The Best Cake Albums of All Time 

Updated October 13, 2018 576 votes 271 voters 11.4k views 6 items

List Rules This list includes studio albums only, so if you add an album make sure it's a proper studio release.

Cake is known to many as one of the best alternative rock bands. List of the best Cake albums, including pictures of the album covers when available. This Cake discography is ranked from best to worst, so the top Cake albums can be found at the top of the list. To make it easy for you, we haven't included Cake singles, EPs, or compilations, so everything you see here should only be studio albums. If you think the greatest Cake album isn't high enough on the list, then be sure to vote for it so it receives the credit it deserves. Make sure you don't just vote for critically acclaimed albums; if you have a favorite Cake album, then vote it up, even if it's not necessarily the most popular.

If you want to know, "What is the Best Cake album of all time?" or "What are the top Cake albums?" then this list will answer your questions. List features Fashion Nugget, Comfort Eagle and more.

This list of popular Cake albums has been voted on by music fans around the world, so the order of this list isn't just one person's opinion. 

Fashion Nugget is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Cake Albums of All Time
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use

1. Frank Sinatra
2. The Distance
3. Friend Is a Four Letter Word
4. Open Book
5. Daria
6. Race Car Ya-Yas
7. I Will Survive
8. Stickshifts and Safetybelts
9. Perhaps, Perhaps, Perhaps
10. It's Coming Down
11. Nugget
12. She'll Come Back to Me
13. Italian Leather Sofa
14. Sad Songs and Waltzes

Release Date: 1996

Artist: Cake

Tracks: Stickshifts and Safetybelts, The Distance, She'll Come Back to Me, + more

Length (mins): 00:48:16

Genres (Music): Alternative rock, Hard rock, College rock

Agree or disagree?
Comfort Eagle is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Cake Albums of All Time
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use

1. Opera Singer
2. Meanwhile, Rick James...
3. Shadow Stabbing
4. Short Skirt/Long Jacket
5. Commissioning a Symphony in C
6. Arco Arena
7. Comfort Eagle
8. Long Line of Cars
9. Love You Madly
10. Pretty Pink Ribbon
11. World of Two

Release Date: 2001

Artist: Cake

Tracks: Opera Singer, Love You Madly, World of Two, + more

Genres (Music): Alternative rock, Pop rock, Funk rock

Agree or disagree?
Prolonging the Magic is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Cake Albums of All Time
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use

1. Satan Is My Motor
2. Mexico
3. Never There
4. Guitar
5. You Turn the Screws
6. Walk on By
7. Sheep Go to Heaven
8. When You Sleep
9. Hem of Your Garment
10. Alpha Beta Parking Lot
11. Let Me Go
12. Cool Blue Reason
13. Where Would I Be?

Release Date: 1998

Artist: Cake

Tracks: Satan Is My Motor, Let Me Go, Cool Blue Reason, + more

Genres (Music): Alternative rock, Alternative country

Agree or disagree?
Pressure Chief is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Cake Albums of All Time
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use

1. Wheels
2. No Phone
3. Take It All Away
4. Dime
5. Carbon Monoxide
6. The Guitar Man
7. Waiting
8. She'll Hang the Baskets
9. End of the Movie
10. Palm of Your Hand
11. Tougher Than It Is

Release Date: 2004

Artist: Cake

Tracks: Dime, She'll Hang the Baskets, No Phone, + more

Length (mins): 00:36:15

Label: Columbia

Genres (Music): Alternative rock, College rock

Agree or disagree?