The Best Movies That Were Originally Panned by Critics  

Ranker Film
21.5k votes 2.6k voters 204.4k views 23 items

List Rules Upvote your favorite movie that was panned by critics. Only add films that received a negative critical response.

Sometimes, even acclaimed film critics make hasty conclusions about new movies. Some of the best movies that were originally panned by critics turned out to be some of the most famous and beloved films of all time. Some films were released with mixed reviews, while others totally bombed. In the end, however, fan support made all the difference in these films' popularity.

When it comes down to it, critics have a subjective opinion, just like every member of the audience. Critics also tend to be more cynical and biased towards films that are breaking new ground, because they have seen so many movies in their lives. Many of these great movies that were initially hated on by critics withstood the test of time or were adopted by audiences as their favorites.

A lot of the films on this list were missed by critics because they were expecting one thing and got something else entirely. This is the case with Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas and Predator. Critics claimed there was no plot in either movie, and that they lacked real story-telling structure. The reasons why audience members like these movies, however, had nothing to do with a well-put together plot line. Many people enjoyed them because of their unique exploration of a subculture, or graphic action sequences.

Not all movies are instant classics. Some require the kindness of time to look more appealing, or the interest of a select group of fans to turn the movie into a cult classic.

back to page 1
Psycho is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list The Best Movies That Were Originally Panned by Critics
Photo:  Psycho/Universal/Paramount

Upon its release, the reviews for Psycho weren’t all terrible but rather just so-so. It's rise to Classic Film status just goes to show that if a film strikes a chord with the public, its greatness can't be denied.

At the time, though, the film was “plainly a gimmick movie,” and even a “blot on an honorable career.” In a particularly pretentiously written review, the New York Times said it had “not an abundance of subtlety” and was an “obviously low-budget job.” No one hated it, but no one thought it to be anything all that special either.

More Psycho

#5 of 257 on The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time #16 of 361 on The Best Movies Based on Books #8 of 758 on The Best Horror Movies of All Time #2 of 199 on The Best Movies of the '60s

Great movie?
see more on Psycho
Fight Club is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list The Best Movies That Were Originally Panned by Critics
Photo:  Fight Club/20th Century Fox

New York Daily News called Fight Club “hardly groundbreaking,” the Miami Herald referred to it as “a bit of a dud,” and the Boston Globe said that its “chic indictment of empty materialist values fizzles.”

More Fight Club

#7 of 257 on The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time #22 of 361 on The Best Movies Based on Books featuring 20 Surprising Facts You Didn't Know About Fight Club Little Details That Should've Made The Twist In 'Fight Club' Obvious

Great movie?
see more on Fight Club
It's a Wonderful Life is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list The Best Movies That Were Originally Panned by Critics
Photo:  It's A Wonderful Life/RKO Pictures

When It's a Wonderful Life was first released in 1946, it received generally negative reviews. It was the next generation of the '60s and '70s that so loved the film that it became the classic that it is today.

Bosley Crowther, writing for the New York Times, complimented some of the actors, including Stewart and Reed, but concluded that "the weakness of this picture, from this reviewer's point of view, is the sentimentality of it – its illusory concept of life. Mr. Capra's nice people are charming, his small town is a quite beguiling place and his pattern for solving problems is most optimistic and facile. But somehow they all resemble theatrical attitudes rather than average realities."

More It's a Wonderful Life

#95 of 1720 on The Most Rewatchable Movies #17 of 292 on The Top Tearjerker Movies That Make Men Cry featuring It's A Wonderful Life Is Not The Heartwarming Movie You Remember Ayn Rand Tried To Convince The US Government "It's A Wonderful Life" Was Communist Propaganda

Great movie?
see more on It's a Wonderful Life
Predator is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list The Best Movies That Were Originally Panned by Critics
Photo:  Predator/20th Century Fox

"Predator is a slightly above-average actioner that tries to compensate for tissue-thin-plot with ever-more-grisly death sequences and impressive special effects." – Variety

The New York Times called it “alternately grisly and dull, with few surprises,” and the Chicago Reader said, "despite the off-rhythm styling, there's not a lot going on."

More Predator

#3 of 205 on The Best Alien Movies Ever Made #85 of 334 on 'Old' Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime #21 of 537 on The Greatest Movies for Guys featuring Somehow, Making Predator Was WAY More Insane Than The Actual Movie

Great movie?
see more on Predator