love every show, but there are some series that attract a lot of unwarranted hate. Often, these despised shows are also some of the most popular anime—franchises like Sword Art Online and Attack on Titan have seemingly equal groups of devotees and haters. 

A lot of anime don't deserve all the hate they get. These shows are by no means perfect – many of them have serious flaws – but they're better than their critics give them credit for. 

Black Clover is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 13 Anime That Don't Deserve All Of The Hate
Photo:  Black Clover/Studio Pierrot

Don't listen to the haters, if you're not watching Black Clover, you're missing out. Some people dislike Asta's shrill, piercing voice and his played out shonen hero personality. Others find the battle sequences uninspiring and badly animated, or write it off as a redux of older, more successful shows like Naruto and Bleach

But Black Clover has redeeming qualities. Asta might be loud, but his goals are clear and his drive and enthusiasm are charming. His world is a cruel and elitist one, but he's determined to beat the odds anyway—a kind of story always worth telling. 

More Black Clover

#6 of 52 on The Most Popular Anime Right Now #64 of 923 on The Best Anime Series of All Time #12 of 78 on The 30+ Best Shounen Anime Of All Time #9 of 124 on The Best Anime on Crunchyroll

Is this anime unfairly criticized?
see more on Black Clover
Fairy Tail is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 13 Anime That Don't Deserve All Of The Hate
Photo:  Fairy Tail/A-1 Pictures

Fairy Tail might be popular, but there are a lot of anime fans who see it as mediocre or downright terrible. Every hater has their reasons, whether its the amount of time spent on Lucy and Natsu or how hard it is to root for a Guild that inflicts so much property damage. 

Criticisms aside, it's actually an entertaining show. Most characters get an impressive backstory, including side characters who might otherwise be ignored. Unlike many shonen series, it doesn't linger too long on any one fight scene - the pace is brisk and keeps viewers on their toes.

The female characters are strong and well-rounded, and the plot is creative and fun. If you've run out of fantasy action to watch, give Fairy Tail a shot.

More Fairy Tail

#12 of 52 on The Most Popular Anime Right Now #11 of 923 on The Best Anime Series of All Time featuring The Best Fairy Tail Villains of All Time The 15 Greatest Fairy Tail Ships

Is this anime unfairly criticized?
see more on Fairy Tail
Attack on Titan is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 13 Anime That Don't Deserve All Of The Hate
Photo:  Attack on Titan/Wit Studio

If you consider yourself a '90s kid, Attack on Titan might have been your gateway anime. It's one of the most beloved shows in anime history, and it's often written off as being terrible for that reason. This is unfair; popularity only equates to poor quality if you have a misanthropic outlook.

There are plenty of legitimate reasons to dislike the show – ranging from nitpicks about the animation to evidence suggesting it might be imperialist propaganda – but as long as you're watching with a critical eye, the series can be enjoyable.

The mystery behind the Titans is compelling, and the genuine danger the characters face keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. Despite being an action-heavy show with little time for romance, it has canon LGBTQ+ representation in the form of Krista and Ymir. Also, Levi is in it. No show with Levi in it can be completely terrible. 

More Attack on Titan

#46 of 120 on Sci-Fi Shows You Should Be Watching Now #8 of 52 on The Most Popular Anime Right Now featuring Attack On Titan Fan Theories 14 Reasons Why Attack On Titan Is Totally Overrated

Is this anime unfairly criticized?
see more on Attack on Titan
Fullmetal Alchemist is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 13 Anime That Don't Deserve All Of The Hate
Photo:  Fullmetal Alchemist/Studio Bones

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is generally considered better than the 2003 series, but there are a lot of people who prefer the former version

The 2003 anime develops its characters' relationships and emotional lives more than Brotherhood does, making it feel less like a shonen action series and more like a dark psychological thriller.

The 2003 version also boasts better pacing and a less confusing storyline, since it doesn't assume everyone's read the manga. Brotherhood edges it out in some areas, but not all of them, so it's not fair to hate on the 2003 version. 

More Fullmetal Alchemist

#86 of 120 on Sci-Fi Shows You Should Be Watching Now #15 of 923 on The Best Anime Series of All Time featuring The Biggest Differences Between The Two Fullmetal Alchemist Anime The Best Fullmetal Alchemist Fanfiction, Ranked

Is this anime unfairly criticized?
see more on Fullmetal Alchemist