53 voters

Every Goalie In Toronto Maple Leafs History, Ranked

February 21, 2020 1.8k votes 53 voters98 items

List RulesVote up the best goalies ever between the pipes for the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The best Toronto Maple Leafs goalies of all time have all had a hand in making the Leafs one of top Stanley Cup contenders in hockey every year. While the franchise has gone through downswings, the best years are always marked by having an excellent goaltender between the pipes.

Early stars from the franchise’s past like Turk Broda and Johnny Bower set the standard that more modern players like Felix Potvin and Ed Belfour would have to live up to in order to be considered among the best Toronto Maple Leafs goaltenders.

So check out this list of every goalie in Leafs history, and vote up who you think deserves to be considered the best Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender ever.

  • Johnny Bower1

    Maple Leafs career: 1959-1970

    Stanley Cup (1962, 1963, 1964, 1967)
    Vezina Trophy (1961, 1965)

  • Curtis Joseph2

    Maple Leafs career: 1999-2009

    King Clancy Memorial Trophy (2000)

  • Turk Broda3

    Maple Leafs career: 1937-1952

    Stanley Cup (1942, 1947, 1948, 1949, 1951)
    Vezina Trophy (1941, 1948)

  • Félix Potvin4

    Maple Leafs career: 1992-1999

  • Frederik Andersen5

    Maple Leafs career: 2017-2020

  • Ed Belfour6

    Maple Leafs career: 2003-2006

    More Ed Belfour 

    #84 of 502 The Best NHL Players of All Time#13 of 15 From Debauchery To Federal Crimes: Outrageous Tales Of Bad Behavior From History's Greatest Athletes

  • Terry Sawchuk7

    Maple Leafs career: 1965-1967

    Stanley Cup (1967)
    Vezina Trophy (1965)

  • Mike Palmateer8

    Maple Leafs career: 1977-1984

  • John Ross Roach9

    Maple Leafs career: 1922-1928

    Stanley Cup (1922)

  • Lorne Chabot10

    Maple Leafs career: 1929-1933

    Stanley Cup (1932)

  • Bruce Gamble11

    Maple Leafs career: 1966-1971

  • Harry Lumley12

    Maple Leafs career: 1953-1956

    Vezina Trophy (1954)

    More Harry Lumley 

    #23 of 36 The Most Undeserving Members of the Hockey Hall of Fame#46 of 93 The Best Toronto Maple Leafs Of All Time

  • Jacques Plante13

    Maple Leafs career: 1971-1973

  • Grant Fuhr14

    Maple Leafs career: 1992-1993

  • George Hainsworth15

    Maple Leafs career: 1934-1937

  • James Reimer16

    Maple Leafs career: 2011-2016

  • Vesa Toskala17

    Maple Leafs career: 2008-2010

  • Al Rollins18

    Maple Leafs career: 1950-1952

    Stanley Cup (1951)
    Vezina Trophy (1951)

  • Jonas Gustavsson19

    Maple Leafs career: 2010-2012

  • Jonathan Bernier20

    Maple Leafs career: 2014-2016

  • Allan Bester21

    Allan Bester

    Maple Leafs career: 1984-1991

  • Ken Wregget22

    Maple Leafs career: 1984-1989

  • Glenn Healy23

    Maple Leafs career: 1998-2001

  • Doug Favell24

    Maple Leafs career: 1974-1976

  • Wayne Thomas25

    Wayne Thomas

    Maple Leafs career: 1976-1977