vote on everything
Music
126 voters

The Best Carrie Underwood Albums, Ranked

Updated January 17, 2019 586 votes 126 voters 1.7k views6 items

List RulesNo EPs.

We're ranking the best Carrie Underwood albums of all time. One of the best country singers right now, Carrie Underwood's discography has been met with positive reception ever since winning American Idol season four in 2005. What is the greatest Carrie Underwood album ever?

From her debut album Some Hearts to her 2018 album Cry Pretty, this list of Carrie Underwood albums also includes Carnival Ride, Storyteller, Play On, and Blown Away, which won the American Music Award for Favorite Country Album.

Vote up the best Carrie Underwood albums, and vote down the ones that were disappointing.

  • Blown Away is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Carrie Underwood Albums, Ranked
    Photo: Arista Nashville

    1. Good Girl
    2. Blown Away
    3. Two Black Cadillacs
    4. See You Again
    5. Do You Think About Me
    6. Forever Changed
    7. Nobody Ever Told You
    8. One Way Ticket
    9. Thank God for Hometowns
    10. Good in Goodbye
    11. Leave Love Alone
    12. Cupid's Got a Shotgun
    13. Wine After Whiskey
    14. Who Are You

    Metacritic score: 70/100

    • Release Date: 2012
    85
    16
    Did you enjoy this album?
    amazon buy button
  • Play On is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Carrie Underwood Albums, Ranked
    Photo: Arista Nashville

    1. Cowboy Casanova
    2. Quitter
    3. Mama's Song
    4. Change
    5. Undo It
    6. Someday When I Stop Loving You
    7. Songs Like This
    8. Temporary Home
    9. This Time
    10. Look at Me (feat. Vince Gill)
    11. Unapologize
    12. What Can I Say (feat. Sons of Sylvia)
    13. Play On

    Metacritic score: 54/100

    • Release Date: 2009
    76
    12
    Did you enjoy this album?
    amazon buy button
  • Storyteller is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Carrie Underwood Albums, Ranked
    Photo: Arista Nashville

    1. Renegade Runaway
    2. Dirty Laundry
    3. Church Bells
    4. Heartbeat
    5. Smoke Break
    6. Choctaw County Affair
    7. Like I'll Never Love You Again
    8. Chaser
    9. Relapse
    10. Clock Don't Stop
    11. The Girl You Think I Am
    12. Mexico
    13. What I Never Knew I Always Wanted

    Metacritic score: 74/100

    • Release Date: 2015
    85
    22
    Did you enjoy this album?
    amazon buy button
  • Cry Pretty is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Carrie Underwood Albums, Ranked
    Photo: Capitol Nashville

    1. Cry Pretty
    2. Ghosts on the Stereo
    3. Low
    4. Backsliding
    5. Southbound
    6. That Song That We Used to Make Love To
    7. Drinking Alone
    8. The Bullet
    9. Spinning Bottles
    10. Love Wins
    11. End Up with You
    12. Kingdom
    13. The Champion (feat. Ludacris)

    Metacritic score: 69/100

    • Release Date: 2018
    86
    24
    Did you enjoy this album?
    amazon buy button
AlbumsMusicCarrie UnderwoodPop MusicCountry Music