Button Mash
135 voters

15 Games You Need To Play If You Liked 'Red Dead Redemption 2'

Updated October 29, 2020 763 votes 135 voters 7.0k views15 items

List RulesVote up all the games like RDR2 that aren't just another Rockstar epic.

Western games are hard to pull off, but so far Rockstar’s three for three (if you don’t include the non-canon Undead Nightmare). Released at the end of 2018, Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic open-world action-adventure game where players take control of Arthur Morgan, an aging outlaw who’s struggling to cope with the changing world around him. As one of the greatest action-adventure games of the decade, there are plenty of other games like Red Dead Redemption that share similar storylines and gameplay mechanics.

Looking for a beautiful RPG adventure? The Witcher 3 is a great choice. While the story deals with steel and silver in lieu of gunpowder, they share a similar style and are both incredibly engrossing. And if you’re looking for a few great westerns to dig into, Call of Juarez and Lead and Gold are great places to start. 

If you’re looking for great games that are like Red Dead Redemption, then be sure to check out these awesome titles. Vote up the ones you think are a worthy next step so other gamers can see which similar titles to pick up next.

  • Photo: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt / CD Projekt

    Why you should play it: Easily one of the most popular games in recent years of all time, Witcher 3 is a gorgeous third-person, open-world RPG that transports gamers to an expensive land mass known only as The Continent. You'll have dozens of quests to complete and a vast map to explore. The story is intricate, and the monsters you face are incredibly challenging. 

    What makes it unique: Instead of playing in the Old West like you do in Red Dead, you'll play as a Monster Hunter. Combat is arguably more complicated and you play in a fantasy world. Nonetheless, Witcher 3 is regarded as one of the best RPGs of all time, so it's definitely worth a try.

      Worth playing?

      More The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt 

      25 Memes That Are Hilarious If You've Played Too Much Of The Witcher#65 of 124 The Most Popular Video Games Right Now#3 of 271 The Most Compelling Video Game Storylines Ever

    • Photo: Grand Theft Auto V / Rockstar Games

      Why you should play it: The GTA franchise is one of the longest standing RPG franchises and the games have always been popular, but Rockstar really hit it out of the park with GTA V. You'll get to explore the streets of Los Santos as you perform exciting and intricate heists. You'll get that feeling of being an outlaw like you do in Red Dead Redemption but in the modern world. Because both GTA and RDR are Rockstar games, the mechanics and gameplay elements are incredibly similar—which is a good thing.

      What makes it unique: In GTA you'll switch between three incredibly unique characters: Franklin, Michael, and Trevor. Each has different motivations and personality traits. Sometimes you'll complete quests with theme separately, while at other times they'll team up for breathtaking missions. If you like exploring and doing your own thing, GTA V is a great game for that as there's lots of room to explore inside and outside the city.

        Worth playing?

        More Grand Theft Auto V 

        25 Memes You'll Only Relate To If You Grew Up Playing Grand Theft Auto#2 of 66 The Most Popular Action Games Out Now#6 of 177 The Best Video Games Of The 2010s, Ranked

      • Photo: Bethesda Game Studios

        Why you should play it: Skyrim is possibly the most popular RPG of all time. Released in 2011, the game set records for games sold and even made waves in mainstream media. The RPG elements of Skyrim are similar to Red Dead Redemption, and the world is just as vast (possibly even more so). You'll be able to put as much time into Skyrim as you did Red Dead, if not more considering the online replay value for RDR2 is still somewhat lacking.

        What makes it unique: Skyrim takes place in a fantasy world, which is slightly different from the Western-themed game you're used to. However, that shouldn't put you off as you'll get to enjoy a skill and perk system that was revolutionary at the time. You aren't forced into picking a class, so you can adapt as you go and build a class that's as unique as you want. It's a game every RPG fan should play.

          Worth playing?

          More The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 

          'Skyrim' Fan Theories That Actually Make A Lot Of Sense#1 of 354 The Greatest RPG Video Games Ever Made#59 of 178 The Best Video Game Franchises of All Time

        • Photo: Mafia II / 2K Czech

          Why you should play it: A gangster is similar to an outlaw, and in Mafia 2 you'll play as a gangster trying to climb the ranks of a powerful crime family. One of the elements of Mafia that's most similar to Red Dead is the wanted system. Your notoriety will rise as you commit crimes, making it easier for the authorities to find you. You'll need to keep that in check or you won't last long. 

          What makes it unique: The setting is very different as the game takes place in New York City. An interesting aspect of the game is that cutscenes are created by the game engine in real-time, so a cutscene can be different depending on if you're in a car or in a house when an event takes place. As a result, replaying the game will give you a much different experience the second time around.

            Worth playing?

            More Mafia II 

            #21 of 617 Sony PlayStation 3 Games: List of PS3 Console Games#272 of 1,371 The 100+ Best Video Games of All Time, Ranked by Fans#26 of 119 The Best Video Game Sequels