Total Nerd The Best Versions of Alfred in Batman History  

Rhune Kincaid
5.6k votes 1.2k voters 19.2k views 24 items

List Rules Vote up who you think was the best Alfred ever.

With the 2016 release of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, the world will meet Batman's stalwart butler, confidant, surrogate parent, legal guardian, surgeon, quartermaster, and friend, Alfred Pennyworth, again for the first time. Jeremy Irons will take up the role alongside Ben Affleck. As Batman has changed over the years, so has Alfred. He's been portrayed in theatrical films, made-for-TV movies, television serials, live-action television shows, animated television shows, comics galore, video games, toys, and wherever else the Batman mythos has reached. The only thing he hasn't done is be the star of his own property, but even that could be on the horizon.

His origins, or more accurately, how he came to be of service to Bruce Wayne and what exactly he did before that, are an ever-changing landscape. Some versions have a military background, some portray the Wayne Manor butlership as a hereditary inheritance, and in some cases, Alfred came to the Waynes after a career in acting. His skill set seems to swell to fit the occasion to the point where he's even thrown on the cape and cowl and masqueraded as the Caped Crusader himself! Which are the best Alfred portrayals? This list of Alfreds needs your votes!

Who's the best Alfred from Batman? There's an Alfred for all tastes, so it's time to weigh in on this list of the best Alfreds in Batman history and tell everyone which Alfred you think is the best!
1 744 VOTES

Michael Caine in The Dark Knight Trilogy

Michael Caine in The Dark Knig... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Versions of Alfred in Batman History
Photo: Warner Bros.
Michael Caine brought a Cockney accent and tough love to the role of Alfred for Christopher Nolan's three Dark Knight films. His Alfred has one of the broader arcs as he goes from being whimsically amused in Batman Begins to genuinely anti-Batman (no longer approving of the risks) by the middle of The Dark Knight Rises. Also, he's Michael freaking Caine, so you get the charming British humor and the Get Carter toughness all rolled into one.
555 189
Agree or disagree?
2 658 VOTES

Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. In Batman: The Animated Series

Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. In Batman... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Versions of Alfred in Batman History
Photo: Fox
Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. wasn't the first animated Alfred, but he was the definitive one. Combined with the subtle but pitch-perfect animation, this incarnation brought Alfred's sly sarcasm and loving indulgence to the fore. Without these defining qualities, Alfred can quickly become just another sidekick, but Batman: The Animated Series nailed it.
480 178
Agree or disagree?
3 562 VOTES

Michael Gough in the '80s and '90s Films

Michael Gough in the '80s ... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Versions of Alfred in Batman History
Photo: Warner Bros.
The venerable Michael Gough lent his talents to Tim Burton and then Joel Schumacher to lock up the cinematic version of Alfred for a solid decade. He gave Alfred a knowing humor and offered more dating advice than combat experience as he guided Batman, and later Robin and Batgirl.
411 151
Agree or disagree?
4 541 VOTES

Sean Pertwee in Gotham

Sean Pertwee in Gotham is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Versions of Alfred in Batman History
Photo: Fox
Sean Pertwee is a gritty Alfred for a goofy prequel. He's not just Bruce Wayne's legal guardian, he's his combat trainer and quartermaster with an insight into Gotham's organized crime landscape. Gotham gonna Gotham.
366 175
Agree or disagree?