The Best Movies Where the Guy Doesn't Get the Girl 

Ann Casano
13.5k votes 2.5k voters 179.4k views 20 items

WARNING! Potential spoilers on this list.

We’ve been trained by Hollywood to expect that the guy will always get the girl at the end of the movie. The couple will be greater than their differences, overcome their enormous obstacles, and fight against all odds to stay together in order to live happily ever after. That’s how all great romantic movies end, right? Yes. Except when they don't.

This is not a list of films where relationships end because someone died like in Love Story. Instead, this list ranks the best movies and rom coms that dare challenge Hollywood conventions and shove past genre codes, even at the expense of audience delight. In these movies, the guy doesn't get the girl, there isn’t a happy ending, and we can’t imagine a future filled with children and Disney vacations.

Sometimes romantic comedies and other films about relationships are actually like real life. And in real life, most relationships simply don't work out. Not every couple is meant to overcome their differences (The Way We Were), not every couple can fight against uncontrollable odds and stay together (Casablanca), and not every couple is meant to last for the long haul (500 Days of Summer).

We might cry at the end of Casablanca every time we see Bogey watch Bergman get on that plane, but admit it, doesn’t the bittersweet ending help to make Casablanca one of the best films ever made? Life isn’t all about happy endings anyway. There has to be some truth, even in our entertainment. So vote up the best movies about in which guys don't get the girl and hope that your own attempts at true love are more successful.


Captain America: The Fir... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Movies Where the Guy Doesn't Get the Girl
Photo:  Captain America: The First Avenger/Marvel
Being a superhero ain't easy, just ask Captain America. How often do heroes have to give up true love in order to save the day? Captain America (Chris Evans) falls for Peggy (Hayley Atwell) while he's fighting Nazis. But in the end, he has to make the decision to save the world from Red Skull, at the expense of his love life. Is there anything lonelier than being a hero?
Is this a great movie?

More Captain America: The First Avenger 

#14 of 165 The Greatest Comic Book Movies of All Time #97 of 101 The Worst Superhero Movies Ever Made

Casablanca is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Movies Where the Guy Doesn't Get the Girl
Photo:  Casablanca/Warner Bros.
"Here's looking at you kid." Rick (Humphrey Bogart) kisses Ilsa (Ingrid Bergman) goodbye and audiences bawl their eyes out. Yes, they will always have Paris, but why, Rick, why did you send her away?! Why?!
Is this a great movie?

More Casablanca 

#169 of 1,699 The Most Rewatchable Movies #184 of 599 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Madelisted on Every Oscar Winning Film Ever

Cast Away is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Movies Where the Guy Doesn't Get the Girl
Photo:  Cast Away/20th Century Fox
No, this isn't about Chuck (Tom Hanks) losing dear Wilson, although that is perhaps one of the most tragic events in the film. Chuck's girlfriend Kelly (Helen Hunt) thought he was dead, and though she searched for him after his disappearance, after four years she moved on to marry another man.
Is this a great movie?

More Cast Away 

#60 of 599 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made #393 of 803 The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made

Gone with the Wind is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Movies Where the Guy Doesn't Get the Girl
Photo: Gone with the Wind/Cineplex Entertainment

An epic story of romance during the American Civil War, a Southern belle and an outsider fall madly in love. But Scarlett (Vivien Leigh) turns Rhett (Clark Gable) away, then begs him to come back to her. The guy doesn't get the girl in the end, because he frankly didn't give a damn about her crying pleas that she never stopped loving him.

Is this a great movie?

More Gone with the Wind 

#3 of 93 The Very Best Oscar-Winning Movies For Best Picturefeaturing The Most Memorable 'Gone with the Wind' Quoteslisted on Every Oscar Winning Film Ever