Teens The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters  

Carly Kiel
483 votes 109 voters 1.2k views 10 items

You can always count on me, and I can count on you. Hey, who's your favorite babysitter? You know, from The Baby-Sitters Club? Good times, bad times / in-between. My friends will see me throooough. Truer words were never sung. Whether you read all the books or never missed an episode of the TV show or have seen the movie a million times or all of the above, any '90s gal familiar with this motley gang has an opinion about which babysitters were the best - and the worst. 

So, ladies, who were your faves? Sporty and bossy Kristy? Exotic and sophisticated Claudia? Stacey, the hot one with diabetes? Mallory, the one with red hair? (JK, she is nobody's favorite.) Each had unique characteristics, idiosyncrasies, and interests that made her (or him, Logan!) an integral part of The Baby-Sitters Club and the community of Stoneybrook. For example, Dawn was from California, and Abby was Jewish. How did people with such disparate backgrounds ever become friends? Through their love of babysitting. And because Stoneybrook was pretty small. 

Go ahead and vote for your favorite BabySitters Club characters, whether it's the bookish girls or the shy ones, the responsible ones or the ones with divorced parents. Heck, go ahead and upvote them all. They're just kids, for chrissake.
list ordered by

1
48 20
Claudia Kishi is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Vice President

2
39 15
Kristy Thomas is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
President

3
37 20
Dawn Schafer is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Alternate Officer

4
29 14
Jessi Ramsey is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Junior Officer

5
36 21
Stacey McGill is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Treasurer

6
28 21
Mary Anne Spier is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Secretary

7
24 22
Mallory Pike is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Junior Officer

8
17 19
Logan Bruno is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Associate member

9
16 20
Shannon Kilbourne is listed (or ranked) 9 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Alternate Officer

10
13 24
Abby Stevenson is listed (or ranked) 10 on the list The Best Baby-Sitters Club Babysitters
Alternate Officer