Celebrity Facts

15 Celebrity Cheaters Who Later Got Cheated On  

Evan Lambert
506.8k views 15 items

When celebrities cheat on each other, the world knows. As a drama-loving society, we've followed the stories of celebrity cheaters and celebrities who were cheated on, so it only felt natural to compile a list of celebrities who fall into both categories. Nothing beats the schadenfreude of those celebrity cheating scandals in which a cheater gets his or her comeuppance. All of the stories on this list involve some sort of karmic retribution in the form of a sexual indiscretion.

Some jilted lovers on this list decided to get back at their cheating partners themselves, whereas others had to wait for karma to work its magic. Some of these souls even watched as their partners got back with the fools they originally cheated on together. That's some Circle of Life nonsense right there. 

Is cheating a terrible crime or a magical road to true love? Click through this list of celebrity cheaters who later got cheated on and discuss! 

Jennifer Lopez is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 15 Celebrity Cheaters Who Later Got Cheated On
Photo:  Flickr/Warner Bros.

The saga of Bennifer began just as it ended: in ignominy. In 2001, the world folded in on itself when J-Lo broke up with hubby Cris Judd only to start dating Ben Affleck. Fifteen years later, J-Lo seemed to get her just desserts when a slightly different handsome backup dancer, Casper Smart, cheated on her.

More Jennifer Lopez

#55 of 455 The Greatest Singers of the Past 30 Yearsfeaturing The Best Jennifer Lopez Songslisted on Musical Guests of the Jay Leno Show

Jessica Simpson is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 15 Celebrity Cheaters Who Later Got Cheated On
Photo:  Newlyweds

Jessica Simpson remained a virgin until her wedding night with Nick Lachey, but didn't wait long afterwards before becoming a full-fledged sex maniac. Jackass star Bam Margera confirmed on Howard Stern's radio show in 2006 that he and Simpson had hooked up while Simpson was still with Lachey. She is also rumored to have hooked up with Johnny Knoxville and Adam Levine while she was still with Lachey.

Six years later, Simpson's second husband, Eric Johnson, was embroiled in a cheating scandal of his own - with his ex-wife Keri. Some sources also claim that he disappeared into some bushes with their nanny for two hours. Drama!

More Jessica Simpson

#62 of 231 The Greatest New Female Vocalists of the Past 10 Yearsfeaturing What The Heck Happened To Jessica Simpson?listed on Actors You May Not Have Realized Are Republican

Frank Sinatra is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 15 Celebrity Cheaters Who Later Got Cheated On
Photo: Sunset Boulevard/Corbis Historical

In Frank Sinatra's heyday, he could have any woman he wanted - and he did, even while he was married to wife Nancy Sinatra. It seemed he'd turned a new leaf once he'd met his one great love, Ava Gardner, but he never predicted that he could be the one cheated on. After confiding to friends that Sinatra could no longer satisfy her sexually, Gardner ran off with a bullfighter. 

More Frank Sinatra

#41 of 283 Musicians Who Belong in the Rock and Roll Hall of Famefeaturing The Best Frank Sinatra Songs of All Timelisted on Actors You May Not Have Realized Are Republican

David Duchovny is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 15 Celebrity Cheaters Who Later Got Cheated On
Photo:  Frazer Harrison/Getty Images

Despite forcing wife Téa Leoni to put up with his sex addiction for years, Californication actor Duchovny divorced Leoni after a brief affair she had with Billy Bob Thornton. 

More David Duchovny

#212 of 337 The Coolest Actors Ever #1,335 of 2,831 The Most Influential People of All Time #84 of 505 The Best TV Actors of All Time