Graveyard Shift The Objectively Worst Decisions In 'Bird Box'  

Jacob Shelton
2.7k votes 476 voters 19.1k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up the regrettable decisions that made you facepalm.

Bird Box - the Netflix film about a world in which unnamed supernatural creatures cause humans to end their own lives - is full of intense and upsetting imagery. It explores how humans might act when the world breaks down, and questions how far people will go to save their loved ones. It also has characters who make a lot of bad decisions. Whether they’re attempting to steer a boat blindfolded or getting drunk in the middle of the apocalypse, everyone in the film acts like they’ve never seen a scary movie before. 

This isn’t to say the characters' regrettable decisions aren't somewhat understandable. They’re living through an absolutely horrible series of events - the Bird Box creatures are inarguably scary and most of the survivors' loved ones have met grisly ends. Even so, at some point, you’ve got to put your head on straight and start making good decisions. How would you handle the world of Bird Box? Would you play it safe, or would you make the same bad decisions as Sandra Bullock? 

1 308 VOTES

Charlie Opens The Door For Fish Fingers

Charlie Opens The Door For Fis... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In 'Bird Box'
Photo: Netflix

While grabbing supplies from the grocery store, Charlie finds his friend "Fish Fingers" on the other side of a loading bay door. He's smashing his fists against the door and screaming at the top of his lungs. It's clear he's not having a good time. 

Why, oh why, does the group open the door for Fish Fingers? In doing so, they effectively annihilate Charlie, a budding author and one of the few characters who seems to have an idea of what they're up against. When Charlie goes, they also lose the one guy with a key to the supermarket. Sure, the food won't last forever, but it's nice to have it all locked up. 

297 11
Is this a bad call?
2 257 VOTES

The Survivors Let Gary Into the House

The Survivors Let Gary Into th... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In 'Bird Box'
Photo: Netflix

Even though Gary effectively ruins the survivors' suburban sanctuary, their decision to let him in the house is still up for debate. They think they are saving a good guy who is simply seeking shelter from an apocalyptic world. It would be heartless to leave him alone outside. 

However, their one definitive mistake is allowing him to putter around in the house by himself while Malorie and Olympia give birth upstairs. It should be apparent to everyone that something is off with him when he pulls out his creepy drawings, starts dancing to Aretha Franklin, and throws the birds in the freezer. 

244 13
Is this a bad call?
3 271 VOTES

Felix And Lucy Take The Car And Leave The Group

Felix And Lucy Take The Car An... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In 'Bird Box'
Photo: Netflix

The initial group comes together at Greg's house by sheer luck. They may not all get along, but they grow to respect each other. They work together and they have food, water, and protection. Essentially, the house is the best place they can be. 

Regardless of how safe the house is, Felix and Lucy take the group's only car and drive off. It's an objectively bad decision for them to leave known supplies and shelter to try their luck somewhere else in the city. 

252 19
Is this a bad call?
4 226 VOTES

Survivors Regularly Decide To Talk With Strangers

Survivors Regularly Decide To ... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Objectively Worst Decisions In 'Bird Box'
Photo: Netflix

Five years after the world comes to a standstill - and after Malorie gives birth to a child during Gary's crazed rampage - humans keep to themselves and do their best to hide from the creatures and other people, as well. Once Malorie and Tom begin living as a family with the kids, pretty much everyone they meet tries to make them look at the supernatural beings. 

Tom meets his end in an attempt to save Malorie when a group of assailants discover their house. Later, when Malorie and the kids are traveling downriver, a guy comes out of nowhere and tries to do something disturbing with a hook. Instead of speaking to him, Malorie should have simply paddled her heart out. Seriously, when has a man with a hook in the middle of a river ever been a good thing? 

212 14
Is this a bad call?