Anime Underground

15 Anime Protagonists Who Just Aren't That Interesting  

Anna Lindwasser
15.5k votes 3.7k voters 33.8k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the protagonists who are probably better off as side characters.

Many cartoon fans have experienced characters who are as dull as dirt. And, indeed, boring anime protagonists can make it hard to actually enjoy the series in question. These characters aren't necessarily bad. Some of them are beloved for good reason; they're occasionally charming. The majority of lackluster protagonists, though, don't deserve the spotlight. There are plenty of other secondary characters who grow and change in anime. They keep the show exciting; and sometimes they deserve their own spin-off series. Boring protagonists, however, can sink an otherwise promising series. 

1 1,607 VOTES
Ash Ketchum is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 15 Anime Protagonists Who Just Aren't That Interesting
Photo:  Pokémon/OLM

The Pokémon world is expansive and magical, but all Ash Ketchum cares about is catching new fighters. The main character has a clear goal: he wants to become a Pokémon master and capture at least one of every Pokémon. There's not much to him besides his mission, however.

He's just a loud, excitable kid who never changes or learns anything from his experiences. He doesn't even age. 

More Ash Ketchum

#44 of 87 on Characters You Most Want To See In Super Smash Bros. Switch #48 of 141 on The Best Anime Characters With Black Hair #2 of 15 on 15 Really Cool Anime Characters Who Got Wack Over Time

Is this character dull?
see more on Ash Ketchum
Yukiteru Amano is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 15 Anime Protagonists Who Just Aren't That Interesting
Photo:  Future Diary/Asread

According to some Future Diary fans, Yukiteru Amano is the worst thing about the show. He spends the first part of the series unable to make even the most basic decisions. And he relies on Yuno - his stalker - to handle everything he faces during the Survival Game.

Yuki does eventually begin to make some of his own decisions, but his development is too little, too late.

More Yukiteru Amano

#39 of 113 on The Best Anime Characters With Brown Hair #9 of 14 on 14 Anime Characters Who Ended Up With The Wrong Person #22 of 60 on Anime Characters Ranked By How Tragically Their Parents Died

Is this character dull?
see more on Yukiteru Amano
Shinji Ikari is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 15 Anime Protagonists Who Just Aren't That Interesting
Photo: via Wikimedia Commons

Shinji is a character unmoved by the fantastical world around him. He's uninterested in his lot in life, which includes piloting giant bio-machine mechas (something most people would be pretty excited about). When a character is constantly referencing their indifference towards the very crux of their program's narrative, it's hard to engage with the show as an audience member. 

More Shinji Ikari

#72 of 113 on The Best Anime Characters With Brown Hair #10 of 13 on 13 Shocking Anime Massacres That Claimed A Ton of Lives #1 of 14 on 14 Times Anime Heroes Were Guilty Of Awful Things #3 of 15 on 15 Anime Characters Who Are Their Own Worst Enemy

Is this character dull?
see more on Shinji Ikari
Kirito is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 15 Anime Protagonists Who Just Aren't That Interesting
Photo:  Sword Art Online/A-1 Pictures

Kirito of Sword Art Online tries to be edgy with his black clothes and standoffish behavior, but he's almost aggressively underwhelming. He likes to defend other characters who are inexplicably weak, but it's hard to take his battles seriously. He has no real competition, so he always wins.

Kirito even looks bland in comparison to all the other colorfully drawn and designed characters on the show.

More Kirito

#24 of 358 on The Hottest Anime Guys of All Time #67 of 1142 on The Very Best Anime Characters #23 of 146 on 25+ Anime Boys You Definitely Crushed On #9 of 113 on The Best Anime Swordsman of All Time

Is this character dull?
see more on Kirito