Graveyard Shift

Overused Jump Scare Tropes That Worked Once But Now Need To Be Banned From Horror Movies  

Jacob Shelton
911 votes 181 voters 10.3k views 13 items

List Rules Vote up the jump scares that should look before they leap.

No cinematic technique receives as much criticism or derision as the jump scare, a trope used to get a quick rise out of an audience in a horror film. Jump scares are frequently pointed to when discussing why horror films aren't what they used to be, but a well-placed jump scare can keep an audience on its toes. When used correctly, a jump scare can be a horror film's most effective technique - a notable example being the final scene of Carrie.

That said, more cheap jump scares exist than good jump scares, and this list provides a rundown of the most egregious examples. In many cases, predictability plays against a jump scare, especially when an audience already saw the scare in an earlier film. On other occasions, a jump scare simply doesn't make sense - what friend grabs your shoulder without announcing themselves first?

Certain jump scare tropes show up regularly, and their best and worst uses appear here. Remember, a jump scare works like a hammer - it’s only as effective as the person using it. Unfortunately, not every director wields their tools with grace. 

1
The Best Friend
The Best Friend is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Overused Jump Scare Tropes That Worked Once But Now Need To Be Banned From Horror Movies
Photo:  Shaun of the Dead/Universal Pictures

AKA: The Fake-Out, OH HELLO!

You Know The One: This jump scare turns up in numerous films and arrives in a variety of permutations. Maybe your protagonist just escaped a masked killer early in the first act, and as they round a corner, BOOM, they run into their best friend. Or someone jumps out of the side of the frame like they're going to attack the protagonist, but it's just a friend barreling at them to say "hi," because that's totally what normal people do. Why is your protagonist friends with people like this? Maybe the protagonist should make new friends after they're killed off one-by-one. This also shows up as a shoulder grab, but that's usually committed by an authority figure/red herring. 

The Scariest: Scream definitely isn't the first slasher film to use this jump scare, but by commenting on the trope, Wes Craven infuses it with more meaning. For instance, when Billy jump-scares Sidney, it's meaningful because he's the killer. Another great subversion of this trope happens in Shaun of the Dead when Pete continually pops up prior to being turned into a zombie.

The Most Played Out: The fake-out takes up most of the runtime of every slasher movie set at a summer camp - Friday the 13th, The Burning, Madman. In these movies, either someone tells a story, and then the prankster camper pops up wearing a mask, or the protagonist walks through the woods and gets scared by another camper. You also see this scare a couple of times in The Prowler each time Pam barely escapes the masked killer. 

Is this a cheap trick?
2
Smash Cut To Titles
Smash Cut To Titles is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Overused Jump Scare Tropes That Worked Once But Now Need To Be Banned From Horror Movies
Photo:  Funny Games/Warner Independent Pictures

AKA: TITLES! Typography-phobia!

You Know The One: You're just hanging out and watching a movie, and then holy sh*t, it's the titles.

The Scariest: A lot of modern horror films use jump scare titles, but the best uses of this trope occur within Funny Games - a film so antagonistic that you'll long for a jump scare; and Cabin in the Woods, a movie that's riffing on horror tropes while gleefully playing into them. 

The Rest: There really aren't any movies that screw this trope up in any major way, but it's more like the filmmakers mistimed their titles. Turkish what-the-f*ck fest Baskin uses a jump scare title at the end, but audiences are so emotionally drained by then that it feels like a waste of effort. The Insidious series uses these, too, and while the first film does it well, the audience is ready for the jump by the third entry in the series.

Is this a cheap trick?
3
The Diagetic Jump Scare
The Diagetic Jump Scare is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Overused Jump Scare Tropes That Worked Once But Now Need To Be Banned From Horror Movies
Photo:  The Innkeepers/Magnolia Pictures

AKA: Knock Knock! 

You Know The One: This scare is basically just a loud sound that happens when the protagonist focuses on something creepy. The noise typically comes from someone knocking on a door or a phone ringing. Couple this with the best friend just stopping by to say hello, and you've got a horror stew going. 

The Scariest: The Innkeepers isn't the first film to use this jump scare by a long shot, but it's one of the best. This Ti West flick uses sound to construct an atmosphere and freak out the audience, and the director makes excellent use of everyday noises cranked up in the mix to deliver tangible scares. The most obvious version of this trope occurs when Claire looks at spooky footage on a computer and the hotel's phone rings. It sounds ridiculous, but it's great. Another great addition to this trope is the "hide and clap" scene from The Conjuring. Have fun watching that movie and trying to go into a basement ever again. 

The Most Played Out: One Missed Call immediately comes to mind with discussing this trope. This is a movie predicated on the idea that audiences can get spooked by a ringtone, and it just doesn't work - especially after 90 minutes. 

Is this a cheap trick?
4
The Scary Face
The Scary Face is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Overused Jump Scare Tropes That Worked Once But Now Need To Be Banned From Horror Movies
Photo:  Fright Night/Columbia Pictures

AKA: Nightmare Face, The Scare Only A Mother Could Love

You Know The One: Out of all the jump scares that have ever scared, this remains the trope that horror movies milk the most. Basically, the scare involves suddenly showing the audience a super creepy face. There are a million ways to do it, and obviously, some films do it more effectively than others. 

The Scariest: Two of the first Nightmare Face jump scares come from the French. The first appears in Jean Cocteau's Beauty and the Beast from 1946. While not a horror movie, it does play by the rules of horror when the Beast is first introduced and his ugly mug pops up right in the middle of the screen. Thirteen years later, the genre-defining classic Eyes Without a Face forced audiences to look at a woman whose skin is ripped off in a car accident.

European cinema really gets the spooky face jump scare - specifically, Suspiria, which has one of the best Scary Face jump scares of all time. It occurs at the end of the film when Suzy finds Helena Markos in her room. The body of her friend Sara comes to life and tries to kill her, but not before director Dario Argento hits the audience with one of the creepiest faces ever. Other great versions of this scare include when Amy reveals herself to be a vampire in Fright Night, and the dream sequence in An American Werewolf in London

The Most Played Out: The worst versions of this trope exist because directors put no thought into the faces they put on screen, which means the audience ends up looking at weird, black-eyed, stretched faces like in Hellraiser: Inferno, or both of the entries in the Grave Encounters franchise. 

Is this a cheap trick?