Watchworthy
177 voters

The Best Historical Mystery Series

Updated November 10, 2020 925 votes 177 voters 8.3k views28 items

List RulesVote up the best period detective series or shows about the mysteries of specific previous era, that have aired on television.

The best period detective series and historical mystery shows let you experience a different time period while also enjoying a good whodunnit. Whether they're a scripted drama or a mystery documentary they offer intrigue and often some great costumes. If you’ve been looking for the best historical mysteries to add some excitement to your TV nights, this list of the period detective and mystery series of all time will help you figure out what needs to go into your queue.

From BBC detective dramas to docuseries that offer plenty of historical reenactment, many of the best mystery shows are set during specific time periods. Thanks to the popularity of detective novels from authors like Agatha Christie, there are several shows based on books, like Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries and Agatha Christie's Poirot - and of course Sherlock Holmes. Other historical mystery shows dramatize famous mysteries such as Jack The Ripper while offering insight from historians. Other shows just know that history itself offers many mysteries and place their detectives in dashing times that offer historical drama and great costumes along with the crime-solving.

Which shows balance mystery and history the best? Vote up the best historical mystery and detective shows, then vote down the shows that don't solve the mystery of the best detective series set in a previous time period.

Photo:
...more
  • 1
    Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries
    81
    24

    Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries

    Essie Davis, Nathan Page

    Premiered2012

    More 

    #302 of 537 TV Shows Canceled Before Their Time#106 of 142 The Best TV Shows Based on Books

  • 2
    Agatha Christie's Poirot
    74
    20

    Agatha Christie's Poirot

    David Suchet, Hugh Fraser

    Premiered1989

    More Agatha Christie's Poirot 

    #186 of 389 TV Shows That Only Smart People Appreciate#90 of 122 The Best Serial Cop Dramas of All Time

  • 3
    The Alienist
    58
    18

    The Alienist

    Daniel Brühl, Luke Evans

    Premiered2018

    More The Alienist 

    The Best Episodes of 'The Alienist'#406 of 639 The Best TV Shows To Binge Watch

  • 4
    Sherlock Holmes
    45
    11

    Sherlock Holmes

    Jeremy Brett, Charles Gray

    Premiered1984

  • 5
    Ripper Street
    41
    13

    Ripper Street

    Matthew Macfadyen, Jerome Flynn

    Premiered2012

  • 6
    Agatha Christie's Marple
    35
    12

    Agatha Christie's Marple

    Geraldine McEwan, Julia McKenzie

    Premiered2004

    More Agatha Christie's Marple 

    #6 of 26 The Best Movies Based on Agatha Christie Stories#13 of 165 The Best Mystery TV Shows

  • 7
    The Return of Sherlock Holmes
    32
    12

    The Return of Sherlock Holmes

    Margaret Colin, Michael Pennington

    Premiered1987

  • 8
    Miss Marple
    27
    11

    Miss Marple

    Joan Hickson, Gwen Watford

    Premiered1984

    More 

    The Best Miss Marple Books#6 of 98 The Best British Detective Series, Ranked

  • 9
    The Doctor Blake Mysteries
    24
    17

    The Doctor Blake Mysteries

    Craig McLachlan

    Premiered2013

  • 10
    The ABC Murders
    20
    13

    The ABC Murders

    John Malkovich as Hercule Poirot, with Rupert Grint

    Premiered2018

    More The ABC Murders 

    #56 of 80 The Greatest TV Shows Set in the '30s#22 of 49 The Best TV Shows Set In London

  • 11
    History Detectives
    10
    8

    History Detectives

    Wes Cowan

    Premiered2003

  • 12
    Dead Still
    5
    2

    Dead Still

    Michael Smiley, Jimmy Smallhorne

    Premiered2020

    More Dead Still 

    #133 of 505 The Best New TV Shows Of 2020#85 of 140 The Best Dark Comedy TV Shows

  • 13
    The Frankenstein Chronicles
    16
    19

    The Frankenstein Chronicles

    Sean Bean, Tom Ward
  • 14
    High Seas
    8
    8

    High Seas

    Eloy Azorín, Ivana Baquero

    Premiered2019

    More 

    #58 of 83 The Best Current Dramatic TV Shows#37 of 62 The Greatest TV Shows Set in the '40s

  • 15
    Agatha Christie's Partners in Crime
    10
    12

    Agatha Christie's Partners in Crime

    Francesca Annis, Reece Dinsdale

    Premiered1983

  • 16
    Jack the Ripper
    8
    9

    Jack the Ripper

    Stratford Johns, Frank Windsor

    Premiered1973

    More Jack the Ripper 

    #102 of 158 The Best Miniseries in TV History#39 of 211 The Best Documentary Series & TV Shows

  • 17
    Ms Fisher's Modern Murder Mysteries
    16
    21

    Ms Fisher's Modern Murder Mysteries

    Geraldine Hakewill, Joel Jackson

    Premiered2019

  • 18
    Roman Mysteries
    8
    9

    Roman Mysteries

    Simon Callow, Francesca Isherwood

    Premiered2007

  • 19
    Mysteries at the Museum
  • 20
    I Am the Night
    12
    16

    I Am the Night

    Chris Pine, India Eisley

    Premiered2019

  • 21
    Maigret
    7
    9

    Maigret

    Michael Gambon, Geoffrey Hutchings

    Premiered1992

  • 22
    Pennyworth
    4
    7

    Pennyworth

    Jack Bannon, Ben Aldridge

    Premiered2019

  • 23
    A Haunting
    6
    12

    A Haunting

    Anthony D. Call, Mark Joy

    Premiered2002

    More A Haunting 

    #1 of 65 The Best Paranormal Reality Shows#21 of 64 The Creepiest Shows In TV History

  • 24
    Medici
    6
    12

    Medici

    Dustin Hoffman, Richard Madden

    Premiered2016

    More Medici 

    #13 of 123 The Best Historical Drama TV Shows#55 of 62 The Best Historical Fiction TV Shows

  • 25
    Musee Eden
    4
    12

    Musee Eden

    Laurence Leboeuf, Guy Nadon

    Premiered2010