The Greatest TV Characters Who Weren't in Season 1  

Randy Miller
14.2k votes 2.8k voters 156.9k views 18 items

List Rules Series regulars who did not appear in the first season of the show only. Vote up the ones you now can't imagine the series without.

Some of the best TV shows - the ones that eventually soar to critical acclaim and garner millions of die-hard fans - don't always hit the ground running. It can be pretty hard to find your footing that first year. In fact, there are a lot of TV characters added after Season 1 that went on to become integral to their shows.

One of the most tried and true methods that showrunners use to stabilize a shaky first season is introducing new characters. A new character can energize a lagging plot line, or even lead to a new plot line entirely, taking the show in directions that may not have been originally intended.

Not all new characters work. Many are summarily dismissed. But some of these new characters feel so enmeshed in the fabric of the show, it's hard to believe that there was a time when they weren't a part of it at all.

This is a list of the greatest television characters who weren't in the first season. Vote up the series regulars who became most integral to their series. And if you don't like the order this list is in, feel free to rerank it. In fact, it's highly encouraged. Make your voice heard for the best TV characters who weren't in Season 1.
Frank Reynolds is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Greatest TV Characters Who Weren't in Season 1
Photo: FX

Wait, you mean Frank Reynolds wasn't always there? It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia existed without him?

It's true. It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia had a seven-episode first season where there was no Danny DeVito to be found. He joined the gang at the start of Season 2 in "Charlie Gets Crippled" and has been deplorable and hilarious ever since.

Series: It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia

Actor: Danny DeVito

Episode: Season 2, Episode 1 "Charlie Gets Crippled"

More Frank Reynolds

#21 of 49 on The Greatest Jovial Fat Guys in TV History #1 of 12 on Which 'It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia' Character Are You Based On Your Zodiac Sign? #9 of 23 on The Best Fictional Managers featuring All Of Frank’s Wildest Schemes On ‘It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia’

Glad s/he's on the show?
see more on Frank Reynolds
Butters Stotch is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Greatest TV Characters Who Weren't in Season 1
Photo: Metaweb (FB)/Fair use
Aw, Butters. Sweet, happy, wholesome Butters Stotch had been a friend of Stan, Kyle, Kenny, and Cartman on South Park for years, but he was never actually introduced (or allowed to speak) until midway through Season 3 in an episode called "Two Guys Naked in a Hot Tub." Even when he's (poorly) planning destruction as his alter ego "Professor Chaos," you just can't help but root for the lovable little guy.

Series: South Park

Actor: Matt Stone

Episode: Season 3, Episode 8 "Two Guys Naked in a Hot Tub"

More Butters Stotch

#37 of 503 on The Funniest TV Characters of All Time #48 of 163 on The Best Cartoon Characters of the 90s #6 of 14 on 14 Fan-Favorite TV Characters Who Were Never Supposed To Have Major Roles featuring Ranking Every Butters Episode of South Park Best to Worst

Glad s/he's on the show?
see more on Butters Stotch
Brienne of Tarth is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Greatest TV Characters Who Weren't in Season 1
Photo: HBO
Has there ever been a more loyal and fully realized female character than Brienne of Tarth? Gwendolyn Christie brings a touching humanity and a sly sense of humor to this powerful warrior, though we don't get to meet her until the third episode of Season 2, "What Is Dead May Never Die." Game of Thrones is not short on powerful women, to be sure. But Brienne has a true heart (and a great sword) that elevates her above all around her.  

Series: Game of Thrones

Actor: Gwendoline Christie

Episode: Season 2, Episode 3 "What is Dead May Never Die"

More Brienne of Tarth

#63 of 288 on The Best Female Characters in Literature #14 of 119 on The Best 'Game Of Thrones' Characters featuring 20 Best Brienne Memes From 'Game Of Thrones' Finale The Best Brienne of Tarth Quotes

Glad s/he's on the show?
see more on Brienne of Tarth
Ben Wyatt is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Greatest TV Characters Who Weren't in Season 1
Photo: via Twitter
What is Leslie Knope without Ben Wyatt? Parks & Recreation had a shaky start and a lot of early characters (like Paul Schneider's Mark Brendanawicz) didn't make it out alive. But the show found its footing when Ben Wyatt (Adam Scott) and Chris Traeger (Rob Lowe) came to Pawnee late in Season 2 in "The Master Plan." The relationship that followed between Leslie and Ben truly gave Parks & Rec the heart that balanced out the comedy which made the show so special.

Series: Parks and Recreation

Actor: Adam Scott

Episode: Season 2, Episode 23 "The Master Plan"

More Ben Wyatt

#5 of 34 on The Best Parks and Recreation Characters #51 of 69 on The Best Fictional Characters You'd Leave Your Man For #37 of 111 on Fictional Political Candidates You'd Cast Your Ballot For #3 of 25 on The Best Married Couples In TV History

Glad s/he's on the show?
see more on Ben Wyatt