Photo:
Music
15.1k readers

Bonnaroo 2012 Reviewed + Ranked

Updated May 25, 2019 15.1k views25 items

List RulesRanked by how much I dug the set, basically.

Reviews, videos, and setlists of the Bonnaroo Festival 2012, all 25 artists that I saw. Ranking and reviewing all the music I caught live at the Bonnaroo Fest in Manchester, TN. Overall, a strong festival - not the best Bonnaroo I've been to (one of these days I will rank rock festivals themselves against each other), but a great time nonetheless.

Headliners this year are Radiohead, Red Hot Chili Peppers, and Phish - a pretty top-knotch set of headliners, but there are also great young bands like Alabama Shakes, Michael Kiwanuka, and Gary Clark Jr. making their Bonnaroo fest debuts earlier in the day. 2012 is a pretty solid Bonnaroo lineup, and has benefitted from some late additions including Danzig Legacy and Sharon Jones. Video footage of each band added when it can be found on Youtube. Consider this to be an overall Bonnaroo 2012 review.

I'd also like to add that thought I didn't actually watch Skrillex, we caught about 20mins of his set from a distance while stopping for some food and "regrouping" to head back to crash for the night, and I was pretty impressed. While it's not quite my style of electronica, seeing the live show I totally "get it". I didn't include Skrillex in the rankings because without actually being engaged in watching the band, it's not really fair to rank them.
...more
  • Phish
    Video: YouTube

    First set: it is drizzling throughout. The opening (DWD/Funky Bitch/Moma Dance) bores me (and much of the crowd) silly. But then it picks up a bit and a half hour in Kenny Rogers joins for . . . The Gambler. A classic goofy-yet-solid Phish moment. The rest of the set is pretty good - I'd give it a B+ (C+ without the Kenny Rogers)

    2nd set:
    After a shorter-than-usual break (respecting the crowd being in the rain and all, though it has stopped raining by the start of this set), they come out with a noticably higher energy level, playing a song I recognize but don't think I've heard Phish cover. It takes me a minute but it's TV On The Radio's "Golden Age". Wow. This sets the tone, and they never let up this set is as good as their Friday night at Bonnaroo 09, which is about as good as a Phish set can get. Audibles were certainly called - Trey hijacked a pretty strong Hood Ending and went into Light - and what a version of Light, easily the best I've heard (see video around 9:40, Trey veers away from the ending coda to Hood). No other guest stars or weird setlist oddities - just a stellar, stellar show.

    Setlist-
    Set One:
    Down With Disease
    Funky Bitch (Son Seals cover)
    The Moma Dance
    Sample In A Jar
    Axilla I
    The Gambler (Kenny Rogers cover) (with Kenny Rogers)
    Possum
    Wilson
    Tweezer
    Free
    Backwards Down The Number Line
    Cavern

    Set Two:
    Golden Age (TV on the Radio cover)
    2001 (Richard Strauss cover)
    Chalkdust Torture
    Carini
    Shafty
    Rock & Roll (The Velvet Underground cover)
    Alaska
    Harry Hood
    Light
    Character Zero
    Rocky Top (Lynn Anderson cover)

    Encore:
    Show Of Life
    Julius
    Tweezer Reprise
  • 2

    Danzig Legacy

    Every bit as good as the show last year that blew me away at Gibson (and nice that the setlist changed up a bit). Though I am hoping that Sunday nite's Phish show will top this ranking, I have to say that hearing Danzig's excellent band doing a full course in Danzig history with Samhain and Misfits bandmembers has been the highlight of my Bonnaroo so far.

    Additionally, there was some entertaining drama. At first it seemed like the Bonnaroo vibe was even getting through to Glenn - Danzig actually smiled and said "he's just a bit over zealous" when an early stage crasher touched his person before security could pull him offstage.

    But then right before the switchover to the Samhain set, disaster strikes. Some photog in the pit looked at Danzig wrong or something and a big brough-ha-ha (sp?) commenced. I have posted the video (funnily, you can see my friend Dan and I at around 1:35 in the video, Dan's got the hat and bandana on and I'm talking to him wearing a grey tshirt). After the guy was escorted away Danzig whined about "ruining it for everyone" and I was nervous that the tantrum would cut the set short. But after a longer-than-usual Samhain intro, he came back out and all was saved, and we got to hear our Misfits gems, probably for the last time live.

    It's hard to pogo when you have a backpack on but rest assured that I would have.

    Setlist:
    SkinCarver
    Twist of Cain
    Hammer of the Gods
    Rebel Spirits
    Her Black Wings
    Devil's Plaything
    How the Gods Kill
    Dirty Black Summer
    It's Coming Down

    Samhain
    Initium / Samhain (Samhain cover)
    All Murder, All Guts, All Fun (Samhain cover)
    Horror Biz (Samhain cover)
    Unholy Passion (Samhain cover)
    To Walk the Night (Samhain cover)
    Mother of Mercy (Samhain cover)

    Misfits with Doyle
    Death Comes Ripping (Misfits cover)
    Vampira (Misfits cover)
    Bullet (Misfits cover)
    I Turned Into a Martian (Misfits cover)
    Night of the Living Dead (Misfits cover)
    Astro Zombies (Misfits cover)
    London Dungeon (Misfits cover)
    Last Caress (Misfits cover)

    Encore:
    Bringer of Death
    It's Coming Down
    Mother

    Encore 2:
    She Rides
    Skulls (Misfits cover)
  • Radiohead
    Video: YouTube

    Main stage, 10PM Friday.

    The first hour of Radiohead's Bonnaroo 2012 set is almost all new songs - some of them even unreleased-new, with the exception of a nice surprise in "I Might Be Wrong". They mix it up more in the 2nd part of the 2 hours and 20mins set, but like their other setlists of this year, it's mostly stuff from the last 5 years. Overall the show is a bit better than the Coachella (2nd weekend) set - Yorke seemed a bit looser, the band in general really seemed like they were having fun.

    While I have to question slanting the setlists so far towards new material when playing to huge festival crowds, this was still a great performance, better than the last 2 times I've seen Radiohead and better than their previous Bonnaroo set (2006 I believe).

    Setlist:
    Bloom
    15 Step
    Kid A
    Weird Fishes/Arpeggi
    Staircase
    The Daily Mail
    I Might Be Wrong
    The Gloaming
    Separator
    Nude
    Morning Mr. Magpie
    Identikit
    Lotus Flower
    There There
    Karma Police
    Feral
    Idioteque

    Encore:
    You and Whose Army?
    House of Cards
    Supercollider
    (Thom Yorke dedicated song to Jack White)
    Bodysnatchers
    Everything In Its Right Place
    (True Love Waits intro)

    Encore 2:
    Give Up the Ghost
    Reckoner
    Paranoid Android

    More Radiohead 

    The Best Radiohead Songs of All Time#368 of 1,891 The Greatest Musical Artists of All Time#100 of 1,728 The Best Rock Bands of All Time

  • Alabama Shakes
    Photo: Wikimedia Commons / CC-BY

    More Alabama Shakes 

    #58 of 154 The Greatest Chick Rock Bands Ever#108 of 126 The Best Black Rock Bands#247 of 559 The Most Hipster Bands