The Best Episodes Of 'American Horror Stories'

List Rules
Vote up your favorite episodes of American Horror Stories to air.

Consider this an American Horror Stories episode guide, ranking all of the episodes on the American Horror Story spinoff from Hulu. American Horror Stories brings back fan-favorite imagery, as well as creating new characters and worlds. Each episode is its own thing, so it's like watching a bunch of horror short films.

The American Horror Stories episodes starring Kaia Gerber, Sierra McCormick, and Paris Jackson - "Rubber (wo)Man Part One," "Rubber (wo)Man Part Two," and "Game Over" are fan favorites. Many AHS fans find the relationship between Ruby and Scarlett compelling. "Drive," which features a movie that sends anyone who views it into a violent rage, is another top-ranking episode. Fans also love American Horror Stories episode "Feral," which features Aaron Tveit and Cody Fern. 

It can be difficult to choose a best episode when there are so many great actors that appear in American Horror Stories. Season one episodes feature trending stars like Noah Cyrus, and Ryan Murphy collaborator Billie Lourd. When you're looking for an American Horror Stories episode to watch, which do you choose? 

Check out the list with all of the episodes of American Horror Stories below, and vote up the ones you enjoy watching most. Then, check back to see if your favorite episodes of American Horror Stories topped our list. 


    • Original Airing: July 15, 2021
    • Season: 1
    • Episode Number: 1
    • Episode Description: A teenager and her parents move into the infamous "Murder House." As the family makes renovations, a darkness takes root within them, with a focus on their daughter, Scarlett.
  • Game Over
    Photo: American Horror Stories / Hulu
    2
    32 VOTES
    • Original Airing: August 19, 2021
    • Season: 1
    • Episode Number: 7
    • Episode Description: A horror-obsessed couple pays to spend a night in the infamous “Murder House,” and are surprised when they get exactly what they asked for. The meta episode also features a video game rendition of “American Horror Story.”
  • 3
    20 VOTES
    • Original Airing: August 12, 2021
    • Season: 1
    • Episode Number: 6
    • Episode Description: Years after their son disappeared while on a camping trip, two desperate parents venture back into the cursed woods when a strange man says he’s had a sighting of the now-teenage boy. A bizarre encounter with a park ranger has them worried about what is actually lurking in these woods.
  • Bloody Mary
    Photo: American Horror Stories / Hulu
    4
    26 VOTES
    • Original Airing: August 18, 2022
    • Season: 2
    • Episode Number: 5
    • Episode Description: A group of teenage girls call upon urban legend "Bloody Mary" to grant their wishes. Unfortunately, they don't realize that each wish comes with a steep price.