Sports
72 voters

The Best Indianapolis Colts Kickers Of All Time

Updated December 4, 2019 346 votes 72 voters 2.5k views21 items

List RulesVote up kickers based only on their performance with the Colts.

The best Indianapolis Colts kickers ever have all had a part in some of the biggest moments in franchise history. NFL games can be won and lost by one or two points, making every made or missed kick of the greatest importance and every starting kicker a potential hero.

While recent stars like Adam Vinatieri and Mike Vanderjagt have made their mark in the Colts’ past, early standouts like Dean Biasucci and Lou Michaels helped craft their own legacies in the old days of the franchise.

So which of these kickers from Indianapolis Colts history deserves to rank near the top of the list? Who are the best Colts kickers of all-time? Vote below, and check back to see what other football fans thought.

Photo:
...more
  • Adam Vinatieri1

    Colts career: 2006–present

    Career accomplishments:
    Super Bowl XLI champion
    1× Pro Bowl (2014)
    1× First-team All-Pro (2014)

  • Mike Vanderjagt2

    Colts career: 1998–2005

    Career accomplishments:
    Pro Bowl (2003)
    All-Pro (2003)
    PFW Golden Toe Award (2003)

  • Dean Biasucci3

    Colts career: 1984–1994

    Career accomplishments:
    1× Pro Bowl selection (1987)
    2× All-Pro selection (1987, 1988)

  • Jim O'Brien4
    15
    10

    Jim O'Brien

    Colts career: 1970–1972

    Career accomplishments:
    Super Bowl V champion
    1970 AFC Champion

  • Lou Michaels5

    Colts career: 1964–1969

    Career accomplishments:
    NFL champion (1968)

  • Raul Allegre6

    Colts career: 1983–1985

    Career accomplishments:
    Second-team All-Pro selection (1983)

  • Toni Linhart7

    Colts career: 1974–1979

  • Martín Gramática8

    Colts career: 2004-2006

  • Dan Miller9
    2
    2

    Dan Miller

    Colts career: 1982

  • Matt Stover10

    Colts career: 2009

  • Jim Martin11

    Colts career: 1963

    Career accomplishments:
    NFL Comeback Player of the Year (1963)

  • Matt Bryant12

    Colts career: 2004

  • Mike Wood13
    4
    4

    Mike Wood

    Colts career: 1981–1982

  • Cary Blanchard14
    11
    15

    Cary Blanchard

    Colts career: 1995–1997

    Career accomplishments:
    Pro Bowl (1996)
    First-team All-Pro (1996)
    PFW Golden Toe Award (1996)

  • Steve Myhra15
    4
    5

    Steve Myhra

    Colts career: 1957–1961

  • Stephen Jordan16
    2
    2

    Stephen Jordan

    Colts career: 1987

  • Boris Shlapak17
    2
    4

    Boris Shlapak

    Colts career: 1972

  • George Hunt18
    4
    7

    George Hunt

    Colts career: 1973

  • Steve Mike-Mayer19
    5
    10

    Steve Mike-Mayer

    Colts career: 1979–1980

  • Dave Rayner20

    Colts career: 2005

  • Mike Cofer21

    Colts career: 1995