VOTE
300 voters

Casting It Part 2: Actresses (Who Aren't Jessica Chastain) Who Should Play Beverly In The Sequel

Updated November 10, 2017 1.6k votes 300 voters 5.0k views16 items

List RulesVote up the dark horse actresses you would love to see in the role of adult Beverly Marsh

With the announcement that It: Part 2 will be released on September 6, 2019, many fans are wondering who will play grown-up Beverly in It. Sophia Lillis’s performance as young Beverly had critics swooning, so the actress cast as older Beverly in It: Part 2 has some high standards to meet. Older Beverly, while smarter and more experienced, will have her own set of challenges and horrors to face, as Stephen King characters do. Set 27 years after the original, It: Part 2 show Beverly Marsh in her element as a fashion designer in Chicago. Unfortunately, Beverly is abused by her partner, much like she was by her father. Older Beverly, like her younger self, still has some demons (and clowns) to vanquish. The actress cast as grown-up Beverly will need to capture the balance of strength and vulnerability that Lillis so perfectly emulated. 

As if following up on a 15-year-old's outstanding performance isn't enough pressure, there are some hardcore Stephen King fans to appease as well. If these fans are going to take the time to do extreme makeup to transform themselves into Pennywise, chances are they are also waiting with bated breath to see who is cast as the story's heroine. Jessica Chastain has been open about her desire to play the older Beverly Marsh, and It producer Barbara Muschietti has stated she wants Jessica Chastain for the role of adult Beverly, so it may seem like the casting is already set. Still, there are plenty of other talented actresses - red-headed and non-redheads alike - who would be prime for the role.

  • 1
    Amy Adams
    177
    25

    Amy Adams

    Age: 41

    BirthplaceVicenza, Italy

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersKat Peterson, Merilynn, Jodi Melville, Rebecca, Katy Luke

    Not only does Amy Adams absolutely look the part, but this five-time Oscar nominee has the acting chops to pull off the meaty role of Beverly Marsh.

    More Amy Adams 

    The Best Amy Adams Movies#1 of 74 Mormon Celebrities

  • 2
    Bryce Dallas Howard

    BirthplaceLos Angeles, California, United States of America

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersRedheaded Girl in Audience, Victoria, Grace Margaret Mulligan, Fisher, Story

    Yet another redhead who looks the part, Bryce Dallas Howard has proven she has the ability to star in blockbusters with her roles in Jurassic World and the Twilight franchise.

  • 3
    Isla Fisher
    52
    52

    BirthplaceMuscat, Oman

    NationalityAustralia

    CharactersBet, Robyn Devereaux Barsby, Shannon Reed, Vanessa Walker

    As a redhead, Isla Fisher certainly looks the part. While Fisher is more known for her comedic roles, she took a dramatic turn in 2016's Nocturnal Animals. With her ability to do both comedy and drama, Fisher would make a stunning Beverly Marsh.

    More Isla Fisher 

    The Best Isla Fisher Movies#268 of 853 The Best Actresses in Film History

  • 4
    Rachel McAdams
    49
    57

    BirthplaceLondon, Canada

    NationalityCanada

    CharactersMary, Patsy, Allie Hamilton, Becky Fuller, Sally Garfield

    Rachel McAdams is famously known for her roles in Mean Girls and The Notebook, but she can go dark as well. McAdams's is much more than a simple love interest, much like It's own Beverly Marsh.

    More Rachel McAdams 

    The Best Rachel McAdams MoviesThe Best Rachel McAdams Characters of All Time

  • 5
    Emily Blunt
    40
    55

    BirthplaceRoehampton, London, United Kingdom

    NationalityEngland

    CharactersLucy Markham

    From her breakout comedic role as an overly stressed assistant in The Devil Wears Prada to an alcoholic divorcee in The Girl on the Train, Blunt has played each of her roles to a tee. There is no doubt Blunt could be a perfect fit for Beverly Marsh.

    More Emily Blunt 

    The 20+ Best Emily Blunt Movies of All Time, Ranked15 Things You Didn't Know About Emily Blunt

  • 6
    Maggie Gyllenhaal

    BirthplaceLower East Side, New York City, New York, United States of America

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersSecret Service Agent, Lorraine Thomas, Maggie Ruth, Denise Lambert, Mira

    Maggie Gyllenhaal has a nice mix of indie films like Secretary and big blockbusters like Dark Knight Rises under her belt, but she has never quite broken through the superstar barrier. Playing Beverly Marsh would finally show Gyllenhaal's enormous talent to a wider audience.

    More Maggie Gyllenhaal 

    The Best Maggie Gyllenhaal Movies#39 of 192 The Greatest Actresses Who Have Never Won an Oscar (for Acting)

  • 7
    Lauren Ambrose
    37
    58

    BirthplaceNew Haven, Connecticut, United States of America

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersMaureen McKinnon, Jessica, Valerie Maxwell

    After roles in Can't Hardly Wait and Six Feet Under, Lauren Ambrose has been flying under the radar. A return to the big screen as Beverly Marsh would remind everyone just how talented this red-headed actress truly is.

    More Lauren Ambrose 

    #229 of 465 Celebrities You Didn't Know Use Stage Names#141 of 205 Famous Boarding School Alumni

  • 8
    Christina Hendricks

    BirthplaceKnoxville, Tennessee, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America, United Kingdom

    CharactersJoyce, Rhiannon, Sarah, Rachel Gibson, Karen Archer

    Throughout Mad Men, Christina Hendricks played Joan with equal parts vulnerability and resilience. Her talent for playing layered characters would help Hendricks nail the role of Beverly Marsh.

  • 9
    Keri Russell
    20
    51

    BirthplaceFountain Valley, California, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersJessica Feeny, Camille, Melody, Jane Mathers

    Keri Russell was introduced to us as Felicity Porter, the young womqn coming into her own, in Felicity. Being that older Beverly Marsh is still a woman figuring things out, Russell is a great candidate for the role.

  • 10
    Amanda Peet
    22
    54

    BirthplaceNew York City, New York, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersJenkins, Leslie Harlan, Actress, Layle, Kathy

    Underappreciated Amanda Peet has always brought a certain fortitude to her characters. Peet also plays characters who are seemingly "one of the guys," which Beverly Marsh is in many ways.

  • 11
    Jennifer Connelly

    BirthplaceCairo, New York, United States of America

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersCatherine Miller, The Girl

    Oscar-winning Jennifer Connelly certainly has the talent to play Beverly Marsh. Connelly's poise would also play well as Beverly Marsh, as she's a successful fashion designer when she's older.

    More Jennifer Connelly 

    Whatever Happened To Jennifer Connelly?#109 of 258 The Best Marvel Movie Actors Ever

  • 12
    Katie Holmes
    22
    66

    BirthplaceToledo, Ohio, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersGrace Fuller

    The world met Katie Holmes when she played the girl next door Joey Potter in Dawson's Creek. Bringing this same girl-next-door quality, Holmes could truly encapsulate that certain accessible side of Beverly Marsh. Also, isn't it about time Katie Holmes made a comeback?

  • 13
    Jennifer Garner
    17
    58

    BirthplaceHouston, Texas, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersBillie H. Vaughn, Romy Sullivan, Nell, Jaime, Sydney Bristow

    No one does girl next door quite like Jennifer Garner, but she can be gritty, too, like her characters in Alias and Daredevil. Seeing an empowered Garner take down Pennywise would be quite the thrill for audiences.

  • 14
    Leslie Mann
    14
    51

    BirthplaceSan Francisco, California, USA

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersMiss Foote

    Considering just how much humor was in It, one can only assume the sequel will also being laughs along with the screams. That said, Leslie Mann's ability to flip from comedy to drama may serve Beverly Marsh well.

    More Leslie Mann 

    #57 of 282 The Funniest Female Comedians of All Time#136 of 201 Famous Women You'd Want to Have a Beer With

  • 15
    Vera Farmiga
    14
    52

    BirthplaceClifton, New Jersey, United States of America

    NationalityUnited States of America

    CharactersLindsay Carson

    Starring in The Conjuring franchise, Vera Farmiga is a horror movie pro. On top of that, this Oscar-nominated actress has that certain wise old soul vibe that young Beverly Marsh definitely had in It.

    More Vera Farmiga 

    #81 of 252 The Best Actresses Working Today#933 of 1,883 The Greatest Actors & Actresses in Entertainment History

  • 16
    Kate Winslet
    12
    117

    BirthplaceReading, United Kingdom

    NationalityUnited Kingdom,England

    CharactersMildred Pierce

    Oscar-winner Kate Winslet is no stranger to playing layered, complicated female characters. Considered one of the best actresses of her generation, there's no doubt Winslet would be able to play Beverly Marsh perfectly, as long as she goes back to her red locks she rocked in Titanic.

    More Kate Winslet 

    Kate Winslet Broke Tom Cruise's Record With Crazy 'Avatar 2' StuntThe Greatest Characters Played by Kate Winslet, Ranked