251 voters

The Best Horror Movies Of The 2010s That Didn't Take Place During The Decade

Updated April 2, 2021 2.1k votes 251 voters 4.7k views20 items

List RulesVote up the movies that mined scares from the past to make a great movie for the '10s.

Looking back at the 2010s, it's hard to ignore the impact that horror movies had on the decade. In a landscape dominated by big-budget blockbusters, relatively small-budget horror films began to break out all over the cinematic landscape. It has also been a decade of horror nostalgia, and many scary movies of the last 10 years didn't actually take place in the 2010s. This was true of both indie horror films and bigger-budget movies, like IT (2017), which became one of the highest-grossing R-rated movies of all time. 

Some of these films came from first-time directors, launching their careers into the stratosphere overnight. Others came from the twisted minds of well-established filmmakers. From the 17th-century Massachusetts wilderness to the scorching Summer of '84, these are all of the best horror films of the decade that took place in the past.

  • Photo: Lionsgate

    When Does It Take Place? 1968

    Why Is This Setting Scary? Set in 1968, the film tells the story of a haunted young girl named Sarah who has the ability to make her terrifying imagination become reality. When a group of teenagers discovers Sarah's home, they become the targets of her spooky stories.  

    What's The Best Throwback Scare? The Pale Lady is a truly monstrous creature.

    • Actors: Zoe Colletti, Michael Garza, Austin Abrams, Gabriel Rush, Austin Zajur
    • Released: 2019
    • Directed by: André Øvredal
    One of the decade's best?

    More Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark 

    The Original Folktales And Urban Legends That Inspired ‘Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark’#87 of 112 Movies That Need Sequels#56 of 114 The Best Horror Movie Franchises

  • Photo: A24

    When Does It Take Place? 1630s

    Why Is This Setting Scary? Roger Eggers's film debut is definitely one of the best horror films of the decade. The movie follows a banished pilgrim family as they try to survive alone in the wilderness, only to come across a forest-dwelling witch that changes their lives forever. The period-accurate dialogue only adds to the film's sense of dreadful realism, and it shows what an often watered-down folk legend would look like in real life.

    What's The Best Throwback Scare? The demonic rabbit that causes William's rifle to backfire.

    • Actors: Anya Taylor-Joy, Ralph Ineson, Kate Dickie, Harvey Scrimshaw, Ellie Grainger
    • Released: 2015
    • Directed by: Robert Eggers
    One of the decade's best?

    More The Witch 

    #81 of 713 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time#63 of 73 The Greatest Movies To Watch Outside#44 of 126 The Greatest Directorial Debuts Of All Time

  • 7

    Annabelle: Creation

    When Does It Take Place? 1955

    Why Is This Setting Scary? A chapter in The Conjuring universe, Annabelle: Creation reveals the origins of the horrifying doll, Annabelle. After the tragic end of their daughter, a toy maker and his wife struggle to overcome their loss. After they welcome a nun and group of orphaned girls into their home, the dark depths of their grief are soon revealed. 

    What's The Best Throwback Scare? The bedsheet ghost in the bedroom.

    • Actors: Talitha Bateman, Stephanie Sigman, Anthony LaPaglia, Miranda Otto
    • Released: 2017
    • Directed by: David F. Sandberg
    One of the decade's best?


    #13 of 22 Horror Movies You Can't Even Finish Watching#3 of 7 All The Movies In 'The Conjuring' Universe, Ranked#19 of 150 The Best Supernatural Horror Movies, Ranked

  • 8


    When Does It Take Place? 1989

    Why Is This Setting Scary? IT is based on Stephen King's hit horror novel of the same name. Set in the 1980s, the story follows the young members of the Losers Club as they uncover a menacing mystery in the small town of Derry, ME. 

    What's The Best Throwback Scare? Pretty much anything involving Pennywise, who is modeled after Victorian-era clowns.

    • Actors: Jaeden Lieberher, Bill Skarsgård, Jeremy Ray Taylor, Sophia Lillis, Finn Wolfhard
    • Released: 2017
    • Directed by: Andy Muschietti
    One of the decade's best?


    Every Time Pennywise Was Hidden In The Background Of The 'It' Movies#5 of 97 The Best Movies of 2017, Ranked#9 of 121 The Best Intelligent Horror Movies