Total Nerd

Blue's Clues Fan Theories  

Brandon Michaels
832 votes 181 voters 3.9k views 11 items

List Rules Vote up the theories you believe could be true.

Debuting in 1996, Blue's Clues was a national phenomenon. Pre-school children everywhere were Skidooing into make-believe worlds with Steve and his dog Blue. The show's characters were household names, much like the residents of Sesame Street before them.

Even decades later, fans are still thinking about Blue's Clues mysteries. Thank to nostalgic '90s kids, the internet is rife with Blue's Clues fan theories. While a lot of the speculation is goofy, the better ideas could potentially crack open some of televison's greatest enigmas.  

It's time for the world to know whether Mrs. Pepper cheated on Mr. Salt or if Steve's house is possessed by a malignant spirit. 

1 123 VOTES
Steve's A Babysitter
Steve's A Babysitter is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Blue's Clues Fan Theories
Photo:  Viacom

If you're wondering why Steve is constantly addressing the camera or seemingly talking to himself, Redditor /u/Chengweiyingji has a theory that makes sense.

Steve is babysitting! When he talks to the camera, he's addressing the kids he's watching. That explains all the make-believe, playing dumb, and educational activities. You even hear the kids responding to Steve (although you never see any kids except in the mail videos). 

This theory also explains how Steve can afford to go to college; when you never leave the house, it's easy to save up thousands of dollars. 

Is this plausible?
2 97 VOTES
Blue Got A Job After The Show Ended
Blue Got A Job After The Show ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Blue's Clues Fan Theories
Photo:  Amazon

Redditor /u/ThatPlaystationUser noticed a striking similarity between the beloved Blue and the spokes-dog for a popular brand of treats.

Like many washed-up celebrities, Blue was forced to sell out for profit once the show ended. She began endorsing products and modeling for advertisements to maintain the lifestyle she was accustomed to. This wasn't such a bad deal for ol' Blue though, as the new job included a lifetime supply of treats. 

Is this plausible?
3 90 VOTES
Steve Was In The CIA
Steve Was In The CIA is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Blue's Clues Fan Theories
Photo:  Viacom

Redditor /u/SilverarcTheJoker thinks Steve never actually went to college. Instead, Steve's sordid past as an "ex-CIA specialist in subliminal messages and manipulation" caught up with him. The user continues:

He assumed the identity of Steve and hid in plain site in front of millions of young children who would lead the next generation. He decided to use his skills to try and persuade children, and the parents watching his show, to sit down in the thinking chair and think... think... thiiiiiiiiink about government... manipulation of the American people.

He also warned of anthrax in the mail because he would always wail when it arrived.

The whole show was based around searching for clues to piece together the truth from an entity that couldn't speak, representing the government's suppression of our rights and free thought. 

After being discovered in his new life, "he left America's youth with one final message: search for knowledge and think for yourself. He actually fled to South America where he still lives to this day, after assuming another identity."

Is this plausible?
4 80 VOTES
Mrs. Pepper Had An Affair
Mrs. Pepper Had An Affair is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Blue's Clues Fan Theories
Photo:  Viacom

If you've ever tried combining salt and pepper, you know the result is not paprika or cinnamon. Given this material reality, one has to wonder how Mr. Salt and Mrs. Pepper conceived their children. 

Some fans believe Pepper is actually married to Dr. Pepper (the soda) and is cheating on him with Mr. Salt. Maybe one day we'll see Mr. Salt and Mrs. Pepper on a daytime talk show and finally learn the truth.

Is this plausible?