Sports
53 voters

The Best Cincinnati Bengals Kickers Of All Time

Updated December 4, 2019 229 votes 53 voters18 items

List RulesVote up kickers based only on their performance with the Bengals.

The best Cincinnati Bengals kickers ever have all had a part in some of the biggest moments in franchise history. NFL games can be won and lost by one or two points, making every made or missed kick of the greatest importance and every starting kicker a potential hero.

While recent stars like Shayne Graham and Mike Nugent have made their mark in the Bengals' past, early standouts like Jim Breech and Doug Pelfrey helped craft their own legacies in the old days of the franchise.

So which of these kickers from Cincinnati Bengals history deserves to rank near the top of the list? Who are the best Bengals kickers of all-time? Vote below, and check back to see what other football fans thought.

Photo:
...more
  • 1
    Jim Breech

    Bengals career: 1980–1992

  • 2
    Mike Nugent

    Bengals career: 2010-2016

  • 3
    Shayne Graham

    Bengals career: 2003–2009

    Career accomplishments: 
    Pro Bowl (2005)
    First-team All-Pro (2005)

  • 4
    Chris Bahr

    Bengals career: 1976–1979

  • 5
    Doug Pelfrey
    18
    7

    Doug Pelfrey

    Bengals career: 1993–1999

    Career accomplishments: 
    "Whizzer" White NFL Man of the Year Award (1999)

  • 6
    Horst Muhlmann

    Bengals career: 1969–1974

  • 7
    Randy Bullock

    Bengals (2016–present)

  • 8
    Neil Rackers

    Bengals career: 2000–2002

  • 9
    Dale Livingston

    Bengals career: 1968–1969

  • 10
    Dave Rayner

    Bengals career: 2008, 2010

  • 11
    Ian Sunter
    4
    5

    Ian Sunter

    Bengals career: 1980-1982

  • 12
    Josh Brown

    Bengals career: 2012

  • 13
    Aaron Pettrey
    0
    1

    Aaron Pettrey

    Bengals career: 2010

  • 14
    Clint Stitser
    1
    4

    Clint Stitser

    Bengals career: 2010

  • 15
    Marshall Koehn
    0
    5

    Marshall Koehn

    Bengals career: 2017

  • 16
    Sandro Vitiello
    0
    1

    Sandro Vitiello

    Bengals career: 1980

  • 17
    Massimo Manca
    2
    1

    Massimo Manca

    Bengals career: 1987

  • 18
    Jim Gallery
    1
    1

    Jim Gallery

    Bengals career: 1989