All The Detectives From 'Law & Order,' Ranked 

Jacob Shelton
Originally by
Updated June 2, 2020 48.5k votes 5.6k voters 79.3k views 27 items

List Rules Vote up the characters who you think are actually good detectives rather than the ones you like the most

In Law & Order’s 25 year run on network television, it has introduced viewers to a slew of detectives - some good, some great, and some who are kind of terrible at their job. But despite their failings, and because of their triumphs, everyone has a favorite Law & Order detective. Most of the time, viewers tend to ignore a detective’s ability to do their job in lieu of a juicy storyline or the officer’s charisma. But today, it’s finally time to rank the detectives on Law & Order in order of how they do their job. It’s going to be hard to be impartial, but anytime you find yourself feeling conflicted, just remember: it’s what ADA Casey Novak would do. 

The Law & Order cast is ever-expanding, and constantly adding members to its crew of detectives. Trying to remember who has been on Law & Order can be tough if you don’t have some handy graphics in front you of. So now that you’ve got a list of Law & Order detectives staring you down, it' time to decide who's the best at getting the job done. Will it be Detective Odafin Tutuola, who basically ignored his family for the first few years on the job in order to go undercover as a narcotics officer, or do you think Detective Zack Nichols did a better job while making time to play the piano in his downtime? 

Vote up the very best Law & Order detectives below, and be sure to let us know what your reasoning is in the comment section. Be sure to also check out our list of other shows like Law & Order.

Data-driven recommendations based on voting from over 40 million monthly visits to Ranker. Try the free app
Lennie Briscoe is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list All The Detectives From 'Law & Order,' Ranked
Photo:  Law & Order/NBC

Detective Briscoe has worked for the NYPD for over 30 years, and is a decorated detective and former US Corporal in the United States Army. Like many Law & Order detectives, Lennie Briscoe (Jerry Orbach) always puts the job first, even at the expense of his family. He is now a recovering alcoholic, and attends AA meetings, but unfortunately, he got clean much too late to have a real relationship with any of his family members. Briscoe's daughter OD'd, and he spends much of his time blaming himself. Lennie Briscoe passes in 2005 after retiring from the 27th precinct.

Good detective?

More Lennie Briscoe 

#89 of 214 The Saddest Television Deaths Ever #291 of 1,428 The Greatest TV Characters of All Time #33 of 152 The Greatest TV Character Losses of All Time

Olivia Benson is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list All The Detectives From 'Law & Order,' Ranked
Photo:  Law & Order: Special Victims Unit/NBC

Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay, Law & Order: Special Victims Unit) is the Patron Saint of Badass Females everywhere. She characteristically always stands up for feminism, and the rights of the victim - no matter what. As a child of rape, Benson knows what victims go through after an attack. Liv watched her alcoholic mother struggle with the fact that she had been raped until the day she died, and in order to pay it forward on behalf of her mother, Benson now acts as a victims rights advocate in every single case.   

Although she can be nurturing and helpful, don't get on Olivia Benson's bad side. She's been known to take down a perp or two, especially the ones who have tried and failed to sexually attract her. She is promoted to Sergeant after both Cragen and Munch retire, and finally understands just how difficult she, herself, was to work with when she was a young detective.   
Good detective?

More Olivia Benson 

#8 of 49 Which Current TV Character Would Be the Best Choice for President? #6 of 1,022 The Greatest Female TV Characters of All Time #11 of 64 Current TV Characters You Would Want to Be BFFs With

John Munch is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list All The Detectives From 'Law & Order,' Ranked
Photo:  Law & Order: Special Victims Unit/NBC

Detective John Munch (Richard Belzer) is your classic, paranoid, misanthropic detective. He thrives off conspiracy theories, and a new ex-wife of his seems to pop up every other season. Munch is a huge advocate for the mentally ill, as several of his ex-wives and family members have suffered from mental disorders. 

He begins his career as a detective on Homicide: Life on the Streets in the Baltimore Police Department Homicide unit. He retires, takes his pension, and moves to New York to work in the Sex Crimes unit on Law & Order: SVU. He takes the sergeant's exam on a bar bet, and passes, earning him the title of Sergeant Munch, which he serves whenever Sergeant Cragen is off duty. He eventually retires, surrounded by all of his friends at SVU. 
Good detective?

More John Munch 

#767 of 787 The Most Annoying TV and Film Characters Ever #5 of 94 The Greatest Fictional Cops & Law Enforcement Officers of All Time, Ranked #27 of 209 The Most Brilliant TV Detectives

Elliot Stabler is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list All The Detectives From 'Law & Order,' Ranked
Photo:  Law & Order: Special Victims Unit/NBC

Detective Stabler is a no nonsense, take-no-prisoners, Irish Catholic tough guy that you can't help but love. At his core, Elliot Stabler (Christopher Meloni, Law & Order: SVU) is a straight-up dad, albeit one with a sick arm tattoo from the Marines and no-holds-barred interrogation tactics. If you're a pedophile, watch out; The Stabes has your number, and you're likely to be on the receiving end of his violent temper towards perps. He almost always gets the collar, but sometimes, his anger and frustration gets the better of him.  

He retires after shooting and killing an armed suspect in the precinct; the suspect was a young girl grieving the death of her mother, and Stabler had to take her out in order to save everyone else in the squad room. 
Good detective?

More Elliot Stabler 

#213 of 1,428 The Greatest TV Characters of All Time #53 of 73 The Best Fictional Characters You'd Leave Your Man For #2 of 152 The Greatest TV Character Losses of All Time