The Best "Big Game" Performances by a Quarterback 

Brandon Oliver
Updated October 13, 2018 2.5k votes 369 voters 6.5k views 26 items

List Rules Vote for the best quarterback based specifically on how they performed in the Super Bowl mentioned.

The Super Bowl is the biggest event in American sports and many of the game's greatest all-time quarterbacks have been labeled either a legend or a disappointment based on their Super Bowl performances and whether or not their team took home championship rings.

The best quarterbacks in NFL history will always be the ones who rose to the occasion on the biggest stage of their lives. There were plenty of great performances by quarterbacks of the team which wound up on the losing end of the Super Bowl. There were also plenty of average performances by Super Bowl winning quarterbacks who won the biggest game of their lives. No matter how a quarterback's career goes, it all boils down to the way Super Bowl Sunday plays out.

All-time greats Joe Montana, Terry Bradshaw, Tom Brady, Troy Aikman, John Elway, Eli Manning, Bob Griese, Ben Roethlisberger, Roger Staubach and Bart Starr all won multiple Super Bowls. Their status as multi-time Super Bowl champions gives them a leg up in the ongoing debate over who the greatest quarterback of all-time truly is.

Jim Kelly (4) and Fran Tarkenton (3) each felt defeat numerous times in the Super Bowl without ever experiencing the joy of victory. Let the debate rage on in regards to which quarterback had the best performance in Super Bowl history.  
Joe Montana (Super Bowl ... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best "Big Game" Performances by a Quarterback
Photo: flickr/CC0
Joe Montana (Super Bowl XXIII)

In the 49ers 20-16 win over the Cincinnati in Super Bowl XXIII, Joe Montana was brilliant.

The legendary quarterback went 23-of-36 for 357 yards and two touchdowns. More impressively, Montana went 8-of-9 on an 11-play drive which covered 92-yards. He ended it with a 10-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver John taylor with 34 seconds remaining. 
Agree or disagree?
Joe Montana (Super Bowl ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best "Big Game" Performances by a Quarterback
Photo: Wikimedia Commons/CC-BY
Joe Montana (Super Bowl XXIV)

Among his many Super Bowl appearances, Joe Montana's cleanest performance may come in the 49ers blowout win over the Denver Broncos is Super Bowl XXIV.

Montana went 22-of-29 for 297 yards and five touchdowns in the 55-10 win. 
Agree or disagree?
Joe Montana is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best "Big Game" Performances by a Quarterback
Photo:  Bobby Bank/Getty Images

Joe Montana proved his worth every time he stepped on the field in a Super Bowl, but his performance in Super Bowl XIX against the Miami Dolphins might be his best.

Montana went 24-of-35 for 331 yards with three touchdowns in the 49ers 38-16 win. 

Position: Quarterback

Birthplace: New Eagle, Pennsylvania, United States of America

Age: 62

Teams: Notre Dame Fighting Irish football, San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs

Agree or disagree?

More Joe Montana 

#22 of 2,166 The Best Athletes Of All Time #332 of 532 Famous Men You'd Want to Have a Beer Withlisted on Athletes You Didn't Know Were Conservative

Eli Manning is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best "Big Game" Performances by a Quarterback
Photo:  Wikimedia Commons (CC-BY)

Manning was outstanding in his first ever Super Bowl appearance as he led the Giants over the previously undefeated New England Patriots, 17-14.

Manning went 19-of-34 for 255 yards, two touchdowns and an interception. More impressive was the manner in which he did it. Look up "David Tyree" if it still doesn't ring a bell. 

Position: Quarterback

Birthplace: New Orleans, Louisiana, United States of America

Age: 38

Teams: New York Giants

Agree or disagree?

More Eli Manning 

#1,008 of 2,166 The Best Athletes Of All Time #177 of 1,536 The Best Football Players Ever