The Best Performances to Not Win an Oscar  

Ann Casano
26.4k votes 3.5k voters 129.2k views 20 items

The actor is everything in film. Sure, the writer provides the words, and the director supplies the vision, but it's the actor who represents the characters and brings them to life. A bad acting performance can completely mar the best of dialogue, just as a superior performance can lift the most lifeless of words. We cherish the film actor, we revel in their celebrity, and often bathe in their beauty. However, there can only be one Academy Award winner for each category every year. This is a list of those other roles that weren't recognized, the best performances that did not win an Oscar.

This list is not about who should have won. No one is here to argue that Bradley Cooper should have beat out Eddie Redmayne for Best Actor in 2015. Cooper did not get snubbed, he did not get robbed, we're not taking anything away from Redmayne's brilliant depiction of Stephen Hawking in The Theory of Everything. But the fact that Cooper gave such an outstanding performance in American Sniper must be recognized. That's what this list is truly about. Call it Ranker’s list for acting redemption.

Some of the actors and actresses on this list, were not even nominated for Oscars. Their performance, for whatever reason, was not recognized by the finicky members of the Academy. Perhaps, it was because of genre bias? Both comedy and horror films rarely get the recognition they deserve. For example, most film buffs think that Jack Nicholson should have received a nod for his terrifying performance in The Shining and who can argue that Dustin Hoffman didn't turn in a perfect performance in Tootsie?

Let us know in the comments section if we missed any of your favorite big screen performances that failed to take home an Academy Award and be sure to vote up the performances below you think should be recognized for their outstanding quality, despite not winning on Oscar night.
Edward Norton is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Performances to Not Win an Oscar
Photo:  American History X/New Line Cinema

The Role: Hate, rage, and anger transition to peace, understanding, and atonement for Derek Vinyard (Ed Norton) in Tony Kaye's 1998 hard-hitting drama American History X. We watch Derek go from pumped-up Nazi sympathizer, to a man seeking redemption after a harrowing prison stint. Norton convincingly captures every emotion. We feel something for him at each point in the film, even the segments when he's spewing hate-filled rhetoric. Norton received his second Oscar nod for the role in 1998.

Winner for Best Actor in 1998: Roberto Benigni, Life Is Beautiful

More Edward Norton

#37 of 1167 on The Best Actors in Film History #15 of 267 on The Best (Male) Actors Working Today featuring There's A Very Compelling Reason Edward Norton Is No Longer The Incredible Hulk The Best Edward Norton Movies

Was this Oscar worthy?
see more on Edward Norton
Robert De Niro is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Performances to Not Win an Oscar
Photo:  Taxi Driver/Columbia Pictures

The Role: De Niro plays alienated loner Travis Bickle in Martin Scorsese's 1976 character study Taxi Driver. Bickle is a delusional psychopath, but his heart is in the right place. De Niro somehow forces us to sympathize with Bickle's monstrous side, even if we really hope that he doesn't make it out alive. The method actor earned an Oscar nomination for the role and took home the Best Supporting Actor trophy the previous year, for his portrayal of young Don Vito Corleone in The Godfather II.

Winner for Best Actor in 1976: Peter Finch, Network

More Robert De Niro

#4 of 1167 on The Best Actors in Film History #24 of 37 on Actors Who Are Having Their Best Year In 2019 featuring The Most Unhinged (And True) Robert De Niro Stories Ever Told The Best Robert De Niro Movies

Was this Oscar worthy?
see more on Robert De Niro
Jack Nicholson is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Performances to Not Win an Oscar
Photo:  The Shining/Warner Bros.

The Role: "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy." Jack Nicholson takes on Jack Torrance in Stanley Kubrick's 1980 horror masterpiece The Shining. Torrance, who suffers from severe writer's block, rapidly descents into total madness. The insanity is right there in Nicholson's eyes. The actor did not receive a nomination for the role, as the Academy rarely recognizes horror films.

Winner for Best Actor in 1980: Dustin Hoffman, Kramer vs. Kramer

More Jack Nicholson

#3 of 1167 on The Best Actors in Film History #11 of 339 on The Coolest Actors Ever featuring The Best Jack Nicholson Movies The Greatest Characters Played by Jack Nicholson, Ranked

Was this Oscar worthy?
see more on Jack Nicholson
Ed Norton, Primal Fear
Ed Norton, Primal Fear is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Performances to Not Win an Oscar
Photo:  Primal Fear/Paramount Pictures

The Role: Ed Norton knocks it out of the park as an altar boy accused of murder in his 1996 feature film debut Primal Fear. Think you can tell a sweet, innocent young man from a manipulative killer? Norton's performance will make you question your own sanity. This was the first of three Oscar nominations for the actor.

Winner for Best Supporting Actor in 1997: Cuba Gooding, Jr., Jerry Maguire
Was this Oscar worthy?