Even though it's supposed to be a developmental program for the WWE, NXT has earned a reputation as one of the most reliable wrestling promotions in the world. Fans anticipate every NXT TakeOver card about as much as major pay-per-views like WrestleMania or SummerSlam, with memorable matches that put NXT superstars on the map well before their main roster debuts.
TakeOvers began as sporadic WWE Network events to draw more attention to the talent on WWE's third brand, NXT. The shows filmed at the black-and-gold brand's home base, Full Sail University in Florida, and often felt like an extended (albeit very good) episode of the weekly series. This quickly changed as these specials started producing dynamic, dramatic bouts that held their own against the best WWE moments of all time. With all of the memorable contests to take place on NXT's black mat and new NXT matchesmatchest all the time, it's hard to pick just one as the greatest NXT TakeOver match of all time.
On paper, fans expected this match to be good. No one ever expected it to be the first WWE match to get five stars from Dave Meltzer since Punk/Cena at Money In The Bank 2011.
Almas and Gargano hit each other with everything they could. Seemingly every variation of the DDT was used in thrilling fashion, with too many near-falls to count. When Gargano's wife Candice LaRae hopped the barricade to spear Zelina Vega, the crowd blew up. The ending sequence where Almas hit his double knees into a prone Gargano slumped against the ring post was vicious, and his final hanging top-rope DDT not only earned a standing ovation from the crowd, but cemented him as a bright star in WWE.
Drama makes for the best wrestling matches, and this contest between Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa was overflowing with drama. The feud between former the NXT Tag Team Champions brewed and then boiled over without Ciampa even setting foot in the ring for the better part of a year. While fans were ready to boo him for attacking Johnny Wrestling at TakeOver Brooklyn III, Ciampa's use of social media built even more heat and earned him the title of "Blackheart."
Ciampa and Gargano's "unsanctioned" match at NXT TakeOver: New Orleans was a clear highlight of WrestleMania weekend and one of only three NXT matches to have ever earned 5 stars from Dave Meltzer. The moment when Gargano went to clock Ciampa with his broken crutch and stopped was one of the most heartfelt and emotional moments many fans ever witnessed inside of a ring. Ciampa turned down that moment of mercy, leading to a epic finish with Gargano using the Blackheart's own knee brace to lock in the Gargano Escape and submit the heel.
The Revival and DIY hold the distinction of being in the only two of three falls match in NXT TakeOver history. And for good reason, since no one's been able to top the absolutely bonkers near-fall fest at NXT TakeOver: Toronto. Fans thought the were watching the final sequence when the Revival missed hitting Gargano with DIY's finisher, only for Wilder to get hit with the Shatter Machine - and he kicked out after a two count.
The legendary moment of the match was when Ciampa and Gargano applied a dual submissions to Dash and Dawson. Just like in at TakeOver: Brooklyn II, the Revival clutched onto each other for dear life to avoid tapping. But when they both submitted and new NXT Tag Champions were crowned, this match became a legit 4.5 star classic.
When Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate walked into their bout at NXT TakeOver: Chicago, they received polite applause. After their match, they received a standing ovation. Fighting for the WWE U.K. championship, Bate and Dunne produced a clinic on modern British professional wrestling. They combined the traditional World of Sport style with lucha, Japanese Strong Style, and American sports entertainment.
The Chicago crowd leaped to their feet to cheer on the then 20-year-old Bate and 22-year-old Dunne as they threw punches in the middle of the ring. The crowd in the arena praised the match, and even respected wrestling figures like Jim Cornette became fans of the young Brits after the fight.