Sports
44 voters

Every Goalie In St. Louis Blues History, Ranked

February 24, 2020 1.5k votes 44 voters70 items

List RulesVote up the best goalies ever between the pipes for the St. Louis Blues.

The best St. Louis Blues goalies of all time have all had a hand in making the Blues one of top Stanley Cup contenders in hockey every year. While the franchise has gone through downswings, the best years are always marked by having an excellent goaltender between the pipes.

Early stars from the franchise’s past like Glenn Hall and Mike Liut set the standard that more modern players like Jake Allen and Brian Elliott would have to live up to in order to be considered among the best STL Blues goaltenders.

So check out this list of every goalie in St. Louis Blues history, and vote up who you think deserves to be considered the best Blues goaltender ever.

...more
  • Mike Liut1

    Blues career: 1980-1985

    Ted Lindsay Award (1981)

  • Grant Fuhr2

    Blues career: 1996-1999

  • Jake Allen3

    Blues career: 2013-2020

    Stanley Cup (2019)

  • Curtis Joseph4

    Blues career: 1990-1995

  • Jaroslav Halák5

    Blues career: 2011-2014

    Jennings Trophy (2012)

  • Greg Millen6

    Blues career: 1985-1990

  • Brian Elliott7

    Blues career: 2012-2016

    Jennings Trophy (2012)

  • Glenn Hall8

    Blues career: 1968-1971

    Conn Smythe Trophy (1968)
    Vezina Trophy (1969)

  • Rick Wamsley9
    27
    4

    Rick Wamsley

    Blues career: 1985-1988

  • Manny Legace10

    Blues career: 2007-2009

  • Roman Turek11

    Blues career: 2000-2001

    Jennings Trophy (2001)

  • Jordan Binnington12

    Blues career: 2016-2020

    Stanley Cup (2019)

  • Brent Johnson13

    Blues career: 1999-2004

  • Vincent Riendeau14
    21
    4

    Vincent Riendeau

    Blues career: 1989-1992

  • Ed Staniowski15
    25
    11

    Ed Staniowski

    Blues career: 1976-1981

  • Chris Mason16
    32
    21

    Chris Mason

    Blues career: 2009-2010

  • Wayne Stephenson17

    Blues career: 1972-1974

  • Jamie McLennan18

    Blues career: 1998-2000

    Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy (1998)

  • Ernie Wakely19
    31
    21

    Ernie Wakely

    Blues career: 1970-1972

  • Chris Osgood20

    Blues career: 2003-2004

  • Jacques Plante21

    Blues career: 1969-1970

    Vezina Trophy (1969)

  • Phil Myre22

    Blues career: 1978-1979

  • John Davidson23

    Blues career: 1974-1975

  • Eddie Johnston24

    Blues career: 1975-1978

  • Curtis Sanford25
    12
    1

    Curtis Sanford

    Blues career: 2003-2007