Graveyard Shift Horror And Supernatural Podcasts To Fill Your Ears With Terror  

Melissa Brinks
514 votes 274 voters 20.5k views 10 items

List Rules Vote up the podcasts perfect for scaring your pants off.

Though horror fans might love the spooky visuals that come from film, horror podcasts are able to capitalize on the frightfulness of what one doesn’t see. That’s why supernatural podcasts are so scary - they aren't restricted by one person's idea of what is spooky, the listener can let their own imagination run wild. The best creepy podcasts make use of sound to emphasize the horror, using eerie music and noises in shiver-inducing ways.

As a continuation of an older medium, radio, podcasts have a long history with the horror genre. Adaptations of Frankenstein and Dracula set early precedents for the power of sound in delivering spooky stories. War of the Worlds will forever be remembered for the country-wide panic it instigated and is a lasting reminder of how powerful audio can be.

Here are a few podcasts for supernatural lovers that carry forward those horror traditions into today. All of the podcasts listed here prove that while a picture might be worth a thousand words, well-written stories and old-fashioned spooky audio are worth a thousand goosebumps. Is your favorite on here? Vote it up to reach the top spot.

1 127 VOTES

Legend And History Combine In Lore

Legend And History Combine In ... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Horror And Supernatural Podcasts To Fill Your Ears With Terror
Photo: Lore

Lore is the perfect blend of creepy campfire tales and history. Host Aaron Mahnke takes a deep dive into different legends and myths in each episode. Through historical research, he explores the truth behind well-known horror lore like werewolves, aliens, and ghosts with laser-sharp focus. He also highlights lesser known stories from history, highlighting some of the more bizarre, gruesome, and just plain creepy true stories to be found.

The show’s perfect blend of skepticism and mystery makes it a fascinating listen for even the most die-hard nonbeliever.

Subscribe here via iTunes.

110 17
Is this a good podcast?
2 69 VOTES

The NoSleep Podcast Will Have You Wondering What's Real And What Isn't

The NoSleep Podcast Will Have ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Horror And Supernatural Podcasts To Fill Your Ears With Terror
Photo: The NoSleep Podcast

The NoSleep Podcast, based on the fantastic horror subreddit of the same name, brings horror fiction written by a variety of modern authors to horror enthusiasts' ears. NoSleep has a distinct air of believability about it achieved through first-person narration. Every story on NoSleep is presented as real giving the entire podcast a unique sense of the uncanny that few shows replicate.

Subscribe here via iTunes.

56 13
Is this a good podcast?
3 89 VOTES

The Black Tapes Explores Skepticism And Belief

The Black Tapes Explores Skept... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Horror And Supernatural Podcasts To Fill Your Ears With Terror
Photo: The Black Tapes

The Black Tapes blends the intrigue of interview-based podcasts like This American Life or Radiolab with a fictional, freaky, ever-evolving, supernatural story. In this weekly docudrama, radio host Alex Reagan investigates The Strand Institute, a paranormal research group founded by notable skeptic Richard Strand. As the story unravels, Alex learns that all is not what it seems. Alex's worldview and faith are shaken as she encounters horrors both natural and supernatural.

Subscribe here via iTunes.

64 25
Is this a good podcast?
4 33 VOTES

Alice Isn't Dead Is A Freaky Roadtrip Across The Country

Alice Isn't Dead Is A Freaky R... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Horror And Supernatural Podcasts To Fill Your Ears With Terror
Photo: Alice Isn't Dead

From the creators of Welcome to Night Vale, another podcast exploring the creepy happenings of a small town, comes Alice Isn’t Dead. This podcast follows a commercial truck driver on her journey across America in search of her lost wife, Alice. Her eerie road trip is decidedly unsettling. 

The narrator’s first-person storytelling - sounding as though spoken via CB radio - is directed to the missing/presumed dead Alice. Featuring ghost towns, horrifying strangers, and an innovative and powerful use of the medium make Alice Isn’t Dead a fabulous horror podcast with a unique supernatural feel.

Subscribe here via iTunes.

29 4
Is this a good podcast?