Entertainment

Are These Horror Movies Really "Based On A True Story"? Truth Is, They're Reaching  

Donn Saylor
1.9k votes 413 voters 22.7k views 16 items

List Rules Vote up the movies you still love, even if they aren't factually accurate.

Based on a true story. It's a tagline sure to attract curious viewers to any movie making the claim, but horror movies supposedly based on true stories are especially compelling. The idea that creepy and unexplainable events are happening all around us, and that real people have to live through such terrifying traumas, are unspeakably compelling. Sadly, however, the truth can sometimes get lost in creative interpretation.

So, while some classic movies may declare otherwise, these horror films claiming to be true are, in reality, stretching the real stories to fit a certain narrative. In many cases, events have been greatly embellished to create a more chilling and powerful story. In other instances, the movies are based on outright fabrications, and are basically entirely fictional. Hollywood is Hollywood after all, and making up exciting stories is what they do best. Let's explore a few horror films that aren't based on true stories... despite what the filmmakers might claim.

back to page 1
The Amityville Horror is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list Are These Horror Movies Really "Based On A True Story"? Truth Is, They're Reaching
Photo:  The Amityville Horror/American International Pictures

The classic film The Amityville Horror takes place in a home haunted by restless and vengeful spirits, who do their best to try and drive out the new owners. While the Lutzes, the real-life family who lived through this experience, stand by their story, others have raised questions.

There are more than a few inconsistencies in the Lutzes' recollections, and some theorize they were just trying to make a profit off the real tragedy: six murders occurred in their house the year before they moved in.

Actors: James Brolin, Margot Kidder, Rod Steiger, Murray Hamilton, Helen Shaver, + more

Released: 1979

Directed by: Stuart Rosenberg

More The Amityville Horror

#27 of 758 on The Best Horror Movies of All Time #7 of 65 on The Best Demonic Possession Movies #12 of 113 on The Best Intelligent Horror Movies #10 of 35 on The Best Horror Movies About Hell

Is this movie still great?
see more on The Amityville Horror
The Conjuring 2: The Enfield P... is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list Are These Horror Movies Really "Based On A True Story"? Truth Is, They're Reaching
Photo: The Conjuring 2/Warner Bros.

The Conjuring 2 is said to be based on the "true story" of the Enfield Poltergeist haunting in London, England, investigated by Ed and Lorraine Warren. In real life, the Warrens did investigate the claim, but they weren't the main investigators by any stretch. 

In August 1977, single mother Peggy Hodgson called the police after her children claimed the furniture was moving by itself and knocking was coming from the walls. The case of the Enfield Poltergeist was investigated by law officials and paranormal experts alike, and the conclusions were varied. Some corroborated the Hodgson family's story, while others dismissed it as a hoax. Ultimately, two of Peggy's children, Margaret (13) and Janet (11) were believed to be playing a giant trick on everyone. As an adult, Janet even admitted that she and her sister "made up 2%" of the paranormal occurrences; as soon as the sisters were taken away from the home for psychiatric evaluation, the hauntings stopped.

Actors: Vera Farmiga, Patrick Wilson, Frances O'Connor, Simon McBurney

Released: 2016

Directed by: James Wan

More The Conjuring 2: The Enfield Poltergeist

#37 of 176 on The Very Best Movies of 2016, Ranked #16 of 65 on The Best Demonic Possession Movies #13 of 113 on The Best Intelligent Horror Movies #3 of 28 on The Best Horror Movies of 2016

Is this movie still great?
see more on The Conjuring 2: The Enfield Poltergeist
Wolf Creek is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list Are These Horror Movies Really "Based On A True Story"? Truth Is, They're Reaching
Photo:  Wolf Creek/Dimension Films

In Wolf Creek, backpackers are tormented by a psychopath in a remote stretch of the Australian outback. The story is a rough aggregate of two different real-life crimes. In one, a mechanic brutalized two backpackers in the outback, killing one of them. In the other story - which happened in Wales, not Australia - a serial killer picked up unsuspecting hitchhikers and tortured and killed them in the woods. Elements of both stories were combined to create the story you see in Wolf Creek.

Actors: Teresa Palmer, John Jarratt, Kestie Morassi, Nathan Phillips, Cassandra Magrath, + more

Released: 2005

Directed by: Greg McLean

More Wolf Creek

#4 of 13 on Pretty Good Horror Movies You Should Never Watch Before Traveling Abroad #19 of 34 on The Best Scary Movies Based on True Stories #20 of 33 on The Scariest Cabin Horror Movies #33 of 35 on Rainy Day Horror Movies You Can Watch Again And Again

Is this movie still great?
see more on Wolf Creek
Hostel is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list Are These Horror Movies Really "Based On A True Story"? Truth Is, They're Reaching
Photo:  Hostel/Lionsgate

Hostel may make the assertion it was "inspired by true events," but what those "true events" are is really anyone's guess. The film's writer/director, Eli Roth, said he based the story on a maybe-fake website he came across that offered tourists a chance to come to Thailand and shoot someone in the head for a mere $10,000. Roth admitted he didn't know if the premise was real, but "my point was like, well, somebody thought of it," he said. "That’s f*cked up. Someone is thinking about this and went so far as to create a website about it." And, obviously, a movie.

Actors: Eli Roth, Ashley Robbins, Jay Hernandez, Takashi Miike, Anita Queen, + more

Released: 2005

Directed by: Eli Roth

More Hostel

#96 of 758 on The Best Horror Movies of All Time #50 of 146 on The Best and Scariest Psychological Thrillers of All Time #1 of 136 on The Goriest Movies Ever Made #1 of 13 on Pretty Good Horror Movies You Should Never Watch Before Traveling Abroad

Is this movie still great?
see more on Hostel