Sports
35 voters

The Best New York Giants Kickers Of All Time

Updated December 16, 2019 393 votes 35 voters35 items

List RulesVote up kickers based only on their performance with the Giants.

The best New York Giants kickers ever have all had a part in some of the biggest moments in franchise history. NFL games can be won and lost by one or two points, making every made or missed kick of the greatest importance and every starting kicker a potential hero.

While recent stars like Lawrence Tynes and Aldrick Rosas have made their mark in the Giants’ past, early standouts like Pete Gogolak and Joe Danelo helped craft their own legacies in the old days of the franchise.

So which of these kickers from New York Giants history deserves to rank near the top of the list? Who are the best Giants kickers of all-time? Vote below, and check back to see what other football fans thought.

Photo:
...more
  • 1
    Pete Gogolak

    Giants career: 1966–1974

    Career accomplishments:
    Member of the New York Giants Ring of Honor

  • 2
    Lawrence Tynes

    Giants career: 2007–2012

    Career accomplishments: 
    2× Super Bowl champion (XLII, XLVI)
    NFC Scoring Leader (2012)

  • 3
    Raul Allegre

    Giants career: 1986–1991

    Career accomplishments: 
    2× Super Bowl champion (XXI, XXV)

  • 4
    Matt Bahr

    Giants career: 1990–1992

    Career accomplishments: 
    Super Bowl XXV champion

  • 5
    Pat Summerall

    Giants career: 1958–1961

  • 6
    Brad Daluiso

    Giants career: 1993-2000

  • 7
    Morten Andersen

    Giants career: 2001

  • 8
    Aldrick Rosas

    Giants career: 2017–present

    Career accomplishments:
    2018 Pro Bowl selection
    2018 second-team All-Pro

  • 9
    Joe Danelo
    12
    8

    Joe Danelo

    Giants career: 1976–1982

  • 10
    Josh Brown

    Giants career: 2013–2016

    Career accomplishments:
    2015 Pro Bowl selection

  • 11
    Ali Haji-Sheikh

    Giants career: 1983–1985

    Career accomplishments:
    1983 first-team All-Pro
    1983 Pro Bowl selection
    PFW Golden Toe Award (1983)

  • 12
    Ben Agajanian

    Giants career: 1954–1957

    Career accomplishments: 
    2× NFL champion (1956, 1961)

  • 13
    Eric Schubert
    5
    4

    Eric Schubert

    Giants career: 1985

  • 14
    David Treadwell

    Giants career: 1993–1994

  • 15
    Matt Bryant

    Giants career: 2002–2003

  • 16
    Paul McFadden
    4
    5

    Paul McFadden

    Giants career: 1988

  • 17
    Jess Atkinson
    2
    4

    Jess Atkinson

    Giants career: 1985

  • 18
    John Carney

    Giants career: 2008

    Career accomplishments:
    2008 Pro Bowl selection
    2008 second-team All-Pro

  • 19
    Steve Christie

    Giants career: 2004

  • 20
    Jay Feely

    Giants career: 2005–2006

    Career accomplishments:
    2005 Pro Bowl selection

  • 21
    Bob Thomas
    2
    1

    Bob Thomas

    Giants career: 1986

  • 22
    Brett Conway

    Giants career: 2003

  • 23
    Cary Blanchard
    2
    2

    Cary Blanchard

    Giants career: 1999

  • 24
    Robbie Gould
    2
    2

    Robbie Gould

    Giants career: 2016

  • 25
    Björn Nittmo

    Giants career: 1989